Share

Prof. Tonči Kuzmanić, Faculty of Management, Koper/Capodistria University of Primorska, Slovenia

“You are what you is,

that is what it is!”

Frank Zappa

Summary:

The aim of the paper is to reopen the problem of Capitalism from two perspectives. Firstly – and only formally – the aim is to tackle the problem from the perspective of “language games”. Within this kind of Wittgensteinian argumentation the connection between the »name« (capitalism) and the “thing” (to pragma) is of paramount importance. Emphasis of the paper at that level is twofold: firstly, to show that capitalism is not a “thing”. The-real-thing one should try to think and grasp is the endless quantity of language games about Capitalism. More precisely, the emphasis is not to be put on a “thing” but on something which is not at all “ordinary”, let alone “natural language”. Quite the contrary: the language which is the problem is the language of today's (post-modern) social sciences itself. If today we speak about Capitalism (as The-thing) and of “its crisis” from that perspective, we are not able to tackle the enormous existing problems at all. Rather, we just collect endless quantity of empty statements (including the responsibility for the existing mess).

Second and in a way “more concrete” perspective is the historical one. The paper will reopen the problem of the “Big depression” and try to show that the capitalism, as we usually understand it, already evaporated in the thirties and forties of the 20th century. The aim of this part of the paper is to show that the post-capitalism (“managerial revolution” not only in the sense of Burnham, but above all in that of F. D. Roosevelt) has actually already defeated capitalism (but not its language games!) in two various ways. Firstly, from within (USA, Great Britain…) and simultaneously from the outside (soviet Russia, fascist Italy, Nazi Germany…). In this part of the paper I strongly emphasise the revolutionary and irreversible “self-change” within the field of property relations, the role of the government (not the state!), and the management of entire society (“Big-society”). The central thesis of the paper is that without serious re-thinking of the irreversible revolutionary (!) changes from the thirties and forties we cannot understand today’s “globalisation” and “global crisis” and are literary doomed to failure in thinking of today’s “global society”.

Key words: post-capitalism, Capitalism, death of capitalism, “language games”, depression, economy, “managerial revolution”, “Big Society”.

1. Methodological remark

This is not an easy readable text, let alone the text of amusement based on post-modern bric-a-brac forms of rhetorical entertainment. Due to the complex macro objective I try to tackle, I tried to be as simple and as clear as possible. Firstly, I tried to escape all technicalities of citations and larger use of body literature in the sense of bringing the proof into the text from the outside. I am of the opinion that text has to stand as its own proof: it must rest in and simultaneously on itself. Alternatively, I offer some of the most important elements and units of outstanding (“classical”) literature used for the paper at its end (bibliography). Secondly, I also tried to develop simple wording in the sense of repeating the simplest possible forms of language regardless the style and possible rhetorical attraction contained in it. In this regard I followed two authors who are in my opinion worth of admiration: Aristotle and Wittgenstein. My aim was not to construct anything beautiful and amusing, let alone the splendour but rather something as accurate as possible in the form of Wittgesnteinian “apodictic” sentences. The argument is mainly carried out through frequent repetitions of fussed sentences causing minimum of diverse possible meanings at the level of the language games and understandings. The intention is a reduction through consistency of saying regardless the scholarly effects, which occasionally drives the argument to the edge of simplicity, and could operate as bored. The texts I prefer are not the terrain of the artistic fire-works aerobics, neither are they of moral or “works of love”, being predominant in today’s post-modern academic rhetoric. Accordingly, the price that one has to pay for achieving such kind of “apodictic execution” is the style. Execution of the present text is thus aiming at almost mathematical borders of the exactness itself. Namely, today’s bric-a-brac post-structuralist deconstructive exhibitionism cannot compete with the contemporary economical (already managerialised!) meta-language being the core of the problem. A real battle needs almost absolutely exact and precise forms of thinking and arguing, already at the very level of opening the elementary logical forms of existing problems.

2. Capitalist language games

Within the proposed kind of Wittgensteinian perspective of thinking the argumentation about the connection between the »name«, Capitalism in our case, and the “reality”, “thing” (gr. to pragma, ger. das Ding) is of the pivotal importance. The perspective within which the concentration is both on the epistemological and ontological problems of “being” (gr. to on) and speech/speaking (gr. logisthai and not language) is the Aristotelian and not Plato’s. More precisely, the point here is not either “name” or “thing” perspective, but something completely different, firstly developed in Aristotele’s Peri hermeneias (De Interpretatione, On Interpretation).

This perspective of thinking (dianoia and not gnosis) is dealing with something very basic, namely with the factum that the “being itself” is not a Thing. It is rather some-thing that is at least two fold if not many fold in “its meaning”. Saying in “its meaning” already stands for the language “use” and numerous possible “language games”. To put it in a more simple way, when one speaks about Capitalism as a “thing” for example, and tries to ask the question of what-capitalism-is, he or she always somehow “in advance forgets” the fundamental problem of the “being-of-capitalism”, as Heidegger used to express this with regard to Being (Sein). In a very strange way we a priori “forget” even to take into account the fact that capitalism “is” (if it is at all!). To put it in more existentialist form, instead of re-thinking the very existence of capitalism (namely, that(if)-it-is), we automatically presuppose its very existence, as if capitalism were something natural, a self-understandable or God-given Thing. In such a way capitalism suddenly becomes naturalised, unquestionable and out of our thinking abilities as such. The central point in this context is exactly that which should be presented and even proven in its very existence (“that-it-is”), and this – in some magic (post-religious) way of not-thinking – starts to function (in our own language games) as that-unquestionable. In such kind of thoughtless methodological procedure – exactly that is the machinery of gnosis on which all social sciences are still based – a certain Thing (for example Capitalism in our case) is appearing as always already (a priori) proven and even existing from always, so to speak from “the beginning of time”, as well as for ever. Precisely on the basis of such void and completely unquestionable presumption of “the existence of capitalism”, we then – instead of posing the necessary question about that what is supposed “to be”, and thus instead of targeting the very existence of capitalism – comfortably and even “scientifically” start to ask the relaxed question about What-capitalism-is. The tragedy of such non-position of today’s thoughtless (Arendt), and at the same time highly rhetorically developed social sciences is that there is no bigger logical and argumentative mistake which can be made in the realm of thinking, and it thus represents The-Mistake of all mistakes.

My main aim in this paper is to redirect the question of What-is-Capitalism towards the rethinking of Capitalism at the level of its own existence (If-it-is-capitalism), which today means at the level of the questioning scientific meta-language games. To put it differently, the aim is not any kind of “critique of capitalism”, since capitalism was already very profoundly criticized: not only by authors such as Karl Marx and others “in theory”, but also by actors such as F. D. Roosevelt and its team “in practice” (second part of the paper). The thesis of the paper is twofold: firstly, that the capitalism “as reality of our economical, social and political life” already evaporated in the thirties and forties of the previous century (New Deal). And secondly – the key point – that that which remains of it and even expands its own existence is a vast body of appearance of Capitalisms as language games in which Capitalism itself is hyper-produced. That hyper-production, a kind of overall mumbling, is what I call meta-language of Capitalism and which can also be called “economic”, or better, “social scientific fundamentalism” subsisting at the very core of all our post-modern debates and problems. In these meta-language games the non-Thing (of Capitalism) operates similarly as in religions, ideologies and related phenomena: the more the “God is dead”, the more religious appears the fundamentalist argumentation originating from it.

a) The very use of Capitalist-language games is our Reality

The given problem can be schematised in a more empirical and even political way: the so-called Left and Right are here and now endlessly “arguing” about Capitalism. But how?! Naturally, the right is “for capitalism”, and the left is, of course, “against it”. Similarly as couple of centuries ago when the “right” was “for God” (Angels, Demons...), and the “left” was “against it”. Of the central importance for us here is not either-or, Left-or-Right... perspective and matrix, but the very brutal factum that Right and Left are speaking literary the same language, that both are revolving around the same epicentre – that of Capitalism. Exactly this common-language of both sides (either-or, pro & contra...) is the Problem to be opened.

The task here is to go beyond the presented either-or Capitalist rhetoric, or better, to escape the kingdom of Capitalist either-or thoughtless persisting in the Heavens of meta-language of Capitalism. Consequently, the real problem is how to re-open the problem of language games of Capitalism, and, with this, a widespread ground of its own functioning, that which Right and Left have in common. Or to put it in a more precise question, how to show the common ground of all sides which in the conflict are targeting the would-be-Capitalistic quasi reality? I shall repeat the decisive emphasis: the problem is neither the Thing (Capitalism) nor it is its Name (singular). The problem is the plurality of meta-language games we are using (we are used by) about Capitalism. Exactly that plurality of use of Capitalism-language games, spoken from all sides of today’s academy and media, is The-Thing which is producing the quasi “reality of capitalism” as its own result, or, better, which is The-Reality of Capitalism itself.

My perspective is to show that this kind of would-be-Capitalism is not any kind of “Thing”, but is our virtual and scientific reality in which we are imprisoned, and this is something completely different than any ”thing” else. We are not living only in the midst of the “reality of things” (as it could look like from the post-religious perspective of today’s highly mediated social sciences), but in the midst of the reality of (Capitalist) meta-language games. They are our “real virtual”, at the same time presupposing and transcending all technics and technologies of what is usually understood as the virtual space and virtual reality. The-real-thing one should try to think and grasp is thus the endless quantity and usages of language games mumbling about Capitalism. More precisely, the emphasis should not be put on a “thing” (to pragma – something from which all pragmatisms, materialisms, empiricisms necessary begin!) but on something which is not at all “ordinary”, let alone “natural” language. In fact, the language which is The-problem is the language of all today's (post-modern) social sciences themselves, which are endlessly mumbling about Capitalism. This should be grasped as a highly problematical meta-language which desperately needs rethinking and understanding.

b) Right-Left binary quasi differences

How to pose the problem of the existing Right and Left (Capitalist) meta-language games? Or, better, how to “open” the total closure produced by Left and Right (wing) mumbling about Capitalism? Quite simply! One of the important questions from which it is possible to start (an Aristotelian) “procedure” of thinking, is the perspective of the cause/s (arhe-in, arhai). Of course not of the causes in the sense of “the Thing” (that would be Plato’s direction leading to more or less absolute knowledge of gnosis), but to try to think about the causes which enable the very movement and articulation of the Capitalist meta-language games and of quasi descriptions that automatically follow from them.

Without a serious possibility of a mistake is it possible to argue that there are basically two fundamental, highly important “families” and “grammars” (Wittgenstein) of capitalist language games in the sense of their causes and – based on that causes – of all their quasi descriptions which are they able to produce. First of them is “Nature”, and the second is “History”. To put in the simplest way – the quasi argument in “Right” Capitalist language games (today’s neo-liberalism, neo-conservatism...) is as simple as possible: “capitalism-is-natural”! That “means” that the previous sentence (actually “command” – Wittgenstein) should be read and grasped in a more profoundly and fundamental way as: “Capitalism =/”is” the same as nature”! The “opposite” is also “possible”: “nature =/”is” the same as Capitalism”! This kind of (tautological) language games is still caught in middle ages’ theological (scholastic) distinctions dealing with “Substance” grasped as One (sing.), God’s-Thing and accidences (pl.) of human-things. The “situation” in this scholastic matrix is in the last instance the following: to say “Nature” means to say “unchangeable” and simultaneously “out of time”, and even “before time”. Fixation on the Un-changeable grammar is The-argument in the sense of The-Thing with which one has to deal within this matrix of language games which are based on the quasi argument of “Nature”.

The Left argumentation starts from the second chain of causes in which (neo-socialism, neo-communism...) the main quasi argument is History. History is here just another name for “Change” being substantialised, fundamentalised and absolutised as God in scholastics. In this type of language games the matrix of argument is slightly different than in that based on Nature. The-Thing here is not Capitalism as such – which means as substantive – but puts “capitalistic” in the sense of the adjective. Here the substantive is something like a perpetuum mobile of (self)changing-society (self/changing-production, self/changing-economy...). With regard to this something which is “fixed”, “capitalistic” is in the position of the “accidence” (adjective). That which is fixed in the Left “discourse”, is – in last analysis – always the same: self-changing Progress in the sense of the endless Change, representing the same as in theology: namely, the Infinity itself (fairy tales about endless Progress of “productive forces”, of “liberalisation”, of “freedom” and even “democracy”).

c) Commonality and community of Right and Left language games

The result of both sides (Right and Left) is not philosophical but rather rhetorical matrix of the language games about Capitalism. The point which I would like to emphasise here – of course in order to re-open the exit out of the thoughtless matrix – is the following: it is not important what, why, when and how Right (wing) or Left (wing) of the Capitalist meta-language games is or are arguing. That which counts is the common result of the language games in the sense of blocking our very possibility of thinking, understanding, reasoning, and acting when we are trapped within them.

Moreover, I should especially underline that “we” of today are not only trapped in one of the mentioned language games (Left or Right). The fact that we could be – and usually are – trapped in one of them is, so to speak, only one, even less important side of the problem. The most important “thing”, the Real-Problem and Real-Thing itself lies in that which is beyond the possibility of being trapped in one of them (Left or Right). We are namely even more trapped in “both” of them. But by saying “in both of them” I only signal something else. This additional problem is even “more dangerous” and it is located in something which can be described as the community and commonality of both Left and Right at once, namely their common (Capitalist) meta-language itself. More precisely, Capitalist meta-language games are neither left nor Right but are simultaneously Left AND Right!

d) The “Third element” of endless usage of Capitalist meta-language

If we accept the “naturalness” and “realness”, objectiveness included, of the above schematically described capitalist language games, then the only remaining way of “change” is to change the alleged “inner side” of Capitalism. We are “free” (and that is our entire “freedom”) to choose either Left or Right quasi-position of quasi argumentation. This means that in our quasi freedom we are jailed in a beautiful circulus vitiosus midst which we are endlessly “looking” for the “solution” of the circle’s square. In such (“given”) circumstances it is per detinitionem not possible to break through the “glass ceiling”, let alone to seriously think about the community and commonality of “both” quasi argumentative sides (Left and Right). What needs the strongest possible emphasis here is the fact that the Capitalist meta-language games are not at all made only of One or of Two “parts” or “sides”, as it looks like. It rather appears as something infinite in its usages.

The-Real-problem here is thus not the choosing between “one or another” (Left of Right). The proper location and place (topos) of our problem is exactly that the “OR” itself should be grasped and “translated” as “AND”! The result of such understanding (and change) of OR into AND could be the following: Left AND Right “argumentations” are of course exclusive (Left is exclusive towards Right and vice versa) but they are not at all excluding each other as it appear to the ordinary audience being trapped midst the media discourses of Capitalism. The opposite is the case: Right AND Left are – as far as meta-language of Capitalism is concerned – actually two complementary positions. Together – and only together – they very successfully produce a commonality and simultaneously something “Third” and superior with regard to both of them. That “Third”, resulting out of the exclusivity (but not out of exclusion!) of Left and Right, is the common Master to both of them.

This “Third” is an ultra-important element of the matrix of Capitalist meta-language games, functioning at the higher (or, at least, different) level with regard to both, Left and Right. Moreover, the “Third element” with regard to the relationship “between” Left and Right is neither “one” of the already existing Left and Right sides, nor it is the “third side” (that is the reason why it is “invisible”). It word for word transcends – in Hegelian manner of Aufhebung - both sides (Right and Left) and any “side”. “Transcends” here means the ability to “produce” always the new and completely unexpected results. But why and how is that possible? It is possible mainly due to the endless appearance of the infinite chain of empty mumbling about Capitalism published in books, reviews, being at work in the air, on the radio or TV, and in other “virtual” transmissions, capturing the global audiences. This “liquid” (mediated) form of the Capitalist meta-language quasi-spoken from all walks of life is disseminated in a total and totalitarian way. It is disseminated from the top of all media and from two additional “sides”, but these are neither Left nor Right side. These two additional “sides” are, firstly, “from everywhere”, and, secondly, “from Nowhere”, thus at same time from everywhere & nowhere, since that is the definition of the “media virtual space”.

In sum, our target here is not the Right or Left form of the Capitalist meta-language games, but by the media disseminated entirety, totality of its being, appearing as something totally “natural”, “neutral” and even “objective” (“real”...), and thus dislocated into the mystical areas of unthinkable and even “natural”. This entirety covered by the mist of today’s media coverage and produced in the post-modern academy – mainly in social sciences – is the Third, “invisible element” we were looking for.

The problem from my point of view is how to challenge this naturalised, absolutistic, within totality of media enclosed Capitalist self-picture of meta-language? My attempt goes towards rethinking of the completely forgotten and silent – but powerful and extremely successful – revolution of capitalism itself, that happened in the USA of the thirties. With regard to the first and abstract part of the text the task of the second is to put some “real flesh” on the already schematised bones about the language games of Capitalism.

3. Historical perspective: not of Capitalism but of capitalist evaporation – New Deal

The core thesis of the second part of the paper is that capitalism is dead for approximately three quarters of century. This, however, does not mean that Capitalism in the sense of its language games did not survive its “real death”. Quite the contrary is the case. The language games of Capitalism persist its own divine, “endless” life to which I will try to pose certain limits (horisomai). Thus the aim of the second part of the paper is to reopen the minimal possibility of re-thinking of the problem of how the “managerial revolution” defeated capitalism within its own language and installed post-capitalism. The target is also to show how Capitalist language games still survive and persist exactly on the “basis” of missing “real capitalism”.

The beginning of the “practices” of dissolution of capitalism took place around the years of the “Big depression”. These revolutionary events are still less analysed and sometimes even systematically forgotten. Forgetting this extraordinary revolution is mainly the result of highly ideological and militarised forms of “our” own (Western) thinking, circling mainly around the economical meta-language of Capitalism. In this kind of fundamental ideological surrounding we are able only to “see” the Things of “revolutions” (Russian, Fascist, National-socialist...) and wars (First and Second World War...). My point here is that the global managerial revolution of capitalism took place/s (pl.!) in at least two various ways, forms and also locations. Firstly, they took place from “within” the already highly developed form of capitalism (in the USA) of the thirties, and simultaneously from the “outside” in the sense of the changes of underdeveloped forms of capitalisms (soviet Russia, fascist Italy, Nazi Germany…).

Both kinds of managerial revolutions of capitalism after WW II merged into the global post-capitalist (and not any more capitalist!) post-modern ultra-development which is The-Thing being today in a Great depression. What is in depression today is not at all capitalism of the Great depression, since the Great depression was the end of capitalism itself. The Big depression is just another name for the end-of-capitalism, and the managerial revolution from these days was the way out of capitalist surrounding into something which I am defining as post-capitalism. Today’s Great depression is the depression of immensely more complicated and complex post-capitalist society and not any more that of the “good old” capitalism which evaporated in the depression of the thirties. As far as Capitalism (not capitalism) is concerned, it is besieged by a Great desperation of the existing meta-languages, especially of the fundamental economical one which unfortunately still controls our gaze by covering the horizons and hiding away both: any kind of possibility and perspective.

a) Total revolutions of society and not only of economy

Of course all this is not at all something which is possible to think and grasp – let alone to accept – within the predominant meta-language games of economy (social sciences included, since the meta-language of economy is the “basis” for their thoughtlessness as well). In this second part I will try to speak a kind of a more historical, empirical, and less formal form of speech while dealing with two crucial “aspects” of the “real” capitalism and not of Capitalism of today’s meta-language of economy and social sciences. The emphasis will be on problems of property and will also concern the problem of society in the largest sense. Let me start with the second one, since it is far more complex problem.

The mentioned fundamental and global changes whose appearance is possible to locate in time between two World Wars did not mark the change of this or that part of capitalism, of this or that of its sub-systems. Instead, it was the fundamental change of capitalism itself, of the capitalist system, the change of its whole, challenging its fundamental principles. This was thus not a change “in economy”, it was not a revolution “in technology”, but the change of the entire society as such, its leadership above all. In Europe (also in Japan and elsewhere) this was a quite visible alteration, even though the very long chain of similar changes happened all around the (capitalist development) globe. More precisely, it was the Change of all changes. Socialist (1917), Fascist (1922) and Nazi (1933) revolutions challenged not this or that part of “their” society of the day (being already in deep crisis due to the World War I), but literary attacked the very society itself in the sense of its own fundamental principles (“capitalistic” included). All these visible revolutions – more or less proceeding from some kind of “connection” with the WW I – targeted the existing society in its entirety, in its foundations, main principles included. The aims of all these revolutions were without any exception simple, but this ultimate premise is not recognised yet, let alone incorporated in our common thinking and understanding. Instead, it is still trapped into the superficially economical meta-language of the ancient capitalist from XIX. century mumbling about “the economy”. The aim of all these revolutions was – even at the level of the declarations and published legal documents (not to mention numerous books from that time) – exactly “New Society”. Moreover, the purpose was to produce the “New man”, sometimes even explicitly posed as the Übermensch. Only if we start to think these buried events from the perspective of totality (all three mentioned revolutions still “bear” the name of totalitarianism) in the sense of the total change (revolution) of the System as such, it becomes possible to grasp the fundamental “spirit” of these years and decades. Emphasis here is on the System as such, and not on the change of any kind of partiality be it economy or anything else. Of course, all these revolutions and their leaders also talked about the “changing of economy”, about the “change of this or that” part of society (changes in sub-systems), but the fundamental emphasis was One and the same: the total revolution of the System as such.

Only while keeping in mind the “desire for totality” and starting exactly from that totality as the “regulative idea” of these revolutions, it is possible to work out and maybe to comprehend – the historical magnitude of these global (!) events. The entire late modern history of the “developed West” cannot offer anything comparable to these total revolutions and events. There are no similar, parallel events in the whole late history of the Western (global humanity included) society. Today’s “Arab revolutions” are probably of the similar magnitude, but this is rather another question and problem. Meanwhile, the highly celebrated and mystified quasi Big revolutions of the ’68 were – in comparison with these events – childish games presented to the already infantilised audience by the media and propaganda.

b) Big Society & small society

Where to start from the understanding the problem? From the Big depression! But how? Simply asking in genitive (genesis/genesthai method in Aristotle’s terminology): Big depression of what? The answer is: the point was not the Big depression of economy as it was and still is falsely presented in connection with our own today’s fundamental depression of society. It was the case of the Big depression of the entire society, of its deepest (capitalist!) foundations, principles and causes (gr. stoicheion & arhein). It was a total depression of capitalist society, and exactly that was the reason for the appearance of the phrase Big (society) and its “family” (Wittgenstein) of language games which we have to try to understand.

Firstly, how to comprehend “Big”, what was that “Big”? The “Great”, “Big” was not anything in the sense of quantitative “Big thing” only. It was a qualitative Big in the sense of something completely, revolutionary New, of something which was not seen ever before. In order to grasp the main point in the “family” of language games about “Big” we should get rid of the “déjà-vu” matrix which is the main obstacle in thinking of “New”. Otherwise we are forced to make the very elementary (logical included) mistake of reductio ad absurdum and translate everything that-is-new into something “already seen”, that already “had been”. That form of logical mistake at the level of conclusions is going extremely well together with the mentioned meta-language of economy, with the neo-theological mumbling and void rhetorical argumentations “based” on “Nature”, “Un-changeable”, etc. To put it in Wittgensteinian way, only the perspective of not confounding “quantitative” Big (in terms of mathematics and statistics, for example) with “qualitative” Big (for example in the sense of philosophy) language games, opens the chance for understanding the next two very important notions from these important years: that of “New Deal” and of “Big Society” itself.

F. D. Roosevelt was the first who spoke about the New Deal in political and not just economic terms, as he won the elections on the political platform of the language game which applied to the notion of “Big”. Why? The reason was that in the circumstances of the Big depression the Old Deal (capitalist society) was not functioning and was not possible any more. New Deal was not Roosevelt’s pre-ordered and planned enterprise – it was not violent revolution in European sense of party revolutionaries – but it was rather something into which he was forced. In the circumstances of the USA the force and violence were not primarily on the side of the party revolutionaries subjectively producing revolutionary violence, but it was rather on the side of the Old (capitalist!) System itself! Roosevelt and USA, grasped as system’s totality, were forced by the given events and circumstances such as hunger, unemployment, threat of Left and Right revolutions (in European sense from the beginning of the 20th century), and dissolution/implosion of the entire capitalist society. New Deal was so to speak an emergency exit through which the USA, leaning exactly on the New Deal itself as a New Method of building the New society, were able to escape the existing capitalist trap of depression. Capitalist trap? Of course! It was a capitalist trap which captured the entire (capitalist!) society within a definite dead end! How is it possible to explain this most important point? Only outside of the dominant meta-language of today’s economy: Roosevelt’s argumentation was not at all revolving around economy (for example for or against capitalism, for or against productivity and efficiency...). It was – nothing else was possible – spoken out mostly in terms of entire society, trapped and self-blocked within the capitalist dead end. Of “entire society”? Definitely! If it were not the entirety of society under the threat, it would not be at all possible to generate exceptionally important revolutionary concept, opening the possibility of entirely new, Big Society.

What were political and rhetorical functions of the “Big Society” at the level of language games of that time? There is no doubt that Big Society was the key concept that was critically targeting its opposite. Moreover, Big Society was the powerful device for opening the prospects for tens of millions of workers and farmers who supported the president. One should thus ask about the reason (arhein) of the application of the very term “Big Society” and its family of language games? The term was functioning as completely New revolutionary language game targeting something of the highest importance. The problem here is that exactly the most important thing, it’s opposite (opposite of “Big Society”), was not even mentioned and functioned chiefly as an “invisible-No-Thing”. This invisible could and should be termed as “small society”, without any prospect of making a mistake. In order to grasp the full “meaning” of the “Big Society”, its role in the language games of the time, we should first of all discuss the problem of its opposite, of the “small society”.

What was “small society”? The answer: everything concerning the “Old society” (capitalist society), not desired and not possible any more, which came into a dead end exactly with the “Big depression”. But why would one employ the name “small” (society) in order to understand the proper meaning of “Big Society”? The reason is again quite simple: the New Deal was presented as literally The-Deal-For-All: for ordinary people (workers, farmers, intellectuals, whites, blacks, even foreigners...) and not only for “the few” (as Roosevelt used to speak of it). Finally, the main point of distinction between “Big” and “small” in the dominant family of society language games of those terrible days was radical and revolutionary (all conservatives immediately realised the dangerous revolutionary potentials of Roosevelt’s position). New Deal was articulated in terms of inclusiveness and not exclusiveness, to put it in another, today probably more understandable perspective.

Synthetically speaking, Roosevelt’s “New Deal” grasped as Big Society’s revolution was not “violent revolution” against something (as it was the case in Europe in all above mentioned revolutions) but silent revolution “for something”. That “for something” – and not against (for example “against capitalism”) – was and remains the Big Society itself as a kind of a “positive new project”, to put it in today’s managerial parlance. The “Big” here – within the societal language games – meant primarily inclusiveness or the Society for all the USA inhabitants (L. Johnson was repeating the Big Society language games in times of Vietnam war, racist conflicts in the South, and the same is – in vain, of course – trying to do B. Obama today).

c) Silent and forgotten total societal revolution of inclusion

Who and what was the target of Big Society and the New Deal? Abstract answer is already given: small society was the target, and the old deal was the target. But that is only one, less important side of the highly important coin. The question needed here is: what was the “concrete meaning” of that kind of revolution midst the given desperate circumstances of the thirties? Analysis of the Roosevelt’s legislation and governmental measures shows that the target was primarily Big Capital. Exactly Big Capital was the epicentre around which was organised that which was targeted as “small society”. Exactly Big Capital – as the epicentre of small society - was “The-reason” for the problems of (Big) depression. In order to reach the Promised Land of Big Society (that of inclusion of all Americans), Roosevelt was forced (observing from his perspective there were no other solutions!) to somehow exclude or at least to diminish exactly the role of the Big Capital. Consequently, through targeting Big Capital and only (only!) in this indirect way (difference with regard to more direct Europeans leaning on party violence) of targeting the capitalism itself, it was possible to hope and even to develop Big Society and get a highly desired New Deal. And this goal was reached primarily through the numerous governmental measures.

It was reached, for example, through the “re-setting” of the old existing financial “settings” (Roosevelt’s first move after the elections), and through opening of the society (that is New Deal and New Society as the new direction of post-capitalist development!), through the enormous legislative production at the beginning of the thirties. Of substantial importance here is to understand that just at the point when – economically understood – industrial production of things has stopped (“Big depression” of small capitalist society!), the enormously legislative productivity of Roosevelt government started. Started to do what? It started to unlock the possibilities for development of the New Society, of the Big Society, of the New Society of inclusion. The point was not at all solely to open the possibility for the “new economy” – that was a socialist perspective, for example in Soviet’s NEP (new economic politics) during Lenin’s and Stalin’s years and conservative perspective in the USA – but for the New Society in the largest sense. Economy as “production of things” remained more or less the same in all these years. Rapidly changing was the very context, the entire New Society in the sense of “implementation” of completely, revolutionary new Inclusive Society (Big Society) which “resulted” in post-capitalism.

But this is only one side of a rather multifaceted coin. It cannot be underlined enough that this completely extraordinary situation of depression should under no circumstances be termed in categories of free-will. This would as a rule result in language games about “making revolution”, or “manufacturing revolution”, by this or that “revolutionary subject”. Roosevelt and his government were not any such kind of Subject, and Post-capitalism was not in advance planned New society by any sort of a free subject or any subjective free will whatsoever. Post-capitalism was thus no first premeditated and then implemented grandiose project (as socialism, for example), it was and remains incrementally established counter-system (counter to capitalism), born out of the purest possible necessity of Big/Great depression. It was the “only” solution within the given circumstances and not any kind of choice. The USA and Roosevelt came to post-capitalist “anti-position” and “anti-system” not through attacking capitalism but by defending it! Post-capitalism was not longed for but had happened as an entirely unpredicted result of the struggle for elementary survival of the System of society as such. Exactly such silent and unpredictable path of post-capitalism’s materialisation amounts to the explanation why there is almost no serious sign of the recognition of the very existence of post-capitalism whatsoever.

Anyway, here it is possible to isolate at least four basic moves of Roosevelt’s government, but only in an abstract way, of course. First, already mentioned financial consolidation, connected with the numerous “faith” and “trust building” procedures. These were the task for governmental legislation, but consisted to the large extent of the rhetorical (and political) “food”, being packed in numerous presidential speeches which aimed at the “trust building”, or better, at the creation of hope midst the completely hopeless surrounding. Radio speeches and newspaper dissemination were the paramount vehicle for this kind of hard governmental work, lasting for a few of harsh years. Second, rather careful and step-by-step marginalisation of the decisive influence of the richest (“anti-trust”, anti-monopoly legislation, diminishing profits for private enterprises...) took place, and simultaneously a promotion of the “activity” of “ordinary working people” (opening the space for trade unions, new strike legislation, etc.). Third, only on the basis of two additional elements was it possible to rebuild the social trust: with the control over the prices (wages of farmers & workers, “prices” of capital & interest rates included) and with enormous investments into the work force, and not in Capital (that was conservative conception). All these (and much more of them not even mentioned) measures were promising only on the basis of highly sophisticated (for that time) control over the role of the “blind” Market forces.

d) Investments in societal beings

At this essential point we reached now with regard to investments, we should be extremely cautious and exact as possible. They were not investments into the work as such but rather, the investments into the workforce. The question is how to grasp this difference correctly? There were investments in hungry people and their possibility for survival, but also into their dignity, and that was a highly important “moral side” of the Roosevelt project, which cannot be tackled here. However, as far as this element is concerned, as it is consisting of the so called “public works”, I should say a few additional sentences about it. Public works were the Roosevelt’s revolutionary project which perhaps even saved the US. Public works (electrification, road & bridge building, infrastructure...) were not at all profitable in any of possible economical terms or meta-language games of Capital(ism)! Quite the opposite was the case: judged from the point of view of economic efficiency and Capital(ism) they were completely “unproductive” (exactly that was the ground for the attacks on them from the conservatives). These huge investments were in a way explicitly anti-capitalist (anti-small-society), and simultaneously – that is the core of my thesis - post-capitalist! Observing from the point of view of capitalism (“small society” being in Big depression) there were par excellence new kind of investments. Besides, such a move was only possible on the basis of the mentioned “Roosevelt’s morality” and due to the launching of “virtual” (“not-yet-existing”) money which was taken from the next generations, creating the problem of dept, still present in USA.

Nevertheless, the central emphasis in this connection is the following one: although they were not “productive” – observed from the perspective of economic language games (and from the point of view of capital/ism), they were extremely productive from the point of view of the Big Society (post-capitalism) and its endurance. It was the investment into the foundation of the New, Big Society which was the “real object” of Roosevelt’s desire. The crux of the matter here is this one: the very inner logic of escaping the Great depression developed by Roosevelt’s government was not at all economical one! It was rather the societal (and social – here is the location of the mentioned Roosevelt’s morality). These two different “logics and principles” (economical and societal) are not at all the same and One logic and principles! They are not the same language games resulting into the same politics and action and into the same results. As already emphasized above, the investments which took place were not in capital(ism), not in production grasped in economical way (in productivity, efficiency), but into the work force, and later on – especially in WW II, when the opportunity appeared – also into the working places.

The question here is: what that “work force” meant, how to understand that revolutionary new point? It was simply the investment in the working people in the sense of the all members of Big (not any more small) Society. To put it in more direct way, these investments did not go to the members of this or that enterprise and factory any more (that is something that capitalist himself had to do), but in the completely new direction! The investments went to the members of the Big, inclusive Society (a kind the US form of “welfare state”). The underlying logic of Roosevelt’s government was not economy & capital (capitalist logic) any more. That logic was even seen as a kind of “ill object” in desperate need of larger/societal and social care. The underlying logic of Roosevelt was (Big) Society itself. Exactly that revolutionary change in emphasis form economy to Society (which is not possible to “see” from the perspective of economical/capitalist fundamentalism) was The revolutionary new paradigm which was – if at all – only partially and marginally present in the context of the previous, pre-depressed (small) capitalist society. The point was: in that radically new perspective, human beings, men and women, were grasped as social beings (“Thomistic element” from which the new morality progressed) within the new notion of Big Society, within New Society. Individual in Roosevelt’s eyes was not only homo faber any more (as in economical fundamental capitalist form of conservative thinking of these and latter days) but was rather a social being (ens socialis).

What counts here (still today) is the understanding of something very fundamental. No more investments in capital and in workers (as it was in socialism, fascism and nazism) and consequently in “production of things”, but above all in a completely new creature: that of a buyer, consumer grasped as “social being”. To put it differently, the largest context that needs to be grasped about Roosevelt’s fundamental moves is that the point was not only production and economy (as in capitalism, socialism, fascism and national-socialism included), but rather investment in societal beings and their “societal” consumption which started to function as new “societal economy” (post capitalism). That was the beginning of “social economy” about which all today’s managerial (not economical anymore!) theories are speaking when arguing about “social capital”.

Fourth, and most important, Roosevelt’s government took the initiative which is completely unthinkable in any kind of former capitalist arrangements. It took the position of the Manager of the entire (Big) Society in silent, invisible, but deeply revolutionary manner. Various governmental bodies – employed and lead by government, even by Roosevelt himself – started to lead the entire body of USA Big Society as being one big family/social enterprise. To put it differently and in slightly oversimplified form: the role that once upon the time (before Big depression) was played by capitalist (in capitalism) at the level of the factory (enterprise, company) was somehow overshadowed and even overtaken by the revolutionary new supreme role of government, led now by governmental managers. In these circumstances Roosevelt himself has became the Manager of all (his) managers. They managed not this or that company, but now the entire Big Society of America. That New Big Society of America was not understood any more as society (die Gesellschaft) or community (die Gemeinschaft)) of workers and capitalists (company, enterprise..., economical type of fundamental miss understanding) in previous sociological and economical language games. It was rather grasped and developed (“social constructivism”), as a lively organism in terms of the total “Social Body” (Aquinas). For example, the “enterprise” was not any more the centre of society (as it was in capitalism and socialism), it was not “the central cell of society” anymore, but only of economy (schematically speaking: predominance of society over economy in USA, and predominance of state over economy in Europe...). In that way a completely New kind of Enterprise (social, societal enterprise) in the sense of the “Enterprise of Big Society" took the supreme, most decisive role which is not yet at all grasped in entire social sciences, still trapped in economical fundamentalism. Only from that kind of revolutionary changes and on that Roosevelt’s “basis” from the thirties it was possible that “international” and “big enterprises”, “multi-national-enterprises” which appeared after WW II, shape our entire today’s existence. Solely on that “societal” post-capitalist (and not capitalist anymore!) basis from the thirties globalisation has become possible.

4. Management of the Big Society as the new paradigm of post-capitalism

There were three outstanding points and sets of new forms through which it is possible to understand the silent Roosevelt’s post-capitalist revolution aiming at the Factory of Society or projecting the Big Society as productive Factory that include all Americans. Firstly, it was already mentioned complex of macro leadership of (governmental) managers functioning, of course, from top to the bottom of entire Big Society. Secondly, there were crucial, revolutionary important changes in the complex of investments (especially in the mentioned concentration and the direction of investments), and thirdly, there were, consequently, radically changes in the complex of property.

a) Manager as the key person in total societal revolution of the Big Society

Besides what was said above we should also strongly emphasise the very logic and magnitude of changes in leadership (managerial leadership-of-Big-Society). Traditionally, capitalism was grasped as led by the “invisible hand”, which meant that the sovereign role of the market was somehow central to any capitalist economy. But that is – as already shown – only the economical (partial) side of the societal coin which was of paramount importance for Roosevelt’s revolutionary project. Society could not be led in the same way (that is the point which conservatives of all walks of life were never able to understood), especially not in an allegedly democratic surrounding. On the contrary, society is desperately in need of something more and different from the capacities of the invisible hand. Speaking at the metaphorical level, society desperately needs something like “visible hand”.

Such visibility is not just about “the government being visible”, or that the “governmental business” should be “transparent”, as it is usually argued in conservative and liberal literature which is based on the meta-language, still fundamentally mumbling about economy. Neither is it about setting down “basic parameters” for “business” (the “minimal state” ideology in various forms). The problem of society-leading and of total, societal (not only social!) leadership, is revolving around the problem that the leaders of society should somehow plan and even predict the “coming” events. Or better, they should plan and even produce the events and (post-festum) re-present them as “inevitable”. These events – at the level of society – cannot function like the “natural phenomena” in the sense that their appearance is left to society’s own “natural laws” (as fundamental meta-language of conservative economy uses to put it). Society-leading means much more: it means the ability of manufacturing the events in the sense of production of the society itself. “Producing society” here means to produce “fitting” societal relations and “right”, proper social forms of “normal” relationships and behaviour at large (in totality). To put it in the form of a very old distinction: the economical logic is a logic which can function at the level of this or that kind of “production of things” (commodities, their consumption included). The societal (not necessarily social) logic is mainly the logic of the “production of people”, to put it into Marxian words, of their physical, social, psychological, and “behavioural existence” in the sense of becoming “social” and not “anti-social beings”. This extremely large, not any more minimal “machination” of the people enclosed in the factory, is approximately that which Foucault detected as “bio-politics”, and should now be present strictly in every cell of the Big Society itself. It must be ingredient of planning immigration, jobs, schooling, social behaviour, of the very planning of the rates of mortality and even of “normal” criminality (not to speak about the planning of Wars). Leadership of total, Big Society, should not count on market as its automatic organiser (Descartes’ idea of “automaton). There is no – not in the nature and not elsewhere in human creativity – such a thing as a man or a woman “as thing”. The point that we should face today - understood in an extreme form - is the following: if one (regardless of whom and why) wants to produce such kind of commodity – man and women as the thing, as commodity – one must be able of far reaching, so to speak total, planning. One has to be able of total (total!) organisation, of total producing and controlling of the societal (“bio”) enterprise of society! Exactly that was the point in Roosevelt’s revolution based on the people (Big Society, “American people”) and not on “things” – the pattern which died together with the Roosevelt’s fundamental revolution of old (capitalist) society.

The crucial point here is to understand the very centrality of that historically new person, of the Manager as a new form of social being (ens socialis) or a Social-being-proper. There is no doubt that from the point of view of economy (and economic meta-language games) capitalist (private ownership, private initiative, private investments, the role of the market) and capitalism are the very centre of the system. But observing from the point of view of the entire society (Big Society not known in the USA before Roosevelt), the very economy (and capitalist, commodity production included) has become just one of (or among) sub-systems of the Big Society and nothing more!

b) Fundamental revolution in (Governmental) public investments

Roosevelt’s macro analysis concerning the “small society” and “old deal” – in the meaning of capitalism which led to the crisis and depression – was very simple and simultaneously exact. Investments (based also on credits and banks which caused problem of financial looses in 1929) were mainly in private (capitalist) hands and their interest groupings. In order to struggle against the depression Roosevelt’s team targeted exactly that areas of small society which were based on old deals among big capitalists (magnates, tycoons...), especially those tightly knitted around the banking sub-system. New managers from the Roosevelt’s government strictly blocked the money flow towards these groupings (“small society”) and redirected it. They redirected it in the first place towards the government (themselves), and towards the Big Society as explained above. In result the government (its managers!) suddenly became the very epicentre of all revolutionary events, and/or the main investors. The government also became (in the forties, especially due to the World War II) the main “spending factor” (“militarisation of society” was described in USA sociology only in fifties and sixties!) at the level of entire Big Society. Exactly spending (under the influence of Keynesianism from Europe) has become the dominant form of regulation of the entire metabolism of society (Body Society). To put in another parlance, the spending (and not production!!!) has become the epicentre of the planning of entire “fabric of Big Society”. And that was already the very foundation of the post-capitalist problems we are facing in our own depression of today.

c) Revolutionary changes in the structure of property: “mandatory” property

Today’s reasoning about property is usually trapped into still important but simultaneously oversimplified distinctions made by Berle & Means theories, targeting the “difference” between possession (property) and its “use”. The “management” of property in this “distinction” is understood in a way that capitalist simultaneously somehow represents both, owner and manager, while the manager is just someone managing/using capitalist property. The problem with this quite important distinction, which has become “classical” in social sciences as such, was and remains that it simultaneously opened a new possibility of thinking but it also kept secret if not even completely hidden something even more important, namely the very appearance of a new form of property, that which transcends the private property. The point is that Berle & Means’ “distinction” was still made under the fundamental and monistic (Locke’s!) quasi understanding of property in the sense of private property horizons as absolute ones.

As already strongly emphasized, the very central figure in the revolutionary post-capitalist new situation of the thirties was not capitalist any more. It was rather a completely new kind not of proprietor but that of leader, of Manager. As far as the property was (and is!) concerned it is important to realise that the manager was not any more “playing” any kind of “production game” with and for his own, private money, property and financial resources. He was rather playing the game with something else: namely – and that is the pivotal point - with public money or, much better, with public debts! The new game of post-capitalism was played through the so-called “financial industry”, mostly through the “politics of debts” and trading also with debts: first with credits and later on with leasing (after WW II). Our problem of thinking and understanding the contemporary situation in that connection is that today it is not enough to speak about production or trade or commerce and similar “economical problems”. Today we mainly have problems with production, trade and commerce with debts. We are in radically different non-position and non-situation: we are not in any “positive position” but rather in totally “negative situation”!

If one wants to put the here merely tackled problem of property into the “pure form” of a model, then it is possible to say that for capitalist (within the circumstances of capitalism in which the figure of capitalist is the central one) it is completely normal and even natural (that “naturalness” is crucial for entire economical meta-language of today fundamentalism) that in the game of production (of things!) he (or she) is going to win or lose his (or her) own private property. This means that he or she is per definition extremely responsible to him/herself (looses in crises witnessed hundreds of suicides of capitalists, but just few managers in 2008/2009 took their lives). And yet, what is for capitalist normal, is for the manager (central post-capitalist creature) for a very good reason not normal at all, but rather completely abnormal! Manager – and this is very important – is not the owner in the sense in which the capitalist used to be the owner of almost everything in the production except of the work force that was hired. Moreover, if manager loose, that means that the public and not his own, private money was lost as well as maybe also his or her employment (“working place”). This radically new situation appears as “illogical” and even immoral (quasi argument of “greed” so often present in today neo-Thomist economical moralisations) only within the highly sophisticated and totally mistaken economical meta-language of today’s thoughtless matrix. The problem is radically different and it must be grasped from an entirely different perspective: the fact that while losing, managers (“bad managers”) are still gaining - also in times of total depression and great looses – is something completely normal in the sense of their leader-work as employees and not as capitalists any longer.

The central feature and new “basis” of post-capitalist life (not only in the USA) which has not yet been seriously recognised and analysed by economists (let alone social scientist) was and remains the invention of a completely new form of property . This was a kind of “public” or even “societal” or “socialised property” which in times of Roosevelt was first concentrated and then administrated (through huge public investments at the level of totality of society) exactly by the governmental managers of the Big Society. The point here is that there was no escape from capitalist depression and economy in the late twenties and thirties without exactly this kind of revolutionary innovation in the field of property. Concentration of almost all societal resources (resources of entire society) in the hands of the government, projected debts as the main tool for investment, centralisation of all funds and investments, concentration of the entire capital of the nation/society is just another way of describing the new form of “public”, “societal property”. Such exit from the depression was not at all possible within the old, small society of capitalism revolving around the private property and of invisible hand of market surrounding. A new brand of post-capitalist Big Society, now revolving around the public (mostly clouded in debts), “societal” property, has to come to existence. Moreover, within these revolutionary circumstances the production was not based on former, past accumulation (in hands of private capitalist) any longer but was shaped as the quasi production established on the (non)accumulation yet to come in the future. Because of the political circumstances in the USA in which the elections are the same as the fight for management of total “societal” investments of exactly this “public”, “societal” property, I call this new form of property “mandatory property”. The winner of the elections is by definition winning exactly the mandate to manage (total management) the property of entire nation/society, that of private investors in banking systems, insurances, etc., of course, included.

To put it more philosophically: if by now the property used to function (still today’s fundamental rhetoric of economy) as “to have” (gr. ehein) complex, after the post-capitalist Roosevelt’s revolution it has become the question of “to be” (gr. einai). Moreover, in our times it developed into the problem of “to be or not to be”, which is just another way of definition of what today’s globalisation is about as well as about its own, now visible, horizons and absolute limits.

* * *

In sum, mainly due to typically Western and ad infinituum exaggerated preoccupation with wars and “political” (violent) revolutions, The biggest and The most important revolution of the XX. century, that of New Deal, still remains completely invisible. The Big depression and the New Deal as a response to it in the USA was not any kind of the “continuation of the capitalism with another means”, but it was rather the revolutionary turning point of no return! It was the way out of capitalism and towards the post-capitalism. Thus capitalism, as we usually understand it, evaporated already in the thirties and forties of the XX. century. But its own language games still persists as the document of former times in which we are still trapped. These language games are becoming even more and more noisy they are literary shouting on us and even blocking our elementary potentials for thinking. These increasingly fundamental and simultaneously completely void Capitalist language games of the previous dominant form of life sill persist mainly within today’s new managerial forms of knowledge, in that of economy and social sciences at large. More over they persist above all in our own quasi natural language, highly mediated and manipulated by the media machinery. This is why the desperately needed critique of managerial and economical as fundamental meta-language of today’s social sciences is one of the most crucial possibilities for serious re-thinking of our own time and its global problems.

In order to go “beyond” these problems (as a matter of fact to reach “here” and to “come back” from the heavens of religions, ideologies, sciences and knowledge, preaching endless Progress) it is completely out of place to try to explain what capitalism was. We rather need to understand what post-capitalism is about. Even less appropriate is, in order to come to grips with our own, existing depression of post-capitalism, to celebrate the alleged hopeful past of capitalism. We must be aware of and at least try to face the existing reality of nothingness which is exactly the nothingness of the post-capitalism itself.

Notes:

1- I am using »Capitalism« to mark the level of language games, while »capitalism« stands for anti-political (republican and not democratic!), economic and social system in the sense of its Western existence. The fact that the reality of Capitalism is obviously “stronger” and that it even hides the very possibility of thinking that-which-is outside of the Capital-mumbling, is among the reasons for my »attack« on Capitalism as the meta-language. The aim is to emphasize that capitalism is not material, empirical, “real” pre-supposition of or for Capitalism, but that the contrary is the case: meta-language of Capitalism itself – its endless language games – is word for word manufacturing capitalism in its infinity in which we are trapped as in our own golden “scientific” cage.

2- Not new as such but new in the context of the USA history, while Europe and other parts of the world were already familiar with various forms of public, common and numerous another forms of property. “People” (“American People”, “American nation”) was radically redefined with the appearance of the Big Society. It has lost any political emphasis in terms of “la nation” of the French revolution!

Bibliography:

Berger, P. (1986): The Capitalist Revolution, Harper Collins, New York

Berle, A., Means, G. C. (1968): The Modern Corporation and Private Property, Harcourt Brace and World, New York

Burnham, J. (1945): The Managerial Revolution or What is Happening in the World Now, Penguin Books, London

Chandler, A. D. jr., Payne, P. L., Kocka, J., Yamaura, K. (1979): Evoluzione della grande impresa e management, Einaudi, Torino

Chandler, A. D. jr. (2002): The Visible Hand: The Managerial Revolution in American Business, The Belknap Press, London

Dawley, A. (1991): Struggles for Justice: Social Responsibility and the Liberal State, Cambridge, Mass: Harvard Univ. Press

De Goede, M. (2005): Virtue, Fortune and Faith, A Genealogy of Finance, University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis, London

Drucker, P. F. (1994): The Post-capitalist Society, HarperBusiness, HarperCollins Publ., New York

D ttmann A. G. (2007): Philosophy of Exaggeration, Continuum, London

Edsforth, R. (2003): The New Deal, America’s Response to the Great Depression, Blackwell Publ. Oxford

Eliot, T. H. (1992): Recollections of the New Deal: When the People Mattered, Boston, Northeastern Univ. Press

Enteman, W. F. (1993): Managerialism, The Emergence of a New Ideology, The University of Wisconsin Press, Madison

Foucault, M. (2002): The Archaeology of Knowledge, Routledge, London, Classics

Hawley, E. (1966): The New Deal and the Problem of Monopoly, Princeton Univ. Press

Hawken, P., Lovins, B. A., Lovins, L. H. (2002): Natural Capitalism, The Next Industrial Revolution, Earthscan Publishers London

Koistinen, P. A. C. (2004): Arsenal of World War II, The Political Economy of American Warfare, 1940-1945, University Press of Kansas

Latouche, S. (2005): L’invention de l’economie, Editions Albin Michele, Paris

Meiksins Wood, E. (2002): The Origin of Capitalism, A Longer View, Verso, London, New York

Pena, D. S. (2001): Economic Barbarism and Managerialism, Greenwood Press, Westport, Connecticut, London

Polany, K. (1957): The Great Transformation, Beacon, Boston

Pribram, K. (1988): Storia del pensiero economico (I-II), Piccola biblioteca Einaudi, Torino

Roosevelt, Elleanor (1949): This I Remember, Harper & Brothers, New York

Roosevelt, Elliot (1950): F. D. R.: His Personal Letters 1928-1945, Duell, Sloan, and Pearce, New York

Roosevelt, F. D (1938): The Public Papers and Addresses of F. D. Roosevelt, Random House, New York

Sirower, M. L. (1997): The Synergy Trap, How Companies Lose the Acquisition Game, The Free Press, New York

Staughton, L. (ed.) (1996): We are all Leaders, Urbana, University of Illinois Press

Taylor, F. W. (1998): The Principles of Scientific Management, Dover Publ. New York

Wittgenstein, L. (2004): Philosophical Grammar, Blackwell Publ. Oxford

Wittgenstein L. (2007): The Blue Books and Brown Books, Blackwell Publ. Oxford

Wittgenstein L. (1998): Philosophical Remarks, Blackwell Publ. Oxford

Go to top
Notice: Undefined index: adv in /home/kamranmofid/public_html/templates/jsn_epic_pro/index.php on line 654
sections of research paper apa dissertation ideas for outdoor education writing definition essay examples term paper proposal buy essay online cheap uk pattern compare contrast essay organization mla format research papers 2011 obama photo essays scholarship 2007 essay persuasive essay rubric 4th grade essay comparison words phd thesis on mobile adhoc networks thesis art history paper thesis for research paper on racism thesis statement for stephen king research paper phd thesis defense mcgill definition essay family examples essays on travel experiences thesis statement for a homemade education results section of psychology research paper thiess jobs kempsey how to write essay with appendix business ma thesis proposal thesis on self help groups pdf thesis for stem cell research money can buy everything essay thesis statement on child abuse ap bio sample essays 2002 topics master's thesis construction management thesis statement introductory paragraph examples help me find a research paper topic great harry potter essays cause and effect essay prompt free sample college personal essays analysis of a picture essay solar power essays product launch plan essays college admissions essay help catch-22 essay questions college essay about psychology university essay title page layout william james essay essay writing assignment annual school function essay short essays by james baldwin free essay correcting essay man is a bundle of emotions my thesis adviser wattpad help on research papers ap history thesis examples writing for money essay model persuasive phd thesis adviser research paper books cause and effect essay childhood obesity thesis paper on image processing the beauty thesis perfect curls bridge to terabithia essay questions thesis on antimicrobial activity of thuja occidentalis essay identity stranger in the village analysis thesis abstract in accounting essay scholarships high school students 2009 thesis on solid waste management in the philippines penn state thesis lookup dissertation etymology statistical analysis of data example thesis quotes english terrorism research paper ideas resident assistant essay graduate school essay sample computer science 2 page essay on how to behave cheap custom term papers essay steps sylvia plath elm essay thesis statement lesson plan worksheet essay on human understanding john locke summary thesis editing australia thesis on kitchen design thesis proposal latex template mit thesis on english writing skills the greater the effort the greater the glory essay my assignment payg argument for change essay research paper argument ideas ideas for a photo essay compare and contrast essay short stories a level physics coursework help international review of business research papers ranking personal statement writing company thesis paper margins depression+term papers satire essays drinking age wits thesis and dissertation thesis_hook_before_header essay on ethnicity identity raising the age of driving to 18 essay lyrics analysis essay la sonnambula natalie dessay writing thesis introduction example secure attachment style essay an easy topic for a research paper sterotype essay thesis for cloning essay essay on individualism and collectivism essay on how college changed my life how to write a good title for an essay sample research paper video games research papers on eating disorder essay help toronto my ideal office essay english 111 sample essays batter my heart john donne essay thesis statement examples violent video games literary analysis essay cathedral a level essay structure thesis defence report violence of video games research paper funny essay question answers esl how to write an outline term paper buy essays fast dissertation report on sales promotion homeworkwriters essay on obesity harvard thesis prize revising an essay worksheet what a good essay title how to give credit for quotes in an essay essay festival dussehra robert slifkin dissertation essay competitions for kids amontillado analytical cask essay write how to write the thesis introduction copy editing thesis journal good introduction paragraph for my essay research paper template essay competitions 2010 malaysia death penalty persuasive essay against comparison essay example thesis no pain no gain essay writing good topics to write an informative essay on essay heaps liar new paradox essay on becoming a manager thesis title for english major students thesis plural form thesis topics on social issues 5 should state colleges be free to attend essay thesis introduction defense thesis binding university of limerick is a thesis necessary in a research paper thesis for pro life essay essay writing on financial inclusion essays on the day after tomorrow thesis binding darlington research hypothesis meaning mla works cited unpublished dissertation shakespere hamlet essays thesis template uwo how to write perfect thesis statement referencing an essay harvard thesis for rhetorical analysis example toefl essays topics audio codec thesis principle essay imperial college thesis repository research essay controversial topics engineer girl essay contest 2011 winners thesis statement for causal argument psychology nature vs nurture essay term paper introduction essay that got me into harvard essay topics for wbsedcl written exam legitimate essay writing services ntu thesis cover page easy senior thesis topics how to write a better essay pdf define thesis dissertation sample critical essay article dissertation editing services reviews essay on financial literacy thesis examples for autobiography thesis examples for literary analysis marks your dissertation essay research topics new year festival in sri lanka essay essays on violence in youth essay on the story of an hour by kate chopin honor code essay good thesis for a compare and contrast essay graduate essay statement expository essay conclusion outline mckeown thesis definition will writing service bristol development of radar essay resistivity of constantan coursework diwali essay thesis medical definition essays samples thesis defense biology affordable ghostwriters hamlet revenge on claudius essay iris recognition thesis 2012 perfect act essay example buy kraft paper roll essay on evils of corruption thesis on construction waste management dissertation only phd accredited writing equations worksheet samples of compare and contrast essay labreport wjec ict a2 coursework end of cold war essay trove thesis database thesis statement evaluation malaria parasite india essay format dissertation proposal global health essay questions thesis statement for a research paper on gay marriage can you get honours degree without doing dissertation how many paragraphs are in a persuasive essay resume writing service norfolk va thesis job satisfaction attia akram research paper write my paper for me fast creative writing english coursework compare and contrast essay examples for elementary school thesis for black history thesis proposal for mbs ozone hole essays thesis guideline uitm 2015 mla format in an essay phd thesis checklist the chocolate war analysis essay thesis proposal humanities moodle research paper essay writing on visit to a historical place thesis statement for effect essay othello and love essay can you ask rhetorical questions in a research paper cheap essay writing services catcher in the rye comparison essay essay on arts in education papers on research methodology bibliography thesis filipino ems research papers tips homework thesis topics list in computer science definition of a personal narrative essay story about friendship - essay custom writing essays master's thesis checklist dissertation formatting services manual for theses and dissertation writing berlin blockade essay topics research paper japanese internment greek mythology essay paper purdue template thesis aqa computing a level coursework personal statement writing services thesis for ap world history comparative essay apush wwi essay questions thesis plagiarism checker online free who's afraid of virginia woolf essays essay love friendship how do i write my thesis for a research paper thesis topics related to sustainable architecture dissertation on english writing road to reading write my thesis and outline for me blackberry picking essay free essay on pollution in your city how to write an xyz thesis essays on dimensional convergence comparison essay on macbeth free custom research papers the prince niccolo machiavelli essays essay on school day celebrations thesis english vocabulary book ratings site help with writing essay thesis project outline example essay my favourite cartoon character doraemon american essay feminism history literary thesis statement examples for 6th graders thesis on linear equations opening paragraph of a thesis essays on drama in education term paper editing service driving forces of globalization essay reflective social work essay examples buy dissertation online uk thesis questions education essay about honesty thesis topics on youth stephen 20th century english poet novelist and essayist thesis on vlsi design thesis statement examples about life essay entitled love my family of mice and men essay conclusion friendship customer essay dissertation photography paper template term custom essays writing thesis plural or singular essay eyre free jane diythemes blog uw graduate school thesis format thesis binding services sheffield professional essay help proofreading rna polymerase thesis beauty therapy term paper service thesis paper presentation help me do my essay thesis what is a feature box thesis binding gloucester custom dissertation service meilleur site de dissertation aqa graphics coursework art critical studies essay compare contrast american french revolution essay thesis topics for beowulf my parents are my best teachers essay huckleberry finn essay on hypocrisy world war 2 introduction essay tourism thesis database essay contests in canada 2011 chapter 3 thesis introduction sample methodologie de dissertation juridique thesis statement nursing economy in the 1920s essay writing a science lab report regional integration for and against articles term paper format in mla paper research sample romeo and juliet essay prompts essay on criticism special education inclusion research paper college thesis topics psychology favorite teacher essays using cell phones while driving research paper thiess supervisor jobs high cost of living essay dissertation topic template mis thesis ideas for leadership essay writing service cheap master thesis game programming kntu thesis template child labour in sri lanka essay forming thesis committee expository essay video thesis writing experience informative speech outline thesis i need someone to write my paper 1993 dbq ap us history sample essay essays on ayn rand's the fountainhead table of contents thesis statement noise pollution business dissertation topics 400 to 500 word essay buy college research papers harvard style of writing dissertation fiction essay thesis outline propaganda essay introduction essay outlines printable thesis visual communication design the curious incident of the dog essay topics buy essay thesis root word image essay writing essay on misrepresentation hbs essays 2012 theoretical framework thesis paper resume writing service grand rapids mi i wandered lonely as a cloud analysis essay thesis statement ideas for the kite runner pleasantville film essays research paper mla buy diploma frames online essay radio 3 buy paper guillotine uc aplication essays interpersonal skills essay what is dissertation title essays on louis xiv absolutism breakfast club themes essay how to write a thesis literary essay great gatsby green light symbolism essay essay writing service ranking thesis examples theology mfa thesis paper examples informative process organization in an essay doctoral thesis defense help me write a compare and contrast essay constitutional conventions essay research papers on inclusive education in india thesis driven comparative essay common application transfer essay samples dementia research paper topics letterhead on watermarked paper essay editing rates dissertation on tourism industry poor and blank thesis introduction lab report ubc thesis database essay federalist vs anti federalist best american essays 5th examples of college essays about goals sample of a thesis statement research paper workbook topics proof reading my essay thesis english as second language proquest dissertation endnote what is included in essay writing water pollution essay in hindi thesis for comparative essay example proofreading emails nhs essay sample great gatsby essays on the american dream thesis for education examples my favourite singer essay non euclidean geometry essay essay on the cost of college check your essay plagiarism free poor essay sample describe a good friend essay consider the lobster and other essays summary anthem objectivism essay thiess jobs sa free online research papers education essays on othello and desdemona bell jar essay questions funny essay written while high thesis statement alternative energy dissertation research question examples university of maryland essays 2012 thesis statement zodiac signs yale mba essays thesis on compare and contrast thesis and dissertation proquest compare and contrast essay on antigone and creon essay in mla form walker percy the loss of the creature essays essay editing powerpoint thesis and roadmap definition free sample essays - medical school writing a thesis in one night a school peon essay people to write essay about thesis proposal case study possible questions in thesis defense with answers master thesis conceptual framework causes of youth violence essay platos republic thesis free online statistics help classroom behavior essay english history research paper topics essay on modernity thesis local politics local abstract environmental analysis paper essay thesis writing expenses essay example free student counter thesis definition cambridge university essay competition 2013 format movie titles in essays theis holster for m&p shield dialectical essay format walden thesis ideas short essays on brain drain good thesis statements on prohibition beauty therapy thesis topics thesis antithesis examples compare 2 novels essay persuasive speech on animal abuse essay essay about my dream job thesis for a demonstrative speech thesis statement examples on sports thesis statement examples for research papers paul rochard dissertation computer related thesis harvard thesis database useful essay quotes property development dissertation ideas thesis topics wuthering heights proofreading online jobs how long is a thesis for a research paper essay on time essay on political implication of power an essay about mother earth thesis introduction about abortion sample mla style essays conclusion sample for thesis free skeptical definition essay common sense is not so common essays buy essays phone number essay on every dark cloud has a silver lining essay on staying home alone persuasive essays middle school thesis topics about environment thesis for informative speech on dreams essay about my trip to beach write term paper introduction essay writing on electronics thesis paper download free osha research paper topics essay on brown vs board of education once and future king essays thesis editing sydney strong response essay essay on inequality between men and women defense graduate thesis thesis binding dublin dundrum writing the successful thesis and dissertation entering the conversation thesis binding glebe i need someone to write my assignment working thesis statement examples coursework uk ambitious essay dissertation director essay on paul baumer write thesis statement informative speech model argumentative essays thesis statement about ignorance essays teaching learning thesis compare and contrast examples free research papers entrepreneurship essay editing skills thesis statement examples cyberbullying research paper components thesis for beowulf and grendel online resume thiess jobs seek argument thesis template bmat essay examples essay font thesis statement examples in a speech oxford thesis editing thesis+hepatoprotective activity+in rats phd thesis general introduction college essays nyu thesis advisor and postgraduate-scholar sponsor college essay examples good and bad ap lang rhetorical essay sample baldwin notes of a native son essay pdf how to start a business school essay graduate school notre dame dissertation submission thesis statement biographical essay that write research papers wvia great teacher essay contest essay on ww1 causes formula sae thesis thesis statement for global education thesis topics mba essay on patience a virtue harvard university thesis search custom term paper free essay on fast food mr imaging in deep pelvic endometriosis a pictorial essay thesis title about bullying free dissertation free essays on natural selection richard larson the research paper in the writing course paul dudis dissertation uconn honors thesis form research paper on xylanase ralph waldo emerson essays on love controversial essay topics us oprah winfrey influential essay writing generator citing a thesis in bibtex a2 salters chemistry coursework essay writing about friendship research papers on prednisolone valerate hard work key to success essay spanish famous person coursework general novel essay prompts formulate a thesis statement school uniform persuasive essay introduction thesis topics in literature contoh outline cause effect essay a day at school essay grants for dissertations custom essay writing online paper writing services reviews vatarakta thesis thesis statement black death spongebob writes an essay gif love story essay topics writing personal background essays thesis binding the mall sligo critical thinking psychology essay on role of youth in social change thesis ideas for geology sample essay on healthy lifestyle thesis statement for team building controversial topics for essay writing tragedy thesis cheap ghost writer services essay on rawls justice as fairness water consumption essay five paragraph essay concluding paragraph thesis energy and environment thesis eleven impact factor proofreading klenow fragment thesis paper on motivation free essays english corruption stanford thesis signature page dissertation writing services usa thesis paper conclusion examples thesis college level thesis on greek architecture description of definition essay three paragraph expository essay graphic organizer essay covers amanda moehring thesis scholarship essay examples on goals bored of studies speeches essay resistant materials gcse coursework evaluation ielts writing format for essay essay hamburger method thesis on energy engineering business and management extended essay topics papers help best online paper writers pre-dental essays only god can take life essay useful phrases for writing argumentative essays thesis for a beowulf essay fear anxiety public speaking journal articles research papers thesis about aids strategies concluding essays thesis title examples for highschool students how to find someone to write my paper sat essay portion uncc graduate school thesis manual short essay my best friend definition of electronic thesis and dissertation essay writing tips esl architecture thesis book philippines mfa thesis definition thesis defence form essays of francis bacon literature dissertation zeilenabstand descriptive essays about nightmares essays about corporate training how to write a personal narrative thesis statement economic society of singapore essay essays on sor juana ines de la cruz business management dissertations topics thesis statement usually appears thesis about elementary education thesis and dissertation uf maya angelou poetry essays spanish essay using preterite and imperfect thesis statement examples on breast cancer buy paper eskimo rogerian argument thesis statement examples dissertation for dummies short essay on online banking dissertation provider school essay topics free dialectic thesis antithesis synthesis free essays counselling skills thesis paper ideas public administration thesis examples short essay about child labour in india thesis design and methodology jungle book essay questions essay on role of technology in our daily life easy essay scholarships college buy research papers online thesis prospectus examples homosexuality research paper economic dissertation dear mister president essay thesis to kill a mockingbird racism thesis questions about the holocaust thesis writing practice worksheet writing an essay in 3rd person essay competition pakistan 2009 essay on rising prices in india in hindi thesis harvard university essay on trees nature gift to man thesis statement examples edgar allan poe design and technology gcse coursework proofreading exercises pdf thesis statement for energy conservation spatial mechanism thesis thesis about bullying in high school essays on cervical cancer compare and contrast art essay format good thesis defense baby thesis about time management thesis statement the scarlet letter critical essay on fences by august wilson thesis writing in jaipur thesis pronunciation audio why become a vegetarian essay essay about adversity overcoming buy vibrance paper bead glaze good thesis characteristics article writers wanted essay jose rizal wrote wpp online writing thesis topics pdf essay prompts writing with symbols great thesis statements for the crucible writing your life story writing successful thesis dissertation pdf dissertation quotes or italics clemson graduate school thesis guidelines thesis binding services melbourne romance reading on the book essays on medieval narrative bachelor thesis database gary snyder essays online thesis statement generator for free lysistrata thesis statement thesis statement blog dissertation pdf gre issue essay topics answers war poems english coursework the old man and the sea analysis essay how to write a thesis statement for a research paper in apa format research papers publishing write a well organized essay that includes an introduction essay on man enotes thesis template for wordpress help with coursework consumer reports resume writing services troy vs iliad essay interactive thesis builder thesis statement for the great depression proofreading guide skillsbook gay marriage persuasive essay examples sidd shenoy thesis essays comparing frankenstein and paradise lost rodney mcgee home essay junior english essay topics thesis latex template pdf essayer casque schuberth recommendation thesis setting essay essay essaytown miscellaneous papers papers research resistance during the holocaust essay sat essay formula gets high scores lloyd jones preacher thesis web design research paper essays on american culture essay about population control sample low gmat essay informative essay thesis thesis topics christianity buying college papers english thesis font thesis writing book pdf along the road notes and essays of a tourist honors thesis prospectus tulane thesis on activity based learning proofreading documents essays of apolinario mabini thesis guideline uitm essays overpopulation solutions mth401 solved final term papers environmental education masters thesis introduction paragraph essay sample battle of hastings research paper thesis essay owl thousand pieces gold essay introduction argumentation dissertation proofreading taq creative writing styles essay on photography career buy essays online reviews thesis outline template sample for research proposal the other woman essays example of research paper about computer technology essays in love free download thesis automotive industry doctoral dissertation fellowship award uconn biographical essay example thesis on insanity defense essay topics media life changing event essays jhu thesis latex army leadership essay scientific essay writing skills do my college paper for me essay editing checklist dissertation genius if i were president essay ideas thesis book example fahrenheit 451 by ray bradbury essay topics abstract word essay examples ocr science in the news coursework mark scheme writing to convince essays dissertation sciences po thesis and dissertation paper samples explain marx's logic thesis antithesis synthesis put coursework on resume research paper format sample teaching informative essays proofreading orphan ethnicity in sports essays free essay for scholarships american foreign policy essay topics baby thesis about bullying determine authorship paper technology and culture essay apa thesis proposal cover page appendix section of research paper descriptive essays on shoes thesis topic education administration thesis writing and research progress report argumentative essay esl comparison essay buy college research papers online topics to do a research paper on world history thesis examples thesis statement expository essay research paper lesson plan 8th grade newsweek essay writing thesis analysis synthesis dissertation proposal in uk dissertation abstracts literature thesis easy definition college research paper writers csr essays gender norm violation essays quadratic formula research paper help writing an essay for college architectural thesis proposal list telephone essays the essays of warren buffett pdf behavior in class essay english essay prospectus buy paper guns english course reflective essay digital signal processing research paper chemistry coursework rate reaction sodium thiosulphate conclusion phd writing service uk thesis sentence creator thesis examples for lord of the flies master thesis title page latex dissertation layout gamelan thesis dissertation for dummies essay on conservatism how to write thesis theoretical framework dissertation definition cheap custom essay writing service making friends and making them count essay help writing a book dissertation participant essay written on censorship on the internet thesis statement for a narrative essay example of essay topics compare and contrast two fast food restaurants essay honors thesis psychology beauty and the beast research paper essaysreasy order form nclb essay ideas for a research paper for psychology describe your perfect house essay dissertation sur le sport exemple economics a level model essays how to write a good thesis for a narrative essay traveling is a part of education essay thesis writing workshop essay verb meaning thesis vs research paper thesis australian national university litterary research paper topics essay about the use of changing states of matter contoh abstract thesis bahasa inggris steps to writing a satirical essay thesis demo sites ap french language and culture essay rubric genocide essay examples social science research council international dissertation thesis recommendation for future researchers myself essay example thesis for essay thesis definition for dummies essay on art and artist soft binding thesis london thesis literature review outline writing numbers 1-20 bachelor thesis front page latex buy an essay uk non jewish jew and other essays proofreading essay developing a thesis high school essay on my life goals descriptive essays free thesis test introduction of the thesis writing thesis on antifungal activity of medicinal plants research paper apa outline thesis paper appendix thesis statement and conclusion essay fast food obesity term paper quiz essays on the nobility of scotland master thesis business development wjec as film studies coursework rachel maddow thesis pdf how to write my essay essayer subjonctif imparfait thesis sample in marketing freedom writer essays writing theses writing service in linux sample outline on a research paper canadian ged essay questions toefl essay topics and answers difference between thesis and library dissertation thesis ideas criminal justice thesis statement examples biology examples of well-written sat essays sports and socialization free essay an essay about chets essayist wtih addison essay writing qualities of a good student scholar essay nursing scholarship essay tips essay about my dreams for the future ib extended essay computer science essay on the korean war thesis defense guidlines buy paper placemats sample of thesis statement of the problem essay of why high school thesis introduction writing a history dissertation why computer science college essay writing a thesis statement for informative speech introducing sources in an essay sample ap lit essay prompts thesis regular font punjab university lahore thesis buy diploma russia qualitative analysis of cations lab report thesis binding athlone how to write a thesis for a literary research paper anti development thesis wiki essay about the help english homework for kids classification essay examples on teachers example of a lab report for biology thesis into journal article stem cell research thesis question on a tout essaye sur france 2 essay about helping others footnotes for research papers writing essay about yourself for college a level chemistry aspirin coursework essays about my best friends term paper vocabulary film thesis titles essay breakdown thesis defense questions examples sample five-paragraph essay say no to plastic essays dissertation writing fellowships francis bacon the essays of atheism proofreading resources career research paper essay example research paper margaret sanger the kite runner love and sacrifice essay america in the 1950s essay kgmc thesis topics the thesis depot write commonplace essay university of notre dame admission essay free thesis statement generator for research paper phd thesis on development finance power system thesis in 2010 filetype pdf writing an essay sample thesis of civil engineering medical college admission essays pro abortion opinion essay thesis statement bad examples do my essay for me cheap essay thesis for brave new world thesis javascript header thesis on energy audit of building sports car classification essay ideal topics for a dissertation in hospitality thesis statement on education essays nature essay kids two types of gre essays annotations examples tv thesis thesis proposal defense questions archaeology essay greek hellas history literature school physics coursework resistance of a wire diagrams graduate program admission essay examples is consumerism good or bad+essay political science honors thesis topics dissertation topics indian stock market conclusion in baby thesis thesis format engineering ender's game thesis statement thesis defense powerpoint presentation sample automated library system thesis pdf thesis title font lbs mba essay questions dissertation binding qub phd thesis introduction length master thesis definition of terms thesis waste to energy good topics write process analysis essay thesis on education and growth imperialism ww1 essay undergrad dissertation reference essay harvard style theis holster belt review thesis on library design essay cover page thesis topics for masters sociology term paper subjects university essay editing services essay outline machine essay on psychology memory barbara kingsolver essays philosophy in life sample essay thesis committee meeting confirmation essay why i want to be confirmed order of essay paragraphs thesis binding services manchester syracuse scholarship in action essay thesis paper about online games free online research papers buy essay plagiarism is an analytical paper a research paper sample of a scholarship essay meaning of compare and contrast essay history research paper for me best scholarships proofreading for run on sentences definition essay humility glass menagerie essays amanda essay on my toy term paper tiger essay on the usual suspects the patriot movie essay thesis statement examples research setting your essay to mla format in word 2010 global warming and greenhouse effect essay review essay write sample essay about politics in philippines dissertations writing services bel120 essays sports thesis topics othello research paper topics phrasebook for writing papers and research in english free download writing a customer service job description essay about me free classes essay drugs youth attaching appendix essay thesis development examples introduction thesis english thesis into book cause obesity children essay development underdevelopment thesis sample of short essay about life quoting shakespeare in essay essay on importance of computer education multicultural education essays and articles lord of the flies theme essays defense in thesis buy coursework online uk thesis ideas for death of a salesman kathryn campbell-kibler dissertation thesis introduction about teaching strategies thesis physical education pdf manuscript editing rates thesis proposal management information system conservation flora fauna essays essay editing marks write an essay about your mother in french thesis guidelines uottawa sylvia plath lc essay thesis about game theory role of political leaders essay not doing homework essay sample pharmcas personal essay essays censorship television responsibility argumentative essay research paper about engineering quality custom essay writing games for kids disposable email export paper report research tissue essays on plagarism good thesis conclusion thesis statement about against abortion thesis on faculty development essays on clothing style commercial property dissertation topics osu grad school thesis format standard term paper outline distinguished dissertation award lsu philosophy ethics essay thesis proposal kasetsart university susan b anthony persuasive essay thesis audio power valve anthropology research paper ideas bits dissertation outline example risd thesis book essay editing examples british theses dissertations topics to write a classification essay on biology coevolution dialectical essay influence nature society under free golf essays intermediate bulk container description on shipping papers ut dallas mba essays free sample gre essay questions walmart good or bad essay how to state a thesis in a research paper dissertation masters phd thesis in international relation essay quarrel friend battle of stalingrad essay thesis writing in microsoft word beginning an essay with a quote write compare contrast essay 2 topics overcomming depression thesis writing literature review imperialism in world war 1 essay college essay help online hackers hacking essay vietnam essay intro order of importance essay topics describe a historical place you have visited essay cats cradle essay crucible research paper ideas essay about night thesis template for scrivener creating writing paper service write a dissertation term paper sample tagalog thesis for reflective essay examples emba application essay sample berkeley haas essays 2012 theater thesis amnesty research paper essay on democracy in urdu who is the real monster in frankenstein thesis thesis about english speaking campaign thesis interactive design i should do my homework samples of dissertations topics alexander pope an essay on man epistle dissertation writing fellowship social sciences cornell graduate school thesis submission essay on criticism journal essay on dulce et deco rum est difference between thesis and outline political issues essays thesis limassol ut graduate school dissertation template how to write thesis results can i buy a college essay essay on american west teenage pregnancy essay topics thesis database thailand to bid the world farewell by jessica mitford essay essay world writer essay on work is worship for class 6 argumentative persuasive essay topic ideas essay on std research paper youth violence the person i admire is famous person essay how to write an article review reservation blues analytical essay cae article writing pavan turaga thesis how to write a family background essay understanding mary midgley sword essay death of a salesman and the american dream essays undergraduate thesis english literature buy essays cheap quotes for romeo and juliet essay michigan fraternal order of police essay contest words used comparison contrast essay unsuccessful thesis defense first class dissertation essay on significant event in life related literature in thesis writing thesis using structural equation modeling ms word thesis format research paper buy thesis statement in a descriptive essay brave new world 1984 essay questions thesis statement examples law thesis statement breakdown buy paper writing numbers backwards recycled paper with watermark othello and desdemona essay essay of arthur miller buy paper fans online online certification courses entrance essay for grad school thesis topics pediatrics india thesis format research paper free essays on veterans essay on why should we project essay grader peg blog writing services essays on loss of innocence how to write an analysis of an issue essay open thesis definition thesis sans font admission essays that worked harvard history thesis handbook bsc thesis electrical engineering learning english is very important essay rabbit proof fence essay mr neville sample design research paper thesis topics in virology thesis on justice thesis binding malaysia thesis chapters collaborative approaches to learning essay essay check for plagiarism humanaties research paper interior design thesis research discursive essays size zero yale second essay ets gre sample argument essay production of space essay dissertations and theses lpi sat essay help conclusion paragraph examples for essays online thesis advisor sample graduate admission essays research proposal sample psychology information security term paper research essay writing topics thesis statement examples for sonny's blues ap world history dbq essay tips thesis examples in business why did the anti-federalists opposed the constitution essay essay anyone contest 2009 difference between master's thesis and doctoral dissertation science in the news coursework layout thematic essay american history short essay on romeo and juliet thesis statement for a compare and contrast essay how to write a interview essay sample creative thesis statement examples citation in thesis thesis course outline hamlet spying essay computer science engineering essay thesis format hrm critical essay on the adventure of huckleberry finn thesis binding swindon a streetcar named desire essay outline help with writing essays at university rachel carson research paper thesis on the construction industry in ghana marketing topics for thesis in mba thesis presentation defense filetype pdf proofreading native english nus thesis template thesis about history of the philippines how to write a thesis statement for dummies statistical data for project romeo and juliet movie compare and contrast essay black men in public spaces+thesis statement good phrases use essay thesis analysis data essay thesis for 1984 essay writing course online free essay on the death penalty should be abolished ms 13 essay creating a cover letter for resume author of essays on crime and punishment dissertation zusammenfassung juno and the paycock essays thesis in computer network security liver transplantation thesis global environmental problems essays thesis add custom page template term paper setup research paper note cards template employee relations essay topics free essays school uniforms energy management thesis pdf essays on save mother earth through green energy etymology word thesis thesis topics doctoral thesis wordpress theme essay diabetes mellitus free online creative writing essays definition periodical essay phd advisor leaving university working thesis generator quoting in research papers mla format sample thesis with dedication service essays conclusion for essay about myself rpi library thesis search dissertation prospectus guide soul food essay amiri baraka kubla khan essay topics thesis statement for cost of prescription medication writing outline research paper apa format dissertation assistant thesis statement letter from birmingham jail thesis binding ucl cons of racial profiling essay common college essay application topics thesis writing books free download thesis statement how to write an essay pearl harbor essay thesis relationships essay conclusion how to write an essay in mla format example where can find free avce business coursework online thesis outline chapters english 9 persuasive essays what make a hero essay essay about feminism dissertation sur la poesie de la negritude thesis statement mla format do you really know yourself essay defnition essay thesis on writing skills thesis format literature review thesis design studio college essay topics list dusty plasma thesis essays on fast food nation sample thesis or dissertation john steinbeck the pearl essay ts eliot religion and literature essay should abortion be permitted essay essay uniforms school against thesis game based learning a good thesis statement on pearl harbor vt thesis dissertation essay about classification and division writing numbers in essays apa what is thesis in writing research paper 7th grade online dissertation thesis statement examples cause and effect ayn rand institute essay contests essay on importance of communication skills in english buy an essay online death and justice essay thesis statement quiz questions thesis acknowledgement sample tagalog thesis for kite runner essay thesis font family download dedicate thesis my wife essay on lokmanya tilak in english thesis statement examples for night essay c apply texas phd thesis stress management satire essay on television thesis defense bedeutung greenspans phd thesis thesis binus ac id ecton inc case analysis essay custom term paper writing service stanford entrance essay prompt essay editing vancouver college readiness thesis short essays in hindi on holi college essay sample writings ancient egypt introduction essay conflict in teamwork essay apa guidelines for writing thesis college essay in a day essays about virginia woolf writing zen thesis hrd climate sample law essay bibliography thesis hypothesis antithesis thesis binding university of cambridge lsu graduate school thesis house of seven gables essay essays on experience my essay anti cosmic satanism best topic for college essay igcse history coursework word limit essays on the importance of friendships cornelius vanderbilt scholarship essay master's thesis research essay on natural calamities in pakistan term paper of scientific calculator very short essay on my ambition in life thesis statement examples english essay on euthanasia should be legalised classification of jobs - essay examples of literature thesis search results template research paper thesis examples introduction thesis filipino how to write good thesis for research paper proofreading freelance conclusion example paper research thesis paper help religion titles essay thesis statement great gatsby introduction to accounting coursework kaist thesis template tragic flaw essay dissertation vs thesis difference remove header padding thesis who can write my paper dissertation sujets sociaux dissertation on education closed thesis definition thesis on education in pakistan pdf sample of law essay santiago calatrava dissertation thesis ideas for art history thesis evaluation committee how to write an essay paper thesis topics related to english buy essays online urban life essay dissertation guide successful thesis persuasive essay helper dissertation upon roast pig buisness reviews essay with thesis example beowulf essay characteristics of archetypal epic hero mla essays cite crossing the bar essay phd thesis conclusion length thiess au careers job search opinion topics for research papers jazz thesis topics john brown thesis statement writing service.org research paper verb tense scientific method essay format how to write a good attention getter in an essay essay geeks jfk thesis binding galway thesis report conclusion free essays on effects of bullying essay proofreading service australia formula sa thesis essay scholarships for hs seniors current thesis topics computer science thesis about anti bullying law how to write research paper in filipino thesis statement how to do what is a reflective essay examples write formalist approach essay dissertation zeitform database thesis topics essays on minot's lust disadvantages of communication technology essays who freed the slaves essay the outsiders book vs movie essay thesis test belbin assignment writing service thesis dissertation is currently under embargo research paper problem statement why was oliver cromwell a villain essay my ambitions essay term paper requirements order of importance essay example beowulf essay prompt finance dissertation thesis ideas for statistics thesis examples for the color purple proposal and report writing research paper worksheets high school justification of the study in thesis sample science fair research paper parts order custom essay online essays on sterotypes essays on blessings of science narrative voice in essays nursing assignments buy papers online for college factory farming essay conclusion free classification essay paper thesis topics educational psychology buy paper marigolds abstract papers on marketing strategies of companies dissertation benefits of paraphrasing write internship application essay human computer interaction thesis dissertation advisor role thesis binding clapham honours thesis format coursework cover sheet uwa short essay about hari raya thesis statements for cloning classical music vs modern music essay do articles get underlined in essays thesis format rmit comparative literary analysis essays proquest dissertations canada thesis for anthropology research paper thesis preparation eckerd city or rural essay thesis ideas for globalization building services engineering dissertation topics essay on psychological approaches american autobiographical by essay i native now tell writer comparison contrast essay purpose ancient greece history essays post masters thesis thesis statement response paper how to write thesis proposals for masters baby thesis in mapeh college board essay questions buy paper stars film thesis statement examples u of s thesis award berkeley thesis deadline of nature essay for kids essay on dubai shopping festival ap world exam essay help thesis binding tullamore drug rehab research paper aqa english language and literature b coursework word count aids awareness essay in tamil language research paper topic ideas + computer science essay about any social problem thesis help australia thesis for graduate school ict coursework gcse aqa good essay topics on education rubin carter guilty essay proofreading blunders college application essay writers canada is a multicultural country essay thesis employee development essay on human values and ethics how to make a good thesis sentence thesis statement for distance education reasons to legalize weed essay embodiment essays on gender and identity thesis statement for a science research paper john keats when i have fears essay esl-cause and effect sample essay essay samples an essay on disadvantages of internet thesis generator for informative speech the age of reason thomas paine essay write good thesis outline graduation thesis defence being grounded to being in jail essay persuasive essay to get into college thesis proposal title page apa thesis jokes tagalog thesis proposal example pdf apa formatting essay examples thesis whisperer abstract thesis for film class lab report software uk liberalism essay dissertation scholarships term paper quotes american creed discrimination essay merton dissertation consent form samples how to write a concluding paragraph for a comparative essay essay about fatherhood considered common knowledge research paper greek meaning of thesis college essays goals and aspirations perfect compare and contrast thesis critical essay on the picture of dorian gray thesis paper significance of the study intermediate 1 computing studies past papers writing organizers thesis question definition essay childhood dream thesis proposal letter sample tun abdul razak biography essay conceptual framework thesis paradigm similarity thesis a sample college essay rome research paper topics short essay formulas thesis statement for zodiac killer thesis on the book of esther descriptive essay format essay on why i should be selected best book review blogs citation in thesis writing sites of urdu essays thesis editing services johannesburg business thesis topics technological revolution essay drama analysis essay example template for thesis defense presentation essay writing rubric for elementary students thesis on english language proficiency annotated bibliography template apa award winning scholarship essays parts thesis paper thesis statement holocaust essay on henry ford quotes writing service certificate resume form example psychoanalytic essay example dissertation outline writing linear equations dissertation kosten essay judging criteria help with essays assignments thesis topics english language teaching thesis competition 2011 thesis proposal computer engineering wimax+thesis paper psychiatry thesis pdf looking for alibrandi essay introduction thesis statement definition in literature help me write a paper essay rattler teachers essay thesis topics for masters in communication free essays on vulnerabilities and exploitation phd thesis dedication dissertation economique introduction attitude disability dissertation graduate people student toward undergraduate honors thesis tcu plural de thesis en ingles thesis for beauty when the other dancer is the self historical essay sample thesis adviser перевод buy paper ephemera essay evolutionary history idea ideology in science view world essay for kids on my best friend poverty crime essay thesis to compare and contrast dissertation oral defense powerpoint sample buy vellum paper sydney uvm cems honors thesis essay on knowledge comes but wisdom lingers bauhaus history essay gcse graphics coursework design ideas thesis statement on greek mythology affordable thesis writing thesis binding wicklow wsu graduate school thesis guidelines 2 essay heidegger others papers philosophical rorty volume duke fuqua essay word limit proofreading your own writing concord review sample essays thesis product development i need help writing a descriptive essay topics on autobiographical essay in a research paper where does the thesis statement go thesis fluid layout parts of essay topic introduction term paper writing in a research paper a thesis statement should good psychology essay questions physics coursework b occupational research papers marketing thesis topics for mba hg wells the red room essay buy thesis papers online opposition argument essay thesis statement in a narrative paper student sample exploratory essay biography of great leaders dissertation improvement grants nsf sociology essay colours life thesis writing methodology chapter guide questions for essay 2003 ap world history dbq essay website that counts words in an essay buy paper mache skull chronological order essays thesis citation harvard style sample essay community service argument thesis ideas aqa a level english literature b example essays thesis on fast food restaurants architectural thesis projects theseus and hippolyta in greek mythology essay writing activities essay writting service german marshall fund essay competition history master's thesis topics visual verbal essay trc south africa essay job satisfaction literature review thesis master's thesis format pay for essay cheap research paper computer science write an expository essay on abuse thesis of a paper definition define thesis in a sentence nature vs nurture intelligence essay thesis dedication parents research essay topics for european history environment protection essay in tamil sessay yorkshire essay theory of demographic transition research paper survey literature thesis building construction rephrase thesis conclusion rainbow gathering photo essay buy paper flowers bulk distinctive voice essay dance topics essay wrongful conviction essay essay on bullying yale graduate school thesis guidelines george milton character essay sample scope and delimitation of thesis auto paraphrasing great wall of china essays essays of eb white download university of north texas dissertation dedication of thesis to husband thesis activity based costing tufts university supplement essay 2011 list of best topic for a research paper thesis format ecu discursive essay on animal testing rashtriya ekta essay thesis preliminary outline essay brotherhood essay on dulce et decorum est analysis free essay romantic music chapter 4 thesis about bullying cotton paper without watermark lord flies dynamic character essay apa thesis headings format get research paper started thesis binding acton texas republican platform critical thinking essays + student counci overpopulation research paper outline writing help affordable thesis writing services mozart research paper essays on how the media affects body images thesis statement examples about abortion psychology internship essays thesis-education.gr thesis characteristics and format master thesis activity based costing sat essay samples and scores proofreading yahoo thesis operational framework what should the introduction of a persuasive essay contain essay miyake perfume surrealist research paper cranfield thesis template download i need a essay for phd thesis structures essay on it industry dissertation rubric buy thesis proposal should abortion illegal essay thesis statement for gun control research paper university essay writing conclusion sociolinguistics term paper writing a science report proofreading practice test writing prompts reddit free homework help thesis on mammalian hemoglobin thesis proposal evaluation criteria my best gift essay college essay about parents divorce thesis statement for history day help writing dissertation a formal essay africa current essay green heart in note time tree atticus finch characterization essay physiology essays essay - financial aid scholarship essays on pro immigration thesis in analytical essay explanitory essays buy kraft paper envelopes thesis editing services philippines essay on iran contra affair thesis defense presentation pdf essay example persuasive proofreading korea types of exemplification essays college essay personal sample statement healthcare management entrance essay in a research paper where does the thesis go construction law thesis examples of annotated bibliography apa style an essay on television samples of research papers in apa format objectivism essay sample pharmcas personal essay essays research papers thesis statement examples for argumentative papers proofreader online aqa a2 history coursework 2010 college essays ethical dilemmas art school essay questions 5 steps to writing a research paper guide to the successful thesis and dissertation conception to publication apa research paper sample writing thesis topics for masters in hospital administration best thesis for a compare-and-contrast essay review of related literature in thesis sample ap environmental science essay 2001 dbq thesis generator essay on john f kennedy assassination science fair project thesis statement anne diary essay frank buy real diploma funny admissions essay choosing a thesis for a research paper nyu economics thesis 2008 thesis rewriter difference between thesis and conclusion thesis hv venti price essay topics helping others essay medical school admission resurrection a tale of two cities essay thesis statement on jane austen sample outline for informative research paper what to include in your dental school application essay narrative essay on lying jekyll and hyde essay setting thesis ucl tips writing 1st class dissertation ucf thesis defense announcement thesis search box the help by kathryn stockett essay thesis soft binding cambridge evaluating essays topics urban planning coursework book title in essay italics thesis defense committee invitation essays on computers today proofreading editing marks oedipus rex essays on irony i cant write my essay thesis statement on iraq war write my assignment short answer question thesis statement teenage pregnancy shooting stars essay analysis personal essay examples graduate school buy paper roses online ap english research paper rubric thesis editing services ireland proofreading linguee essay about third year life integrity essays x term paper thesis help research paper thesis format mcgill cfad thesis guide essays on china's political system what is a powerpoint presentation thesis statement martin luther king jr outline and thesis statement guide appendix h who will do my homework prescribed essay hypothetical thesis essay writing website reviews harry potter essays topics proofreding synopsis thesis mba sample essay about introduce myself essay editing free essays empathy counselling describe artwork essay thesis binding hamilton research paper network security essay what i know about my rights and responsibilities what is racism essay introduction thesis in a doll's house makes educated person essay shooting an elephant and other essays pdf sample research papers adhd boston university application essay sample thesis about inventory system research paper nursing topics thesis binding kerry law thesis conclusion thesis chapters dissertation coaching services war of the worlds comparison essay performance enhancing drugs in sports persuasive essay sample dental school admission essays research paper writing service uk free book summaries critical essays ref william faulkner solar energy essay introduction cv writing service bath renata raksha essay thesis writing design personal reflective essay tips emory scholars essay example thesis about workbook thesis solar power system thomas becket biography essays thesis ideas for the giver bernini baroque essay best essay sites free thesis statement generator for research paper free ged scoring essay content writing services vancouver title page layout term paper new york city teaching fellows essay artemis fowl essay write my paper college billy budd analysis essay thesis summary template thesis for response essay writing prompts for 5th grade practice writing paper free sample essays for the toefl writing test examples controversy essays short essay on the environment buy philosophy essay thesis for critical essay the awekening essay life experience essay example thesis on bullying research paper are essay writing services legal chapter 2 dissertation personal statement essay grad school dr jekyll and mr hyde coursework essay geology thesis outline outline of thesis proposal sample baby thesis chapter 1 thesis introduction sample tourism research paper latex buy essay webs com what is cultural literacy essay estee lauder essay thesis topics about technology best article writing service the king's shadow essay dissertation topics services marketing essays on theatre of cruelty essayer subjonctif bscs thesis sample dissertation chair california bar exam essay topics frequency not using i in an essay archaeology thesis online thesis-based writing assignments evaluative essay samples greek mythology theseus adventures essay paragraph order of importance i am sasha essay online editor essay for national junior honor society master thesis in information security sports studies dissertation ideas essays about rodeo thesis statement generator for history example essays on scholarships jane collier an essay on the art of ingeniously tormenting research paper thesis great gatsby essay colors proofreading verb tense worksheet essay in apa 6th edition thesis writing help uk thesis qualitative research stanford mba essay help poverty economics essay thesis topics hospital administration outline and thesis statement guide appendix f our town essays appreciate life the yellow wallpaper essay feminism thesis assistance essays twelfth night thesis on construction procurement i am very bothered simon armitage essay health economics dissertations zno thin film thesis essay on climate change for kids birmingham campaign essays thesis writing using lyx ttu grad school thesis guidelines biotechnology essay questions buy a diploma or ged writers writing service thesis greek hero short essay speeches how to write your thesis statement buy paper birch trees