Share
The text of Keynote Speech by
Luk Bouckaert
Emeritus Professor of Ethics at the Catholic University of Leuven (K.U. Leuven, Belgium) &European SPES Forum
Can Spirituality save the World?
Presented at
12th Annual GCGI International Conference and the 2nd Joint GCGI and SES Forum
The Value of Values: Spiritual Wisdom in Everyday Life”
31 August- 4 September, 2014
Waterperry House, Oxford
2014 Oxford Program 
Abstract 
Can Spirituality save the World?

Is the world driven by politics of power, economics of greed and a cultural ethos of consumerism?  At first glance, it seems that many political and economic events can be explained by these narrow drivers of individual and collective ego-centrism. However, there are countervailing powers at work.  A growing number of people from different religions, nationalities, political parties, scientific disciplines or social classes become aware that we reached the limits of our current system of ego-centric growth.  In interviews enlightened business leaders speak about their interest in Zen or other meditative practices.

In this paper I will focus on the shift from business rationality to business spirituality? Is it only a change in vocabulary or does it reveal a deeper (r)evolution? Although spirituality clearly implies an inward movement unlocking the inner self in depth, it simultaneously reconnects the self to the outer world generating a personalized sense of responsibility for the whole. How can we integrate this spiritual sensitivity in a theoretical framework that can support a sustainable and coherent managerial practice?

We will first explore some paradoxes in current economic rationality such as the ethics management paradox,  the happiness paradox and the sustainability paradox. Second, we will elucidate the distinction between rational and spiritual knowledge and explain why spiritual knowledge can help us to understand and solve these paradoxes.  In the last section I will propose some reflections for a spiritual-based theory and practice of leadership linking spirituality to the work floor of daily life.

Good morning Ladies and Gentlemen,

Can Spirituality save the world? This is not meant as rhetoric but as an open question. Answering ‘yes it can’, might sound very great but also very naïve. It is not realistic to assume that our great-grandchildren will live in a world without greed, dominance and competition. Answering ‘no’ or ‘mission impossible’ would express defeatism and make our gathering here completely redundant. By joining this conference we express at least the implicit belief that spirituality as a factor of social change can make a difference. 

Spirituality as a lever of change has a completely other modus operandi than other factors of change such as HR management, ethical codes, CSR regulations, reputation management, legal regulations, taxation policies etc.  Spirituality relates a person or an organization to its soul or to its inner self. Hence spiritual changes do not operate from external conditions and incentives but from within, from an inward movement unlocking the inner self in depth. In section 1 I will tackle the question ‘Why do we need such an inner directed movement in economic and social life’? Section 2 explains how spirituality leads to a revision of some basic concepts such as happiness or ethics. In the third section I will elaborate on the nature and source of spirituality. The last section deals with the practice of spiritual-based leadership

The paradoxes of economic life: or why we need spirituality?

We can sum up many reasons to introduce spirituality in social and economic life?  Some will stress that we live in a VUCA world: a world characterized by a high degree of Volatility, Uncertainty, Complexity and Ambiguity. Because we can no longer control such a volatile and uncertain world on the basis of econometric and rational models, we need a higher type of holistic knowledge to anticipate the future. Hence spirituality is used as a container concept for all these meta-rational forms of knowledge which we call wisdom, intuition, spiritual intelligence, meditation or mindfulness etc. and which empower us to cope with the uncertainties of the VUCA world.

Another line of argumentation starts from the observed lack of trust in organizations. The Edelman Trust Barometer gives us an idea of the decreasing trust in political, religious, social and financial institutions. Besides market failures, we are confronted with political and moral failures. Our media are full of stories of corruption, fraud, scandals and misuse. Hence, in order to give  our institutions a new credibility, we should renew their foundation.  What is mostly needed is a new type of leaders whom we can trust because of their inner integrity, inspiring vision and social empathy. Spirituality emerged in business ethics in the beginning of this century through the mediation of transformative leadership theory and practice. I will come back to this leadership practice in section 3. 

Although the arguments of the VUCA world and of trustful leadership are good entrees to introduce the need of spirituality in social life, they don’t inform as much about the kind of spirituality we need to overcome the problems of distrust and uncertainty. In my view a complementary approach is to focus on the paradoxical features of our current economic and social system. Paradoxes are problems that cannot be solved within the existing logic. They reveal an unsolvable contradiction. The only way to solve them is to transform our way of looking at things. As Einstein has reminded us: We cannot solve our problems with the same thinking we used when we created them. In this perspective spirituality can be viewed as a heuristic to solve unsolvable problems (Schumacher, 2004).[1]

We will confine us here to two paradoxes that are manifest today for many observers. They are called the ‘paradox of happiness’ and the ‘ethics management paradox’ (Bouckaert, 2007 & 2006).

The happiness paradox

The happiness paradox has a long history. Even within the utilitarian tradition the paradox was stated by John Stuart Mill, saying that people fixed on the goal of happiness will not be the happiest people. The paradox is cultivated in many spiritual traditions warning us against the illusion that more material wealth makes us more happy. In contrast with all this warnings economists are used to define happiness as the maximum utility or pleasure we can get from the realisation of all our needs and preferences given the constraints of budget and time. By economising scarce means and time, they assume that happiness will always increase.

Easterlin (1974) was the first economist to put the correlation between economic growth and happiness into question on the basis of statistical research. He found that in international comparisons, the average reported level of happiness did not vary much with national income per person, at least for countries with income sufficient to meet basic needs. Similarly, although income per person rose steadily in the United States between 1946 and 1970, average reported happiness showed no long-term trend and declined between 1960 and 1970. The self-evident correlation between growth of income and happiness was broken. The Easterlin paradox was the start of an ongoing body of research, called happiness economics. But simultaneously, it opened a philosophical debate. If it is true that more income and more welfare state do not create more happiness, why should we always strive for more economic growth, more income and more welfare state.[2]

The ethics management paradox

The ethics management paradox is based on an observation in the field of business (Bouckaert, 2006). Business ethics gained more and more attention in the eighties and nineties of the last century. One of the basic arguments in this rise of business ethics was the argument that in the long run ethics pays, hence ethics is a good investment for the company and its stakeholders. However, we can easily observe that a lot of companies or organisations involved in ethics programmes and using ethical language do not always display genuine ethical commitment once confronted with a difficult situation. An example of this in my country was the closing of a Renault plant in Brussels in the 1997. Renault at that time developed an ethos of participation and cooperation on the factory floor but, once it was confronted with a problem of long term profitability, forgot completely about its stakeholder philosophy and fired more than three thousand employees without prior communication or negotiation. This is just one example of how business ethics proclaimed on the factory floor was disclaimed on the level of decision-making. The crucial point was not that companies sometimes need to close a plant for reasons of long term profitability but the way it was done without negotiation and communication. The result of the highly discussed case in Belgium was a growing distrust of managerial ethical discourse. Other business scandals in the late nineties (Enron, Lernaut&Hauspie, Worldcom a.o.) and more recently during the banking crisis revealed the same phenomenon: more ethics management does not guarantee  more ethical commitment. Analogously to the happiness paradox teaching us that more welfare does not necessarily create more happiness, we can observe that more ethics management does not necessarily create more ethics in management.

Towards a spiritual understanding of reality

In the nineteenth century Karl Marx was convinced that a paradigm shift to scientific materialism was needed to understand and solve the contradictions of the economics of capitalism. To-day, we need a spiritual understanding of reality to solve the current contradictions of our economic system.[3] Following this argument implies that we should introduce spirituality in our concepts of happiness and ethics to understand and solve the paradoxes.

Revising happiness

Economists define happiness as the maximization of pleasure (utility) through the optimal realisation of our basic needs and preferences.  But this is only half a truth. Apart from our capability to maximise pleasure from the fulfillment of our needs and preferences, human happiness greatly depends on the quality of human relations: family relations, authentic friendship, good professional relations with colleagues and peers etc. The key point here is that the quality of human relations cannot be reduced to the economic notion of maximising pleasure. Let me illustrate it with the example of friendship. 

Defining friendship as the maximisation of pleasure drawn from an encounter with a friend would reduce the presence of my friend to a means for maximising my own happiness. Most of us will realise that such an approach is deemed to fail. A flourishing friendship needs at least a tacit commitment to keep the friendship alive even if it implies a cost in terms of pleasure. Too much focus on maximising feelings of pleasure undermines the genuine commitment of the relation. Moreover, it will reduce friendship to a consumption good submitted to the economic law of decreasing marginal utility. Our feelings of friendship will decrease and burn out (as we see in so many relations). This is exactly what the happiness paradox reveals: the more we focus upon maximising happiness as a pleasure, the less we will get it. This makes clear that the source of genuine and endurable friendship does not lay in the fulfillment of our own need of affection but in the commitment to endorse each other’s life in good and bad days. Only by this commitment beyond egocentrism can friendship escape the decreasing curb of marginal utility. 

From the example of friendship we may learn that human happiness has a dual nature. It only partly results from our rational capability of maximising pleasure. More important is the spiritual capability of self-gift and reciprocal commitment. This is not only true for friendship: all genuine human relations require a particular non egocentric commitment. If we want to restore a positive relation between happiness and economics, we have to focus on the quality of human relations. Pleasure and utility cannot be the ultimate concepts of economics. We should integrate the relational and spiritual view of happiness within economics and business.

Revising ethics

In a similar way as we unveiled the dual nature of happiness we should realise the dual nature of ethics. Ethics has, at the same time, an instrumental/rational and a non-instrumental/intrinsic meaning. Economists focusing exclusively on the instrumental or rational use of things, approaches ethics as a tool to realise some external goals such as a better reputation, lower transaction costs, reduction of risk, cooperation of stakeholders, goals which at the end can improve profit for a company.

There is nothing wrong with this rational and instrumental use of ethics as far as it does not crowd out the intrinsic and genuine meaning of ethics. Precisely this crowding out mechanism – replacing moral feelings by economic incentives – is at work in the many failures of business ethics in the IT and banking sector. It explains very well our paradox: the more (rational) ethics management, the less (genuine) ethics in management. If our ethical behavior is mainly driven by external goals and incentives, ethics will be applied in a very selective and opportunistic way and at the end be crowded out. The call for more spirituality in business and leadership is an effort to restore the balance between instrumental and intrinsic use of ethics in business.

But the difficult point here is to define what we mean by intrinsic motivation? It does not suffice to say that intrinsic motivation implies that our behavior is not driven by external goals such as good reputation, profit making or a competitive advantage. If we do not explain the nature and source of the  inner commitment, we will not understand why spirituality is needed.  For most philosophers the Kantian and rational answer will suffice. In a Kantian perspective, intrinsic motivation means that the good we want to do is good in and for itself and can be considered as a basic and necessary good for every human being.  

The Kantian definition is right but highly abstract. We can easily agree on the Kantian principles and remain selectively blind for our own unethical behavior or being morally disengaged in everyday life. Therefore, instead of a rational based ethics characterized by abstract principles and deductions, we need an experience-based approach to ethics unlocking and motivating our personal, inner self. Here spirituality as a personal search for meaning and purpose in life comes in. But to make the case of spirituality more convincing, we have to clarify what we mean by it. 

The nature and source of spirituality

Defining spirituality is not an easy task. In the SPES network[4] we define spirituality as people’s multiform search for meaning interconnecting them with all living beings and to ‘God’ or ‘Ultimate Reality’. The key word of this definition is ‘interconnecting’ and I believe that this is the hallmark for an experience based definition of spirituality. However I would like to suggest a somewhat lighter version of the SPES definition: Spirituality is a way of thinking and living that originates from deep and personal experiences of interconnectedness.   This statement focuses on two points: first, the origin of spirituality lays in deep and personal experiences of interconnectedness; second, spirituality coincides with a specific way of thinking and living. The last point is important. Without critical reflection (thinking) and concrete practices (living) spirituality runs the risk to fall in subjectivism and escapism.

Some approaches of spirituality are stressing so much the experiential and mystical part as to lose the input of critical and reflective thinking while other definitions are too philosophical and miss the personal and existential search for meaning. No less misleading is a one-sided focus on practical effects   reducing spirituality to an instrument of stress reduction, work motivation or therapeutic recovery. To give spirituality a solid foundation a good balance between inner experience, reason and practice is required.

Religion, ethics and spirituality are not the same. The three domains are different but complementary expressions of the human search for values, meaning and purpose in life. Religion keeps alive transcendent values and moral norms through institutionalized rituals, ceremonies and traditions; ethics creates values, rights and norms by education, public debate and legal regulations; spirituality discloses its values of deep interconnection through a process of inward reflection and personal search for meaning. Historically, there have been many conflicts between spiritual committed persons and established religious  and moral systems. Yet in my view spirituality remains  the inner source of religion and ethics. Religions always have been founded and renewed by spiritual leaders and ethics remain abstract without spiritual motivation and commitment. Despite bloody and cruel conflicts I believe that an ongoing process of alignment takes place between religious faith, spiritual experience and human rights ethics. 

As said, spirituality originates from deep and personal experiences of interconnectedness which are accessible for every human being. These experiences are very different from the digital and technology-driven forms of connection via internet. To some extent digital globalization disconnects people from their roots and communities. The inward search for spiritual interconnectedness may be considered as a way to cope with the negative effects of global disconnectedness. 

Experiences of spiritual interconnectedness can take many shapes and expressions but they all have in common a deep sense of being part of a greater whole or flow. Just to mention some examples[5]. On some privileged days we experience nature as an overwhelming source of life and beauty eliciting deep feelings of awe, gratitude and interconnectedness. At such moments we feel life as a gift and as a flow of co-creativity. Religious people relates this experience of life as a gift to God as the ultimate Giver. But even without religious reference we can experience ourselves as deeply part and gift of Nature. The deep ecology movement is an expression of this experience.

Another deep feeling of interconnectedness comes into being when we are confronted with the vulnerability of things – be it the defenselessness of children, the suffering of people, the voicelessness of future generations, the threatened species of animals or the vulnerability of our overexploited planet itself. Vulnerability, breaking open our comfort zone, spontaneously awakens in our mind and heart an inner sense of empathy, compassion and co-responsibility According to the French philosopher, Emmanuel Levinas, the traumatic confrontation with situations of human vulnerability is the genuine source of social ethics.

In all these experiences of interconnectedness we see a double movement at work. On the one side there is an inward movement. We are deeply touched – in our mind and heart - by a suffering face, an unexpected encounter, a challenging situation. We are not producing or making the experience in an active way. A deep experience overwhelms us. We are  in a passive but very alert modus. At that moment we coincide – be it for just a moment - with the other or with the inner flow of life.

On the other hand the dynamics of interconnectedness also reveal an ethical movement from the self to the other. In her magnificent work The Silent Cry: Mysticism and Resistance (Minneapolis, Fortress Press, 2001) Dorothée Sölle nicely demonstrates how the mystical experience of interconnectedness generates an inner call for social action to save the world. Spiritual persons are empowered to resist consumerism and opportunism and to take unexpected initiatives to ‘save the world’.

A recent example of the link between spirituality and social activism is the  provocative  essay, Time for Outrage ( Indignez-vous), a 35-page book written by Stéphane Hessel in 2010 at the age of 93. The essay sold 3 million copies in 30 languages and inspired protests like Occupy in the United States and The Indignados in Spain. Stéphane Hessel calls us to give more space to the emotion of moral indignation in order to generate concrete actions of solidarity. He wrote “The worst possible outlook is indifference that says, “I can’t do anything about it; I’ll just get by.” Behaving like that deprives you of one of the essentials of being human: the capacity and the freedom to feel outraged. That freedom is indispensable, as is the political involvement that goes with it.”

However we must be careful with feelings of moral indignation. Moral indignation runs the risk to generate feelings of vengeance and blind violence. History teaches us  that a deep spiritual experience of interconnectedness is needed to keep our moral indignation free from them. It is the greatness of leaders such as Mahatma Gandhi and Nelson Mandela to keep the emotion of moral indignation in alignment with the spirit of universal interconnectedness. By this reference to leaders such as Gandhi or Mandela  I come to my last section: the practice of spiritual-based leadership which links mysticism with social activism.   

The practice of leadership 

In current theory of leadership, the distinction between the rational manager and the value-driven leader is mostly linked to the distinction between transactional and transformative leadership  (Bass, 1990).  While the aim of transactional leadership is to motivate and direct people through rewards and punishment, transformational leadership is focused on transforming people by creating a new vision and a shared set of values in an organization. Transforming people through shared values requires a growing relation of partnership and open communication which generates trust and intrinsic motivation. Transformational leadership integrates the themes of empowerment, charisma, servant leadership and value-driven management.

However it is important to realise that within the range of transformative leadership there are many types to distinguish. Steve Jobs has been a very charismatic leader gifted with good intuitions and able to motivate people but his practice of leadership was primarily driven by market imperatives, creation of shareholder value and strict operational control. Business leaders as Lars Kolind (Oticon) or Muhammed Yunus (Grameen bank) gives more attention to the personal sense of co-responsibility and co-creativity of people and to the creation of meaning in work. Still other charismatic leaders follow an aristocratic model of leadership leading to a paternalistic and hierarchic type of governance. 

To get more grip on the ambiguities and different models within transformative leadership, we can structure the field on the basis of two axes: a vertical axe representing the tension between a market driven and a spirit centered idea of leadership, and a horizontal axe representing the tension between an aristocratic and a democratic vision of leadership. Each quadrant refers to a specific type of transformational leadership. Of course, real leaders are often a mix of the ideal types but there is always a dominant characteristic.  The key assumption of the spiritual-based model of leadership is the idea of being interconnected not only by market relations but by a primary sense of shared co-creativity and co-responsibility. Because of this spiritual link, every person has in his/her function a potential to lead and to follow. Its style of communication empowers people and fosters social relations of trust, reciprocity and interconnectedness.

Market

Market leadership                        CSR Leadership

(Shareholder value)                     (stakeholder value)

Aristocracy                                                             D       Democracy

Aristocratic leadership              Spiritual-based leadership

(top-down inspiration)                     (co-creation of meaning)

Spirit

Fig. 1 Types of transformational leadership

More challenging than making a nice typology of leadership styles, is the question how to start a practice of spiritual-based entrepreneurship and leadership? When entrepreneurs ask me where to start, I always answer that they are the starting point. In all spiritual traditions self knowledge and self transformation are the first steps to enlightenment. Without an effort of self reflection and self transformation, spiritual and ethical programmes in business will remain manipulative management tools for good reputation and  window dressing. Therefore the first step is asking oneself who I am, what is the meaning and purpose of my own life, what inspires me, how can I make good decisions? Next to this step of self-disclosure (unlocking the inner self) comes the passion for quality and, as a third step, creating conditions for co-creative communication. Within the Belgian SPES Academy we developed a series of workshops in order to facilitate these steps.

Unlocking the inner self 

To facilitate the first step, for some years already SPES organizes a workshop entitled ‘Thinkers for Doers’. The philosophy behind the workshop is that reading together a brief but well selected master text in spirituality is a more easy way for self disclosure than the method of direct introspection. We need a mirror to see ourselves in the right way. Therefore we read eye opening text fragments from the Buddhist, the Christian, the Sufi, the Socratic tradition as well as from modern philosophers and poets. All text fragments are helpful to distinguish the difference between the rational ego and the inner or spiritual self.  After a brief introduction, the participants read the text personally and in group. After this, they are invited to apply the text to their own lives and experiences.

To give an example. One of the texts I like to read in the workshop is a poem of Lao Tzu from the Tao Te Ching  (poem 48 in the translation of Stephen Mitchell, 1988).

“In pursuit of knowledge,
every day something is added.
In the practice of the Tao,
every day something is dropped.
Less and less do you need to force things,
until finally you arrive at non-action.
When nothing is done,
nothing is left undone.
True mastery can be gained
by letting things go their own way.
It can't be gained by interfering.”

The poem invites the reader to understand the distinction between the rational and the spiritual self or between rational and spiritual intelligence. In contrast to rational thinking, spiritual intelligence is presented by Lao Tzu as a process of ‘dropping every day something’ until you arrive at a stage of non-action. The process is very similar to what the Greek philosopher Socrates has in mind as the first and most fundamental prerequisite to gain wisdom: we must discover in our mind  a point of not knowing – ‘I know that I do not know’.  So the relevant question for the workshop is: do we recognise in our mind such a point prior to action and rational knowledge?  Can we trust that point of ‘spiritual intelligence’ as a source of creativity and decision making? As you can imagine, such a workshop opens a space for deep questions. These are not pragmatic questions about how to do things but questions about being before doing.

A passion for quality in work

To facilitate the second step, we started as a joint venture between the SPES Academy and UNIZO, the Belgian Union for independent entrepreneurs a project called Inspirational Entrepreneurship. The idea was very simple: if you want to know how spiritual-based leadership works, confront yourself with a spirit-driven entrepreneur.  Ask him/her where the spiritual and ethical drive comes from and how it makes a difference in terms of strategy, human resource management, marketing, profit sharing, communication and community involvement? Every year with a group of interested entrepreneurs we visit a series of small and medium sized companies. Reports of the visits are published in booklets. (5) One of the most striking characteristics of spirit driven entrepreneurship that we discovered during these visits, was their particular passion for the quality and authenticity of their product. 

Hard working entrepreneurs are not eager to speak much about spirituality. They don’t like grand statements and do not use an explicit spiritual vocabulary. They prefer to speak about the quality and authenticity of their product. An authentic product cannot be reduced to its functional and economic utility. One of the entrepreneurs we visited, a coffee-maker, spoke about his product in a very revealing way. For him, coffee was a relational good linking farmers in the South with coffee drinkers in the North. He informed us about the different kind of beans and their ecological environment, the problems of transport and the delicate process of production. He introduced coffee as a cultural good: a ritual that begins and structures our day and helps people to talk to each other. From his passion for coffee we can learn that spiritual-based entrepreneurship is not primarily about good stakeholder management. Just as the inspiration of an artist does not depend on how (s)he relates to other people but on how (s)he creates meaning through his/her work of art, so the spirituality of an entrepreneur is mainly expressed in his/her passion for a product that creates meaning and interconnectedness.

Creating conditions for co-creative communication

The third step to practice spiritual-based leadership is the creation of good communication. In most approaches good communication is seen as a means to realize the goals of a company expressed by its shareholders or stakeholders. If we adhere to the shareholder vision of a company, we will interpret communication as an instrument to create maximum value for shareholders. In the case of a stakeholder vision good communication will be measured by its capacity to create an added value for all the stakeholders. But in both cases communication will still remain a tool for disciplining people rather than a genuine conversation.

Spiritual-based leadership opens another, non-instrumental view of communication. It defines communication as the process of creating a co-responsible and co-creative community. The reference point is no longer a set of goals and targets but a shared sense of community and commitment. If communication is too much instrumentalised in function of goals and targets, it will fail in mobilizing people and engaging employees.  Transformative and relational language has another logic than informative and instrumental language. Transformative language creates meaning and a sense of moral co-ownership while instrumental language reduces the actors to their functional use.  

Whatever their juridical statute, all persons co-creating value and investing time, money, talent or trust in a company are, ethically spoken, co-owners of a company. However, to be fully realized, the ethical claim of co-ownership needs to be completed with a formal and contractual structure of stakeholder participation. But a formal structure of participation never guarantees the inner spirit of co-creativity and co-responsibility. Empirical research indicates that despite many managerial efforts, a genuine spirit of co-ownership  is rather rare. It requires a sense of leadership based on relations of mutual trust, reciprocity and open communication.  According to Gallup's new 142-country study on the State of the Global Workplace (Gallup Report, 2013) only 13% of employees worldwide are engaged at work, 24% are actively disengaged and 63 % feel no genuine interest or commitment in their work.

The following example taken from F.D. Jensen (1996)  may illustrate the power of trust-based leadership. The example tells us the story of Oticon, a Danish company with branches worldwide that sell hearing-aids and related technologies. Until the 1990s the company was structured according to the traditional model of bureaucratic rationality: a clear hierarchical pyramid, divided into departments each of which is responsible for managing its own affairs, quantitative economic goals as standards for measuring and monitoring success, emphasis on formal procedures. In the beginning of the 1990s,  the dollar fell to half its value in Danish crowns. This meant a catastrophic decline in revenue for Oticon, since its most important market was in the United States. The company was facing a crisis. Meetings were held left and right, but the loss of control continued to rise. The Board of Directors pulled the emergency brake. The eight executive directors were dismissed and Lars Kolind, manager of a high tech firm (Radiometer Inc.) was hired as director. In response to the crisis, he developed an ambitious vision for the Oticon group: Oticon was to be restructured into an ‘anthropocentric network’ that grew to become a world leader in audiology and within five years became listed on the Danish stock market.

Kolind’s basic philosophy consisted of dismantling bureaucratic rationality and creating in its place a ‘moral free space’, a space for freedom and personal responsibility. In practice, this meant the abolition of all titles and departmental structures, of fixed working hours, of clearly defined jobs; moreover, all information apart from a few confidential details was to be made accessible to everyone. Kolind wanted a company that was structurally comparable to the human brain: chaotic, non-hierarchical and effective. Each person was able to make suggestions and proposals directly to Kolind himself. If anyone did not receive a reply within twenty-four hours he or she could consider the suggestion as having been accepted, and could count on the means for realising it. If Kolind was unavailable to receive the suggestion, one could add a surcharge for the lost time (in the form of an internal interest payment) to the project.

Not everyone could adapt to Kolind’s style, which called for a high degree of personal responsibility and creativity. Some left the company. When the group succeeded in designing a new hearing system based on digital technology, the company made a leap forward. Kolind’s style had evidently released people’s self-confidence and creativity. He described the core of his leadership in the following way: ‘The key lies in the notion of trust. No one can resist trust. The basic assumption that guides my notion of leadership is that the personnel will only take responsibility for itself and look after the common good if management is able to create an environment that promotes trust and autonomy.’ (Jensen, 1996: 26)

Conclusions

How can we foster spiritual awareness as a lever for a new period of global social and economic ‘renaissance’?   

First, we should view spirituality as a public good and not just as a private matter. People from different religions, nationalities, political parties, scientific disciplines or social classes become aware that we reached the limits of our  current system of ego-centric growth and rational management. Paradoxes in economic and social life reveal the limits and contradictions. Without a full understanding of these paradoxes, we will be unable to realize the spiritual correction that is needed.

Second, if we want to foster spirituality in public and social life, we must start with unlocking our own spiritual self as a presence of deep interconnectedness. This requires an ongoing process of reflection, self criticism, listening to our inner intuitions and learning from the wisdom of other people. Without this effort, spirituality will end up in subjectivism and escapism.

Third, we have to translate spirituality from a personal to an organizational level. This implies that an organization learns to think and act from an inner mission and value system and not only from current market incentives and ad hoc opportunities.  Spiritual-based leadership is the art of disclosing the capacity of an organization to think and act as a co-responsible and value-driven community. To-day we call this capacity of thinking and acting as a co-creative an co-responsible community the spiritual capital of an organization.  In this perspective, business spirituality can be defined as management of an organization’s spiritual capital. 

References

Bass, B. M.,1990. “From transactional to transformational leadership: Learning to share the      vision”. In: Organizational Dynamics, (Winter), pp.19-31.

Bouckaert, L. 2006. “The Ethics Management Paradox” in: Zsolnai, L. (ed): Interdisciplinary      Yearbook of Business Ethics. Peter Lang, Oxford, 2006, pp. 199-202 and pp. 215-219.

Bouckaert, L. & Zsolnai L (eds). 2007. Spirituality as a public good, Antwerp, Garant (European SPES Cahier 1).

Bouckaert, L. 2011. “Spirituality and Rationality” In: Bouckaert, L. & Zsolnai, L.(eds), The Palgrave Handbook of Spirituality and Business, Palgrave Macmillan, Hampshire, pp.       18-26.

Bouckaert, L. Opdebeeck, H. and Zsolnai, L. (eds) 2008. Frugality: Rebalancing Material and Spiritual Values in Economic Life. 2008. Peter Lang, Oxford.

Bouckaert, L. 2013. “Schumacher and the Principle of Responsibility in Economics” In:      Opdebeeck H., Responsible Economics. E.F.Schumacher and his Legacy for the 21st        Century, Peter Lang, Oxford, pp.209-225.

Easterlin, R. 1974. “Does Economic Growth Improve the Human Lot? Some Empirical       Evidence.” In: Paul A. David and Melvin W. Reder (eds), Nations and Households in         Economic Growth: Essays in Honor of Moses Abramovitz, New York, Academic Press,       Inc.

Gallup Report, 2013, State of the Global Workplace: Employee Engagement Insights for   Business Leaders Worldwide, www.gallup.com/poll/116431/research-reports.aspx

Hessel Stéphane, 2011, Time for Outrage. Charles Glass Books, London. The original French title           Indignez-vous! was  published in 2010, Indigène, Montpellier , 32 pages.

Jensen, F. D. 1996. “Ethics at work”. Siena, Research Paper presented at EBEN Conference.

Lao Tzu, 1988. Tao The Ching (translated by Stephen Mitchell), Frances Lincoln, London.

Levinas, E. 1974. Totalité et Infini. The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff.

Schumacher, E.F. 2004 (first edition 1977). A Guide for the Perplexed. London: Harper Perennial.

Sölle Dorothée, The Silent Cry: Mysticism and Resistance. Minneapolis, Fortress Press. 


[1] See F. Schumacher about the solution of divergent problems in his Guide for the Perplexed, chapter 10 (Schumacher ,2004).

[2] Even within a modern welfare state with a balanced system of social security, the correlation  between social happiness and social welfare remains problematic. How to explain in a well developed welfare state the rising rates of depression, stress, burn-out, suicide and loss of meaning in life?

[3] This is not a new idea. The claim of ‘spirituality first’ and the search for integral humanism as a consequence of it, were already made during the interbellum period in Europe by personalist thinkers such as Jacques Maritain and Emmanuel Mounier and expressed in the Journal Esprit (Spirit). (1) Some years before, the Indian philosopher and  poet Rabindranath Tagore made a similar claim and gave it an Indian expression in the Visva Bharati University and its claim to combine human science and spirituality. The European SPES Forum is a network that tries to keep alive this legacy of spirituality in economic and social life. Our situation today makes the claim of ‘spirituality first’ only more timely and relevant.

[4] SPES is a Belgian and international network aiming at disclosing spirituality as a lever of economic and social progress. SPES means hope but is also used as an acronym for Spirituality in Economics and Society. See www.eurospes.be & www.spesforum.be

[5] Besides the two examples given in the  paper (natural mysticism and the experience of vulnerability) we may think of deep experiences of silence, genuine conversation, prayer  or shared religious rituals as ways to disclose interconnectedness. 

Go to top
Notice: Undefined index: adv in /home/kamranmofid/public_html/templates/jsn_epic_pro/index.php on line 654
purdue graduate school thesis office osu graduate school thesis template harvard graduate school of design thesis penn state graduate school thesis office graduate school purdue thesis template graduate school purdue thesis uq graduate school thesis preparation uri graduate school thesis proposal graduate school penn state thesis purdue graduate school thesis submission school of graduate studies queen's thesis uq graduate school thesis review unc graduate school thesis requirements unsw graduate research school thesis submission graduate school sample thesis uq graduate school thesis submission warwick graduate school thesis submission durham graduate school thesis submission uga graduate school thesis submission hku graduate school thesis submission unc graduate school thesis submission ttu graduate school thesis submission usc graduate school thesis submission duke graduate school thesis submission ucl graduate school thesis submission cornell graduate school thesis submission msu graduate school thesis submission uw graduate school thesis submission siuc graduate school thesis graduate school thesis topics uf graduate school thesis template uga graduate school thesis template utep graduate school thesis template ust graduate school thesis template uq graduate school thesis template duke graduate school thesis template graduate school uq thesis submission graduate school uq thesis unc graduate school thesis uw graduate school thesis utsa graduate school thesis uncc graduate school thesis vanderbilt graduate school thesis wsu graduate school thesis yale graduate school thesis thesis goddess of creation cruel angel thesis geeky thesis greek definition define thesis greek thesis statement for greek mythology thesis for greek mythology thesis statement for greek olympics greek word for thesis thesis statement for greek architecture thesis statement for greek theatre thesis greek hero greek history thesis thesis greek mythology greek mythology thesis statement greek mythology thesis topics greek mythology thesis ideas thesis greek name is thesis greek or latin thesis statement on greek mythology thesis on greek mythology greek meaning of thesis thesis statement on greek culture thesis on greek architecture thesis statement on greek art greek philosophy thesis greek phd thesis greek pottery thesis freaks and geeks thesis thesis greek warrior thesis greek word greek root thesis words greek civil war thesis senior thesis grad school grad school thesis topics grad school thesis ideas what is a thesis grad school purdue grad school thesis deposit thesis for grad school osu grad school thesis format uga grad school thesis format ttu grad school thesis format uaf grad school thesis format undergraduate thesis for grad school ttu grad school thesis guidelines thesis in grad school lsu grad school thesis grad school no thesis osu grad school thesis grad school thesis paper purdue grad school thesis purdue grad school thesis template psu grad school thesis uq grad school thesis review grad school thesis statement uq grad school thesis submission uga grad school thesis submission uga grad school thesis template umd grad school thesis template uq grad school thesis uwm grad school thesis uw grad school thesis uky grad school thesis grad school without thesis thesis game theory thesis games in education thesis game free download thesis game based learning thesis game proposal thesis game introduction thesis game of thrones thesis game online thesis game engine thesis game studies gamehendge thesis game thesis documentation games thesis topics games thesis statement game thesis title game thesis pdf game thesis example gamelan thesis thesis about game development thesis about game thesis android game thesis about game theory thesis about game addiction thesis video game addiction thesis computer game addiction thesis statement game addiction sample thesis android game thesis statement video game addiction thesis title about game development game application thesis game ai thesis example of thesis about game game architecture thesis game art thesis bachelor thesis game theory bachelor thesis game design bachelor thesis game thesis car game thesis about computer game android game thesis documentation sample game thesis documentation thesis most dangerous game 3d game thesis documentation educational game thesis documentation game development thesis philippines game development thesis pdf game development thesis introduction game development thesis topics game dev thesis thesis educational game thesis statement ender's game thesis for ender's game master thesis game engine thesis for game development thesis for game thesis statement for game of thrones thesis title for game development thesis guessing game thesis greek game thesis about hangman game thesis in game theory thesis in game development thesis video game industry ender's game thesis ideas phd thesis in game theory video game thesis ideas master thesis in game theory thesis mobile game theseus and minotaur game master thesis game theory master thesis game programming thesis on game theory thesis on game development thesis online game addiction thesis on game design thesis topics on game theory phd thesis on game theory game of thesis game thesis objectives android game thesis pdf thesis about puzzle game phd thesis game theory game programming thesis thesis pc game example thesis proposal for game game related thesis thesis games thesis statement game game thesis sample documentation ender's game thesis statement video game thesis statement mobile game thesis sample thesis sample games thesis serious games hunger game thesis statement thesis simulation games online game thesis statement android game thesis sample most dangerous game thesis statement sample thesis game development the westing game thesis statement thesis statement computer games addiction thesis the game game thesis topic video game thesis topics android game thesis title game theory thesis topics game theory thesis pdf game theory thesis ideas most dangerous game thesis topics game testing thesis mobile game thesis title thesis video game thesis video game violence thesis writing game thesis meaning in greek gatech thesis template gatech thesis deadline gatech thesis submission gatech thesis format gatech thesis office gatech thesis search gatech thesis repository gatech thesis gloss sty gatech-thesis.cls gatech-thesis natbib gatech-thesis-index.sty certificate of thesis approval gatech gatech thesis copyright gatech-thesis class gatech ece thesis georgia tech thesis format gatech graduate thesis office gatech graduate thesis deadline gatech thesis library gatech thesis latex template gatech thesis manual georgia tech thesis office gatech phd thesis gatech phd thesis template gatech thesis submission deadline thesis maker free free thesis statement generator for essay thesis statement generator for free free thesis statement generator for research paper thesis generator free online thesis statement generator research paper free thesis statement generator free thesis help online thesis help services thesis help in chandigarh thesis helper malaysia thesis help in delhi thesis helpline thesis helpers thesis help sfu thesis help in jalandhar thesis helper philippines thesis help ireland thesis help dublin thesis help research paper thesis help uk thesis help india thesis help desk thesis help forum thesis help topics thesis help australia phd thesis help and assistance architecture thesis help apush thesis help thesis for the help by kathryn stockett thesis statement for the help by kathryn stockett bachelor thesis help thesis help chennai phd thesis help chennai thesis writing help canada thesis statement help compare/contrast help creating thesis statement m tech thesis help in chandigarh help choosing thesis topic chemistry thesis help cheap thesis help phd thesis help delhi dbq thesis help dissertation thesis help doctoral thesis help m tech thesis help in delhi help thesis statement examples engineering thesis help thesis help free thesis help for research paper thesis formatting help help for thesis help for thesis statement frq thesis help help forming thesis statement help finishing thesis thesis help generator thesis on self help groups in india thesis on self help groups thesis on self help groups pdf phd thesis self help group good thesis help help generating thesis statement thesis help in hyderabad thesis statement homework help honours thesis help honors thesis help thesis help in pakistan thesis help in malaysia thesis introduction help phd thesis help india help in thesis writing phd thesis writing help india help in thesis thesis help kuwait thesis help malaysia thesis help melbourne thesis writing help malaysia thesis of the help movie master thesis help help making thesis statement m tech thesis help mba thesis help msc thesis help help my thesis matlab thesis help nursing thesis help help on thesis statement help on thesis thesis help philippines thesis help pakistan thesis paragraph help thesis project help thesis writing help paper master thesis proposal help phd thesis help thesis statement help research paper phd thesis help uk thesis research help help restating thesis reddit thesis help thesis statistics help thesis structure help clear thesis statement help homework help thesis statement great thesis statement help dbq thesis statement help animal cruelty thesis statement help senior thesis help thesis help tutor thesis theme help thesis title help thesis for the help thesis statement for the help thesis ideas for the help thesis writing help uk thesis help writing thesis writing help india thesis wordpress help thesis writer help phd thesis writing help free thesis writing help help writing master's thesis medical thesis writing help help with thesis help writing thesis statement research paper help with thesis statement examples help with thesis paper help with thesis statement about marriage help with thesis topic thesis how to start thesis how to write an introduction thesis how to make thesis how to write acknowledgement thesis how to pronounce thesis how to write conclusion thesis how to write methodology thesis how to write abstract thesis how to cite thesis how to write discussion thesis how to make introduction thesis how to write statement of the problem thesis how to write literature review thesis how to do thesis how to quote thesis how to reference thesis how to write reference phd thesis how to write thesis how to write a conclusion how to answer thesis defense questions how to a thesis statement thesis how to make a thesis thesis of how to tame a wild tongue how to acknowledgements thesis thesis on how to write an essay how to analyze thesis thesis how to write a thesis master thesis how to find a topic how to apa thesis how to a thesis proposal how to analysis thesis how to argumentative thesis statement how to cite thesis apa thesis to buy thesis to be defended thesis to belonging thesis how it feels to be colored me thesis statement for how to build a fire thesis binus thesis background of the study thesis binus ac id thesis by publication thesis background of the study sample thesis centre thesis chapter 1 thesis chapter 2 thesis chapter 3 thesis chapter 4 thesis chapter 1 sample thesis chapter 5 thesis cyprus thesis conclusion example thesis statement how to do how thesis defense thesis download thesis documentation thesis declaration thesis example chapter 1 thesis education thesis statement how to find thesis for to kill a mockingbird thesis for research paper thesis filipino thesis furniture thesis filipino 2 thesis for it students thesis for computer science thesis for information technology thesis forum thesis to graduate thesis gantt chart thesis guildford thesis global warming thesis to hamlet thesis helper thesis holster thesis hypothesis sample thesis human resource management thesis hair salon thesis hrm thesis harvard university thesis hotel thesis human trafficking hec theses thesis how to write introduction thesis how to write it how to identify thesis statement how to identify thesis how to identify thesis statement in an essay how to install thesis how to install thesis 2.0 how to improve thesis statement how to include thesis in resume how to introduce thesis how to introduce thesis statement how to install thesis theme how to identify thesis in essays how to install thesis theme in wordpress how to install thesis skin how to improve thesis writing how to include thesis in cv how to install thesis 2 how to introduce thesis presentation thesis to journal article thesis to journal thesis john holland thesis jane eyre thesis jeans thesis joke quotes thesis jane austen thesis juvenile delinquency thesis juvenile delinquency philippines thesis juniper fund thesis to kill a mockingbird essay thesis to kill a mockingbird prejudice to kill a mockingbird thesis thesis to kill a mockingbird courage thesis to kill a mockingbird racism thesis statement to kill a mockingbird prejudice thesis statement to kill a mockingbird racism thesis contribution to knowledge thesis statement for to kill a mockingbird thesis kabanata 4 tesis kualitatif thesis kabanata 5 thesis how long thesis to letter from a birmingham jail thesis to lord of the flies thesis statement to legalizing weed thesis lamb to the slaughter thesis related to literature thesis statement to lord of the flies thesis limassol thesis literature review example thesis lifestyle thesis layout template thesis statement how to make thesis how many words thesis how many pages thesis to manuscript thesis dedicated to my parents thesis methodology sample thesis meaning in hindi thesis manga thesis meaning in english thesis marketing thesis meaning in urdu thesis mining jobs thesis related to nursing thesis na tagalog thesis nit rourkela thesis nursing thesis nepali subject thesis network security thesis networking thesis nursing topics thesis nanotechnology thesis nav menu thesis nottingham thesis non performing loans pdf thesis of to kill a mockingbird thesis online thesis on cloud computing thesis on human resource management thesis objectives thesis on marketing thesis objectives sample thesis on leadership thesis on global warming thesis to publication thesis for a how to paper thesis acknowledgement to parents thesis statement to persuasive thesis pdf thesis presentation ppt thesis parts thesis statement on how to quit smoking thesis qualitative research thesis quotes tagalog thesis quotes hard work thesis quotes and sayings thesis quantitative research thesis questionnaire sample format thesis quality thesis to research paper thesis to romeo and juliet essay thesis related to education thesis statement to research paper thesis recommendation sample thesis recommendation thesis real estate thesis reference format thesis research methodology thesis for how to speech writing thesis how to start thesis to shooting an elephant how thesis statement thesis statement to a research paper thesis statement to a descriptive essay thesis statements to write about thesis statement to things fall apart thesis sample thesis title sample thesis topic ideas thesis topics for architecture thesis title proposal thesis title for information technology thesis tagalog thesis topics in education thesis topics for information technology thesis title for education thesis words to use thesis utm thesis unit trust management thesis uk thesis uitm thesis ukm thesis um thesis upm thesis usa thesis usm thesis uthm thesis university of toronto thesis utm format thesis uwo thesis uum thesis ucl thesis urban dictionary thesis university of pretoria thesis viva thesis vs topic sentence thesis vs research paper thesis video tutorials thesis vocabulary thesis viva questions thesis variables thesis vs course based masters thesis vs research project master thesis how to write bachelor thesis how to write thesis statement how to write an essay thesis paragraph how to write thesis co to znaczy thesis hypothesis statement thesis hypothesis synthesis thesis hypothesis meaning thesis hypothesis statement example thesis hypothesis format thesis hypothesis difference thesis hypothesis theory thesis hypothesis testing thesis hypothesis pdf thesis hypothesis research question hypothesis thesis writing hypothesis thesis proposal hypothesis thesis paper master's thesis hypothesis examples thesis hypothesis antithesis thesis and hypothesis thesis and hypothesis difference thesis and hypothesis examples thesis statement and hypothesis is thesis and hypothesis the same thesis assumption and hypothesis topic sentence thesis and hypothesis architecture thesis hypothesis thesis hepatitis b bachelor thesis hypothesis thesis hepatitis c doctoral thesis hypothesis phd thesis hypothesis examples null hypothesis thesis example hypothesis for thesis hypothesis for thesis examples filipino thesis hypothesis hypothesis for thesis paper hypothesis for thesis statement hypothesis for thesis writing hypothesis in thesis hypothesis in thesis sample hypothesis in thesis example hypothesis in thesis writing hypothesis in thesis proposal hypothesis in thesis meaning hypothesis introduction thesis hypothesis in thesis paper master thesis hypothesis thesis on efficient market hypothesis thesis null hypothesis example thesis null hypothesis thesis without hypothesis thesis hypothesis of the study thesis or hypothesis thesis statement or hypothesis thesis example of hypothesis hypothesis of thesis sample hypothesis of thesis writing thesis proposal hypothesis sample thesis hypothesis pdf sample hypothesis thesis paper phd thesis hypothesis efficient market hypothesis thesis pdf psychology thesis hypothesis thesis research hypothesis thesis structure hypothesis difference hypothesis thesis statement sample thesis hypothesis statement hypothesis of the study thesis example hypothesis sa thesis difference between hypothesis thesis statement thesis example topics thesis example title thesis example tagalog example thesis title for information technology define thesis versus hypothesis thesis with hypothesis thesis writing hypothesis sample thesis with hypothesis sample hypothesis thesis writing thesis title with hypothesis master thesis without hypothesis example of thesis with hypothesis thesis hatement slate phd thesis how to write introduction thesis title how to write thesis topics to write about how to write a thesis proposal how to write a thesis paragraph how to write a thesis statement examples how to write a thesis statement high school how to write a thesis statement middle school how to write a thesis outline how to write a thesis statement for dummies how to write a thesis pdf how to write a thesis statement powerpoint how to write a thesis title how to write a thesis introduction example how to write bachelor thesis how to write thesis background of the study how to write thesis book how to write baby thesis how to write thesis background how to write thesis bibliography how to write best thesis how to write better thesis how to write ba thesis how to write better thesis statements how to write bsc thesis how to write bachelor thesis proposal how to write thesis by latex how to write biology thesis how to write blueprint thesis how to write business thesis how to write a thesis based essay how to write a thesis by rowena murray pdf how to write bibliography for thesis apa style how to write thesis chapter 1 how to write thesis chapter 2 how to write thesis conclusion chapter how to write thesis chapter 3 how to write thesis chapter 1 introduction how to write thesis chapter 4 how to write ccot thesis how to write thesis chapter 5 how to write comparative thesis how to write thesis chapters how to write college thesis how to write thesis contribution how to write clear thesis statement how to write chemistry thesis how to write thesis chapter 4 and 5 how to write thesis citation how to write thesis conceptual framework how to write comparison thesis how to write dbq thesis how to write diploma thesis how to write doctoral thesis how to write dnb thesis how to write thesis dedication how to write thesis discussion section how to write dbq thesis statement how to write thesis documentation how to write dnb thesis protocol how to write thesis defense how to write degree thesis how to write thesis data analysis how to write design thesis how to write thesis draft how to write doctoral thesis proposal how to write down thesis statement how to write descriptive thesis how to write dba thesis how to write essay thesis how to write effective thesis statements how to write essay thesis statement how to write engineering thesis how to write thesis evaluation report how to write thesis example how to write thesis executive summary how to write expository thesis statement how to write experimental thesis how to write economics thesis how to write thesis examination report how to write thesis evaluation how to write a thesis statement how to write excellent thesis how to write a thesis essay example how to write thesis proposal example how to write phd thesis evaluation report how to write thesis introduction example how to write thesis acknowledgements example how to write thesis for research paper how to write thesis for phd how to write thesis for compare and contrast essay how to write thesis for dbq how to write thesis fast how to write thesis for essay how to write thesis faster how to write thesis findings how to write thesis for literary analysis how to write thesis for m.tech how to write thesis for comparative essay how to write thesis for persuasive essay how to write final thesis how to write thesis for analytical essay how to write thesis for synthesis essay how to write thesis for history essay how to write thesis for expository essay how to write good thesis how to write good thesis statements how to write good thesis statements for argumentative essay how to write graduation thesis how to write good thesis introduction how to write good thesis statement for an essay how to write good thesis proposal how to write good thesis title how to write great thesis how to write good thesis for research paper how to write good thesis conclusion how to write good thesis abstract how to write thesis general discussion how to write general thesis how to write master thesis guidelines how to write glossary for thesis how to write good phd thesis how to write a thesis grade 10 how to write a thesis general introduction how to write good essay thesis how to write history thesis how to write thesis hypothesis how to write honours thesis how to write history thesis statement how to write honors thesis how to write thesis harvard how to write a thesis high school how to write a thesis hook how to write a thesis statement high school powerpoint how to write a thesis statement handout how to write art history thesis how to write a thesis statement for history fair how to write a good history thesis statement how to write a thesis ap world history how to write an ap history thesis how to write an art history thesis statement how to write thesis in latex how to write thesis introduction sample how to write thesis introduction chapter how to write thesis in word 2007 how to write thesis in word 2010 how to write thesis in essay how to write thesis in apa format how to write thesis in word how to write investment thesis how to write thesis in english how to write thesis in apa style how to write thesis in research paper how to write thesis in one week how to write thesis in chemistry how to write thesis in a month how to write thesis in literature how to write thesis justification how to write thesis journal how to write a thesis statement junior high how to write a phd thesis joe wolfe how to write a thesis statement for julius caesar how to write a thesis for romeo and juliet how to write a thesis statement about a job how to write a thesis statement for criminal justice how to write your mba thesis by stephanie jones how to write keywords in thesis how to write thesis in kile how to write your thesis kim kastens how to write a killer thesis how to write a kickass thesis statement how to write a thesis for to kill a mockingbird how to write a thesis statement to kill a mockingbird how to write a thesis statement for the kite runner how to write with style kurt vonnegut thesis how to write contribution to knowledge in thesis how to write law thesis how to write thesis limitations how to write thesis latex how to write legal thesis how to write literature thesis how to write literary thesis how to write thesis-led essay how to write llm thesis how to write literary analysis thesis statement how to write a thesis lesson plan how to write thesis in lyx how to write thesis introduction literature review how to write a thesis lit review how to write master thesis literature review how to write a thesis lesson how to write a thesis letter how to write thesis related literature how to write a thesis literary essay how to write master thesis how to write master thesis proposal how to write medical thesis how to write my thesis how to write mba thesis how to write medical thesis protocol how to write thesis methodology chapter how to write master thesis report how to write master thesis abstract how to write master thesis introduction how to write master thesis in latex how to write mini thesis how to write mphil thesis how to write master thesis conclusion how to write md thesis how to write master thesis in computer science how to write thesis motivation how to write master thesis methodology thesis write numbers how to write narrative thesis how to write narrative thesis statement how to write nomenclature in thesis how to write notes in thesis how to write a thesis nz how to write a thesis nursing how to write a neutral thesis statement how to write a thesis statement nhd how to write a non-thesis paper how to write a narrow thesis statement how to write a thesis statement notes how to write a nursing thesis statement how to write a nice thesis how to write a thesis statement nz how to write a thesis with no prompt how to write a personal narrative thesis statement how to write a thesis for a novel how to write a master's thesis yvonne n bui how to write a thesis in one night thesis how to write one thesis statement how to write one how to write thesis outline how to write thesis objectives how to write thesis of an essay how to write thesis on latex how to write thesis organization how to write thesis overview how to write thesis of research paper how to write thesis of project how to write thesis of phd how to write thesis on resume how to write thesis on english literature how to write thesis on word how to write a thesis on a book how to write a thesis outline for a research paper how to write a thesis on a poem how to write a thesis on a compare and contrast essay how to write thesis proposal how to write phd thesis how to write thesis paper how to write thesis pdf how to write phd thesis pdf how to write thesis ppt how to write thesis proposals for masters how to write thesis problem statement how to write thesis protocol how to write phd thesis proposal how to write phd thesis synopsis how to write thesis paragraph how to write phd thesis in word how to write thesis proposal pdf how to write phd thesis abstract how to write phd thesis in latex how to write phd thesis introduction how to write phd thesis conclusion how to write perfect thesis statement how to write thesis question how to write thesis quickly how to write qualitative thesis how to write thesis questionnaire how to write a thesis how to write quotation in thesis how to write thesis research questions how to write your thesis quickly how to write quote in thesis how to write a qualifying thesis how to write a good thesis question how to write a quality thesis statement how to write a quantitative thesis how to write a quick thesis how to write thesis report how to write research thesis how to write thesis recommendation how to write thesis results how to write thesis results and discussion how to write thesis review how to write thesis results section how to write thesis research paper how to write thesis rationale how to write research thesis statement how to write thesis research objectives how to write research thesis proposal how to write recommendation thesis sample how to write thesis reference in apa format how to write reference thesis(pdf) how to write thesis research plan how to write thesis statement how to write thesis statement in essay how to write thesis statement for argumentative essay how to write thesis statement for compare and contrast essay how to write thesis statement examples how to write thesis summary how to write thesis statement in essay example how to write thesis synopsis how to write s thesis how to write strong thesis how to write scientific thesis how to write thesis statement for persuasive essay how to write thesis summary and conclusion how to write thesis statement for cause and effect essay how to write thesis statement for expository essay how to write senior thesis how to write thesis significance of the study how to write thesis structure how to write synthesis thesis how to write the thesis how to write thesis title how to write the thesis statement of an essay how to write the thesis of an essay how to write the thesis proposal how to write thesis topic how to write the thesis of a research paper how to write the thesis introduction how to write the thesis abstract how to write thesis theoretical framework how to write the thesis of a compare and contrast essay how to write the thesis conclusion how to write tentative thesis how to write the thesis outline how to write the thesis pdf how to write thesis table of contents how to write the thesis of a book how to write the thesis for a dbq how to write thesis tips thesis write up thesis write up sample thesis write up plan thesis write up grant how to write undergraduate thesis how to write thesis using latex how to write university thesis how to write thesis using word 2007 how to write thesis using word how to write undergraduate thesis proposal how to write thesis using ms word how to write thesis utm how to write undergraduate thesis psychology how to write phd thesis using latex how to write a thesis uk how to write a thesis using microsoft word how to write a thesis using lyx how to write up a thesis proposal how to write a thesis unsw how to write a thesis umberto eco pdf how to write a thesis video how to write vitae in thesis how to write a thesis statement video how to write a valid thesis statement how to write a thesis for a visual analysis paper how to write a very good thesis statement how to write a very good thesis how to write a visual analysis thesis how to write curriculum vitae for thesis how to write a thesis statement on video games how to write a thesis statement on domestic violence how to write thesis with latex how to write working thesis how to write thesis word 2007 how to write a thesis worksheet how to write a thesis without listing how to write a thesis when comparing and contrasting how to write a thesis with an argument how to write a thesis with examples how to write a thesis with a question how to write with a thesis how to write a working thesis statement how to write a thesis statement with three points how to write a thesis statement without using i how to write a thesis statement wikihow how to write website references in thesis how to write a thesis a working guide how to write an xyz thesis how to write your thesis how to write your thesis statement how to write your thesis in 15 minutes a day how to write your thesis in 10 minutes a day how to write your thesis in 3 months how to write your thesis in latex how to write your thesis proposal how to write your thesis conclusion how to write your thesis discussion how to write your thesis title how to write your thesis in a week how to write your thesis pdf how to write your thesis abstract how to write your thesis fast how to write your thesis in word how to write your thesis ppt how to write thesis yahoo how to write your thesis faster how to write your thesis in 2 weeks how to write your thesis sentence how to write thesis in zoology thesis statement handout middle school thesis statement handout pdf thesis writing handout thesis statement practice handout handout on thesis statements thesis statement handouts revising thesis statements handout writing thesis statements handout hypothesis example in a thesis hypothesis example for thesis hypothesis example in thesis null hypothesis example in thesis research hypothesis example in thesis hypothesis example of thesis thesis hypothesis examples thesis hooks list thesis hooks visual thesis hooks plugin thesis hooks for dummies thesis hooks tutorial thesis hooks example thesis 2 hooks thesis 2.0 hooks thesis custom hooks thesis 2.1 hooks good thesis hooks thesis statement hooks sugarrae thesis hooks bell hooks thesis thesis hook after post thesis_hook_after_header thesis hook after html thesis hook after post box thesis hook after body tag thesis hook after content area thesis and hook statement thesis and hook examples wordpress thesis_hook_after_title thesis_hook_before_header thesis hook before html thesis hook before content thesis hook before headline thesis hook before sidebars thesis_hook_before_sidebar_1 thesis hook before content box thesis hook before container hook thesis bridge hook thesis blueprint hook thesis background thesis_hook_feature_box thesis_hook_multimedia_box thesis_hook_custom_template thesis hook content diythemes thesis hooks thesis hooks full width thesis hook footer hooks for thesis hooks for thesis papers thesis hook header thesis header hook thesis hook headline meta hooks in thesis hooks in thesis theme thesis hook locations thesis hook last_nav_item thesis hooks map thesis open hooks thesis open hooks map thesis openhook plugin hook thesis plan thesis hooks reference thesis hook reference list thesis hooks visual reference thesis hook sidebar thesis theme hooks thesis theme hooks visual hook thesis topic sentence hook thesis transition using thesis hooks thesis hooks wordpress thesis openhook wordpress plugin theis holsters theis holster review theis holsters vs crossbreed theis holster m&p shield theis holster squeak theis holster shield theis holster ppq theis holster xds theis holster glock 19 theis holsters facebook theis holster glock 26 theis holster break in theis holster lc9 theis holster sr9c theis holsters youtube theis holster ez clip theis holster location theis holster single clip theis holsters appendix theis appendix holster review theis holster retention adjustment theis holsters conway ar theis holster beretta nano theis holster baby powder theis holster belt review tommy theis holster break in theis holsters jake belt theis holsters jake belt review theis holster clips theis holster vs crossbreed theis holster kydex clips theis ez clip holster review theis single clip holster review thesis appendix carry holster theis holster for shield theis holster for m&p shield theis holster for sale theis holster for glock 30 theis holster for fns 9/fns 40 theis iwb holster for m&p shield theis holster glock 30 theis holster glock 27 this gun holster are theis holsters good theis horsehide holster theis holster iwb theis iwb holster review crossbreed vs theis iwb holster theis holster phone number theis owb holster theis owb holster review theis holster pm9 theis holster p238 theis holster sig p238 theis holster walther pps theis holster retention theis holster review youtube tommy theis holster reviews theis holsters review theis holsters xds theis holsters location theis holsters ppq theis holsters glock 26 theis holsters 2013 theis holsters kydex clips theis holster tuckable tommy theis holster theis holster vs theis holster youtube thesis harvard referencing thesis harvard referencing generator thesis harvard business school thesis harvard pdf thesis harvard extension school harvard thesis format harvard thesis template harvard thesis statement harvard thesis latex harvard thesis repository harvard thesis examples harvard thesis proposal harvard thesis template word harvard thesis cdo harvard thesis guide harvard thesis archive thesis at harvard harvard thesis architecture harvard alm thesis harvard architecture thesis topics harvard architecture thesis winner harvard thesis binding best thesis harvard bachelor thesis harvard harvard bachelor thesis examples harvard-thesis.cls harvard thesis controversy harvard thesis class harvard thesis collection harvard college thesis citing thesis harvard style creative thesis harvard harvard thesis database harvard thesis download dba thesis harvard thesis economics harvard phd thesis economics harvard master thesis economics harvard harvard english thesis harvard extension thesis database harvard electronic thesis example thesis harvard style e thesis harvard thesis from harvard university harvard thesis financial crisis harvard thesis font obama's thesis from harvard harvard finance thesis harvard thesis guidelines thesis grades harvard harvard gsd thesis harvard gsd thesis reviews harvard government thesis harvard gsd thesis prize harvard gsd thesis review schedule harvard honors thesis thesis in harvard thesis in harvard university harvard thesis index thesis in harvard format referencing thesis in harvard style harvard immigration thesis harvard iq thesis jfk thesis harvard kissinger thesis harvard harvard thesis library harvard thesis layout harvard llm thesis harvard law thesis thesis mba harvard harvard thesis movie senior thesis harvard math harvard thesis on marketing master thesis harvard master thesis harvard university harvard master thesis format harvard mba thesis topics harvard master thesis examples master thesis harvard style harvard master thesis template harvard mathematics thesis harvard master thesis pdf harvard thesis online thesis of harvard university harvard thesis on financial crisis obama thesis harvard harvard oeb thesis harvard thesis papers harvard thesis physics harvard thesis presentation harvard thesis prize harvard thesis projects harvard thesis title page obama harvard thesis paper thesis by publication harvard harvard phd thesis harvard phd thesis format harvard phd thesis latex template harvard psychology thesis harvard phd thesis template harvard phd thesis latex harvard phd thesis search harvard professor thesis 30 seconds to mars harvard philosophy thesis harvard thesis requirements unpublished thesis harvard referencing phd thesis harvard reference harvard referencing thesis online harvard referencing thesis phd thesis harvard style thesis structure harvard thesis statement harvard harvard thesis search senior thesis harvard sample thesis harvard university thesis writing harvard style harvard thesis thirty seconds to mars harvard thesis topics harvard thesis titles economics thesis topics harvard phd thesis harvard university thesis format harvard university thesis statement harvard university harvard university thesis pdf harvard university thesis guidelines harvard university thesis database harvard university thesis template harvard university thesis online harvard university thesis search harvard university thesis proposal harvard university thesis archives harvard university thesis repository harvard undergraduate thesis award harvard university thesis latex thesis writing harvard harvard thesis writing guide thesis with harvard referencing harvard writing thesis statement humorous thesis statements thesis writing humor phd thesis humor thesis on humor advertising translating humor thesis thesis about humor thesis statement about humor thesis statement for humor thesis on humor thesis statement on humor thesis statement humor humor therapy thesis thesis history topics thesis history and memory thesis history pdf thesis history fair history thesis statement history thesis ideas history thesis paper topics history thesis statement generator history thesis proposal example history thesis proposal history thesis topics list history thesis format history thesis titles history thesis introduction history thesis prospectus example history thesis prospectus thesis about history thesis art history thesis art history paper thesis about history of the philippines thesis american history thesis art history example thesis ancient history thesis of a history of the world in 6 glasses thesis for a history paper thesis statement about history thesis statement art history master's thesis art history thesis proposal art history thesis for american history x thesis british history thesis for black history thesis statement for black history month thesis statement for black history thesis of a brief history of time thesis for history of basketball end of history thesis by francis fukuyama thesis completed history thesis on church history laurentian thesis canadian history thesis about canadian history thesis for ap world history comparative essay collingwood thesis history history thesis table of contents thesis on history of christianity ap world history thesis compare and contrast thesis statement history day thesis statement history day project thesis for history day thesis statement national history day thesis on diplomatic history history day thesis examples thesis for ap world history dbq history doctoral thesis history dbq thesis history dissertation thesis history thesis tu delft thesis history examples thesis statement history examples master's thesis history examples thesis topics history education us history thesis examples undergraduate history thesis example world history thesis examples phd thesis economic history american history thesis examples thesis on economic history master thesis economic history thesis on environmental history ap history thesis examples thesis for history paper thesis for history research paper thesis for history and memory thesis for history history thesis fair oxford thesis statement history fair thesis statement for history paper thesis topics for history thesis ideas for history history thesis statement format phd thesis for history thesis statement for history day history thesis generator history thesis guidelines oxford history thesis guidelines good thesis history history graduate thesis thesis statement for global history history thesis harvard thesis statement history halloween history honours thesis example history honors thesis thesis in history thesis in history paper history thesis in progress phd thesis in history thesis statement in history art history thesis ideas history thesis topic ideas american history thesis ideas phd thesis in history pdf military history thesis ideas thesis on indian history master thesis in history senior history thesis ideas ancient history thesis ideas thesis on islamic history define thesis in history history thesis length elton thesis history learning site phd thesis list history phd history thesis length lancia thesis history master thesis history leiden history thesis methodology thesis of making history with vitamin c history master's thesis history master's thesis topics history master's thesis length history major thesis ideas thesis for national history day thesis on history of nursing thesis on history history thesis online thesis on history and memory history thesis oxford thesis oral history thesis on history of english language thesis on history of pakistan phd thesis history of architecture thesis statement on history phd thesis on history thesis statement for history of tattoos thesis statement on history of baseball thesis a people's history of the united states thesis on the history of philosophy history thesis proposal sample history thesis paper format history thesis paragraph history thesis presentation thesis statement history project us history thesis paper topics world history thesis paper topics american history thesis paper topics art history thesis proposal art history thesis pdf history thesis questions american history thesis questions thesis statement history research paper thesis in history research history thesis paper rubric ap us history thesis rubric thesis statements history and memory history thesis structure history thesis search history thesis statement template art history thesis statement thesis typeface history history thesis tips history thesis theoretical framework history thesis topics american senior thesis history topics art history thesis topics us history thesis topics good history thesis topics world history thesis topics european history thesis topics ancient history thesis topics canadian history thesis topics military history thesis topics history thesis uk thesis us history turner thesis us history thesis ap us history thesis for ap us history essays history undergraduate thesis history thesis writing thesis ap world history thesis statement world history thesis on world history ap history thesis writing thesis statement world history ap ap us history thesis writing thesis statements for american history x thesis hv venti price thesis hv venti for sale audison thesis hv venti audison thesis hv venti review audison thesis hv venti for sale audison thesis hv venti amplifier audison thesis hv venti prezzo audison thesis hv venti malaysia audison thesis hv venti 20 audison thesis hv venti manual thesis hv venti prezzo audison thesis hv venti цена audison thesis amplificatore hv venti audison thesis hv venti купить audison thesis hv venti test audison thesis hv venti price thesis on high heels thesis high school topics thesis high school vs college thesis high school dropouts senior thesis high school thesis worksheets high school thesis statement high school lesson plan thesis titles high school students thesis rubric high school thesis about high school and college thesis comparing high school to college thesis title high school thesis statement for high school and college thesis about high school students thesis about high school dropouts thesis statement activities high school thesis topics about high school students thesis title about high school students thesis topics about high school wellesley high school author thesis thesis about open high school program thesis statement about highschool life developing a thesis high school thesis about open high school thesis statement about changing high school high school biology thesis topics high school baby thesis high school biology thesis best high school thesis topics high school thesis chapter 1 thesis statement comparing high school college thesis statement for changing high school high school thesis defense high school dropout rate thesis high school diploma thesis thesis high school example high school english thesis high school senior thesis example high school thesis topics examples high school enrollment system thesis high school thesis writing exercises thesis title examples for highschool students high school senior project thesis examples thesis for high school students thesis for high school students topic thesis for high school dropouts thesis for high school vs college thesis titles for high school students thesis title for high school thesis sample for high school thesis statements for high school research papers high school senior thesis format thesis proposal for high school students high school graduation thesis high school grading system thesis high school senior thesis guidelines good high school thesis topics good high school thesis statements thesis statement for graduating high school high school history thesis topics high school history thesis thesis in high school high school thesis ideas high school thesis introduction sample high school senior thesis ideas high school thesis topics ideas thesis topics in high school thesis topics for high school students in the philippines high school senior thesis topic ideas high school thesis introduction wellesley high school junior thesis high school level thesis statement high school level thesis thesis lesson plan high school high school thesis topics list high school math thesis thesis on high school dropouts thesis on high school vs college high school thesis outline thesis on high school high school senior thesis outline high school thesis paper high school thesis paper topics high school thesis proposal high school thesis project high school thesis prompts high school physics thesis topics high school thesis topics proposal thesis statement practice high school sample high school thesis paper thesis proposal sample - high school high school thesis topics philippines high school senior thesis paper thesis topics for high school students philippines high school research paper thesis examples of thesis statements for high school research papers high school senior thesis high school thesis sample high school senior thesis projects high school thesis statement exercises thesis statement high school dropouts high school thesis title high school thesis topics statement high school senior thesis topics high school science thesis topics high school thesis writing thesis writing tips for high school teaching thesis writing high school thesis practice worksheets for high school thesis for 4th year high school thesis headings and subheadings thesis headings apa thesis headings format thesis headings capitalization thesis chapter headings master's thesis headings thesis section headings phd thesis headings thesis chapter headings latex thesis paper headings apa style thesis headings thesis header and footer thesis layout apa thesis header background color thesis header background image thesis header clickable thesis custom header thesis clickable header image thesis change header thesis center header image thesis custom header hook thesis chapter layout phd thesis chapter headings apa thesis chapter headings master's thesis chapter headings thesis header dimensions thesis document layout thesis edit header thesis header footer thesis header format thesis fluid layout master thesis header footer headings for thesis thesis header height thesis theme header height thesis 2 header height thesis nope header hoses thesis header image thesis header image not showing thesis layout indesign thesis layout in word thesis insert header image thesis introduction layout thesis interior layout borders color thesis 2.0 header image thesis 2.1 header image thesis remove header image headings in thesis thesis javascript header thesis header latex thesis header logo thesis layout latex thesis layout lyx thesis magazine layout headings of thesis thesis header.php thesis header padding thesis header plugin thesis page layout thesis presentation layout thesis plant layout thesis poster layout thesis paragraph layout thesis project layout thesis layout requirements thesis header size thesis layout sample thesis layout software thesis simple header widgets thesis show header thesis sidebar header thesis theme header size thesis layout samk thesis layout table of figures thesis theme header.php thesis theme header thesis theme layout thesis layout tips thesis layout ucd thesis layout ucc thesis layout ugent thesis header widget thesis header word thesis layout word thesis writing layout thesis help for free honors thesis example honors thesis proposal example honors thesis fsu honors thesis uf honors thesis unc honors thesis tulane honors thesis proposal honors thesis osu honors thesis cu boulder honors thesis umich honors thesis format honors thesis usf honors thesis emory honors thesis wiki honors thesis psychology honors thesis uconn honors thesis jmu honors thesis stanford honors thesis archive honors thesis asu honors thesis acknowledgements honors thesis auburn honors thesis arizona honors thesis award unc honors thesis archive honors thesis william and mary fsu honors thesis application honors thesis umass amherst undergraduate honors thesis anthropology ohio state honors thesis application honors thesis baylor honors thesis berkeley honors thesis biology honors thesis bucknell honors thesis barrett honors thesis benefits honors thesis butler university honors thesis byu honors thesis berkeley mcb honors thesis baruch honors thesis brown sociology honors thesis berkeley uf honors thesis business rhetoric honors thesis berkeley unc honors thesis biology uwo honors thesis biology honors thesis cornell honors thesis csu honors thesis cv honors thesis unc chapel hill uf honors thesis cals is honors thesis capitalized honors thesis smith college uf honors thesis course honors college thesis honors thesis table of contents honors college thesis handbook honors thesis duke honors thesis dartmouth emory honors thesis database schreyer honors thesis database uconn honors thesis digital commons government honors thesis dartmouth honors thesis example psychology honors thesis economics honors thesis east honors thesis eku honors thesis elon honors thesis en español undergraduate honors thesis examples sociology honors thesis examples honors thesis prospectus example usf honors thesis examples political science honors thesis example baylor honors thesis formatting honors thesis submission form uconn honors thesis form tulane honors thesis format senior honors thesis format honors thesis en francais honors thesis guidelines honors thesis gsu csu honors thesis guide uf honors thesis guidelines unc honors thesis guidelines emerson college honors thesis guidelines honors thesis handbook honors thesis history honors thesis harvard utsa honors thesis handbook umaine honors thesis handbook usf honors thesis handbook highest thesis honors iona college honors thesis handbook honors thesis ideas honors thesis ideas psychology honors thesis in psychology honors thesis iowa honors thesis worth it honors thesis length honors thesis literature review honors thesis law school undergraduate honors thesis length honors thesis university of lethbridge honors thesis u of l honors thesis medical school honors thesis meaning honors thesis math honors thesis viral marketing honors thesis nus honors thesis nmsu honors thesis on resume honors thesis oregon state honors thesis ou honors thesis university of arizona honors thesis university of utah senior honors thesis ohio state honors thesis or honors thesis honors thesis project honors thesis presentation honors thesis prospectus honors thesis penn state honors thesis political science honors thesis proposal template honors thesis philosophy honors thesis pdf honors thesis paper honors thesis prospectus tulane honors thesis process usf honors thesis prospectus wsu honors thesis proposal undergraduate honors thesis psychology honors thesis requirements honors thesis rubric honors thesis resume honors thesis rutgers tulane honors thesis requirements interdisciplinary honors thesis rutgers osu honors thesis requirements senior honors thesis resume honors thesis sample honors thesis structure honors thesis statement honors thesis submission uf honors thesis ohio state economics honors thesis stanford tulane honors thesis schedule honors thesis wayne state baylor honors thesis syllabus honors thesis biology stanford honors thesis topics honors thesis timeline honors thesis tcu honors thesis ttu honors thesis tufts honors thesis tumblr honors thesis tamu honors thesis traduccion psychology honors thesis topics economics honors thesis topics sociology honors thesis topics unc honors thesis title page political science honors thesis topics honors thesis traduction honors thesis uark honors thesis uncw honors thesis umass honors thesis umn honors thesis utsa honors thesis uga honors thesis uvm honors thesis unl honors thesis umaine honors thesis uh honors thesis uwo honors thesis ucsd honors thesis uiowa honors thesis ucla thesis with honors honors thesis wsu honors thesis wvu honors thesis wmu uconn honors thesis workshop master thesis with honors thesis handbook chula thesis handbook unsw bgsu thesis handbook thesis writing handbook ccsu thesis handbook mes thesis handbook master thesis handbook