Share

Economics and Economists Engulfed By Crises:

What Do We Tell the Students?

Prof. Kamran Mofid PhD (ECON)

Founder, Globalisation for the Common Good Initiative (GCGI)

Steve Szeghi PhD (ECON)

Professor of Economics, Wilmington College, Wilmington, Ohio

Co-Author Right Relationship: Building A Whole Earth Economy

      

"Education should consist of a series of enchantments, each raising the individual to a higher level of awareness, understanding, and kinship with all living things". Author Unknown

"It is the supreme art of the teacher to awaken joy in creative expression and knowledge". Albert Einstein

"What is the essence of life? To serve others and to do good". Aristotle

“Education is the leading of human souls to what is best, and making what is best out of them”.  John Ruskin

The recent global crisis has lead to questions about whether the kind of economics that is taught in universities was responsible for the crisis itself, or indeed for its widespread failure to predict the timing and magnitude of the events that unfolded in 2008. There are many reasons for such failure. However, whatever the reasons might be, we strongly believe that now is the time for us all to begin to debate this issue and to discover what is it that we should now teach our students.

While the global financial crisis is most surely a significant peril, it is not the most significant problem that human beings or this planet face.  There are two larger crises of which it is a part and which grow in immensity and difficulty to solve by the day, and which were in turn caused by many of the same philosophies, misguided ethics, flawed economics and politics that helped to spawn the financial meltdown.  These two larger crises, of which we speak, are the crisis of growing inequality, economic insecurity and social injustice and the crisis of the environment which imperils an abundant diversity of life on earth as well as human survival.

It is our hope that with this paper we may begin an open dialogue with all concerned-colleagues, students and others, so that together we can prescribe a working solution.

It is clear that some serious reflection is in order. Not to stand back and question what has happened and why, would be to compound failure with failure: failure of vision with failure of responsibility. If nothing else these current crises of finance, social injustice and environmental devastation present us with a unique opportunity to address the shortcomings of our profession with total honesty and humility while returning the “dismal science” to its true position: a subject of beauty, wisdom and virtue.

Nowhere can the urgency of this task be better seen than in the eloquent words of the Real-World Economics Review.

"It is accepted fact that the economics profession through its teachings, pronouncements and policy recommendations facilitated the GFC (Global Financial Collapse).  We also know that danger signs became visible long before the event and that some economists (those with their eyes on the real-world) gave public warnings which if acted upon would have averted the human disaster.

With other learned professions entrusted with public confidence, such as medicine and engineering, it is inconceivable that their professional bodies would not at the very least censure members who had successfully persuaded governments and public opinion to ignore elementary safety measures, so causing epidemics and widespread building collapses.

To date, however, the world’s major economics associations have declined to censure the major facilitators of these grave crises or even to publicly identify them.  This silence, this indifference to the engendering of human suffering, constitutes grave moral failure.  It also gives license to those economists who continue to indulge in axiom-happy behaviour.  Nor has the economics establishment offered recognition to those economists who were not taken in by fads and fashion and whose competence, if listened to, would have prevented these crises. These two silences reveal a continuing moral crisis within the economics profession”. (See Real-World Economics Review Blog, January 11, 2010

On the other hand, of course we find it somewhat encouraging that the most recent Nobel Prize in Economics went not to Eugene Fama for his theory of the always efficient and rational market but rather to two behavioral economists who question the rationality postulate.  Coupled with the reception of the Nobel Prize by Paul Krugman last year and Joseph Stiglitz a few years earlier, both advocates of re-regulation of the financial system at the national and global level, there is reason to think that our field as a whole may truly be ready for something new.

The recent financial crisis provides overwhelming evidence that financial markets are lacking in both efficiency and rationality. Even if financial markets are characterized by something as rational as the price of an asset being related to the present value of its future income earnings; that can hardly be all that determines asset prices.  Financial markets have always been griped by heavy doses of irrationality, as well as outright cons and Ponzi schemes.  The potential of financial products and markets to create systemic risk and to fall prey to con and Ponzi schemes due to moral hazard, adverse selection, and asymmetrical information, was generally well understood and is why they were heavily regulated, to great success from the 1930’s until the time of Thatcher and Reagan.  

Since the 1980’s, financial markets were increasingly deregulated throughout the world until the current crisis. Following Thatcher and Reagan; Clinton, Bush, Blair, and Brown all continued the deregulatory trend of the Anglo-American financial system. There were many who warned of what was to come, including Robert Kuttner (See Kuttner, Robert, The Squandering of America, 2007) and even earlier, such a wise but lonely economist as Hyman Minsky. (See Minsky, Hyman, Stabilizing An Unstable Economy, reprinted 2008, McGraw Hill) Yet it was the always efficient market hypothesis of Eugene Fama and others that came out on top in the policy debates of the last three decades in the corridors of power throughout most of the world.  

Certainly the failure of the global financial system, as well as the crises of the environment and inequality and economic insecurity can not be solely blamed on standard economic theory.  Surely there has been a failure of politics, ethics, spirituality and human culture as well. But standard economic theory is not without blame.

James Buchanan (See Buchanan, James and Tullock, Gordon, The Calculus of Consent: Logical Foundations of Constitutional Democracy, 1962) and other Public Choice theorists introduced the concept of government failure to the basic vocabulary of Economics in the 1970’s and 80’s.  Ever since, policy makers at the national and global levels have been reluctant to aggressively tackle the many cases of market failure which standard economics previously and currently admits, and for which previous theory prescribed government action.  Somehow always missing from the list of examples of government failure for the public choice theorists, is the most egregious failure of all and that is the failure to correct for market failures for fear of making a mistake.  

At the core of the social attitudes which are engendering the crises of the environment and increasing inequality are both market fundamentalism and standard economics.  While standard economics in and of itself is distinct from the rigid ideology of market fundamentalism, too often the profession as a whole has failed to draw the sharp distinctions between standard theory and the claims of market fundamentalists.  The silence of much of the economics profession in the face of the political ascendancy of this ‘market knows all’ ideology has enabled and assisted it.

Market Fundamentalism is the assertion or ideological dogma that markets and private property with little or no role for government, civil society, tradition, and community are capable of solving all human wants, needs, and problems.  Standard economic theory of course posits a role for government in correcting for externalities, insuring the provision of public goods, and addressing other forms of market failure such as imperfect competition in order for markets to be efficient.  In order for markets to be just, standard economics recognizes a role for government in shaping the income distribution. While much of the economics profession has been eerily quiet in the face of the political ascendancy of market fundamentalism, some economists have in fact resorted to becoming cheerleaders and boosters for it.  

As social scientists who study resource allocation there should be no bias in favor of market as opposed to command or tradition in the allocation of resources, just as there should be no bias in favor of private as opposed to communal or state ownership of the means of production.  But frequently the enthusiasm of some economists for market allocation and private ownership in any and all circumstances is too obvious, bordering on ideology or religion rather than science and amounts to a flirtation with market fundamentalism if not a full blown affair.

It is certainly tempting in the face of so called gridlock or broken government, or partisan stalemate, to perhaps wish that markets were capable of solving all of our problems.  Collective decision making is a messy business as are relationships generally. Our politics are so divided though, precisely because of the fairly strong view on the part of some, or so it would seem, that markets are capable of solving all problems.  

As both Robert Kuttner and Paul Krugman (See Krugman, Paul, The Conscience of a Liberal, 2007) suggest, the rough consensus on the proper role for government in a system of managed capitalism which existed in the United States in the 1950’s and 60’s, and even 70’s has broken down.  In the context of the present day, the ardent wish for markets to solve all problems is to side with market fundamentalists in the political debate.  But, wishing doesn’t make it so.  Markets can not solve the biggest problems faced by human society. They can not on their own, although they can play a role, in solving the crisis of inequality and the crisis of the environment, nor can they solve the financial crisis.  

Markets are simply not capable of solving all problems with little or no role for government, civil society, or tradition.  Economic theory shows that markets do in fact fail to be efficient.  One failure is of course externalities, another is the case of public goods, both of which have implications in the study of the environment.  Markets also need perfect competition to be efficient. In addition, markets give disproportionate influence to the wants of the rich, and theory has never claimed that even when ‘efficient’ that markets are just or ethical.  Many Public Choice theorists, in the tradition of James Buchanan, by suggesting that government is capable of little good in the correction of market failure have become allies, conscious or otherwise, of market fundamentalism.     

Leaving it to the market alone, is leaving it to the few, to the rich, to have inordinate say so and disproportionate influence on what is produced and how.  Leaving it all, to private property is to fence off the bulk of humanity from the means of life.  It means walling off retreats of splendor to wander in, gain solace from and find spiritual sustenance in.  Leaving it to the market in the absence of regulation or in the absence of perfect information about the quality of what is being sold (Food, Drugs, Financial Products) is leaving it to a bunch of crooks, where Ponzi schemes proliferate.  As Arthur Okun once suggested, “The market needs a place but needs to be kept in its place.”  The unfettered market is killing the planet upon which our survival depends, even as it also kills relationships between people.  

Karl Marx long ago wrote that ‘capitalism has torn asunder all familiar relations ...” It has also torn asunder the traditions that governed the use of the commons and the ties which bound people to one another in community.  But Marx was wrong in one respect, these traditions were not torn asunder, not at the time he wrote, certainly not completely, not by capitalism. The best of these traditions survived long after he wrote the Communist Manifesto.  But what survived capitalism for centuries may not survive market fundamentalism and a modern economic system where human beings are no longer citizens, only consumers.  Where, once we had public spaces called town squares, now we have private spaces within shopping malls, places that have the look and feel of town squares but are not.  The town squares of old were places where citizens and members of the community gathered for the common life.  The town square replicas inside shopping malls are places where consumers linger for a few moments before venturing forth for the next purchase, even as they are calmed by the shadows of what once was.

Apart from the failure to speak strongly against market fundamentalism, and the enthusiasm of some economists for it, standard theory itself shares some of the blame for other attitudes which have assisted if not engendered the crises of the environment and inequality.  Standard theory tends to be obsessed with economic growth, typically GDP growth, viewing it as an automatic remedy for everything from population growth, to inequality, to environmental problems.  In addition standard theory has tended to neglect Ecology and the environment, although these are included sometimes for their rather narrow ‘economic’ benefits and costs.  More rarely are the aesthetic human use values of the environment considered, and almost always nature, the earth, and other species are viewed in homocentric terms and not in terms of intrinsic value.

The failure to correct for market failure, accompanied by a deregulatory and privatization frenzy engendered by market fundamentalism directly contributed to the global financial crisis as well as continuing failure to adequately address the crises of Inequality/Economic Insecurity and of the Environment.

Now is the time to acknowledge the failures of standard theory and the narrowness of market fundamentalism. The times demand a revolution in economic thought, as well as new ways of teaching economics.  In many respects this means a return to the soil in which economics was initially born, moral philosophy amid issues and questions of broad significance involving the fullness of human existence.

To begin this process, we suggest the following:

1-Begin a Journey to Wisdom

We should acknowledge that economics and business should be all about human well-being in society and that this cannot be separated from moral, ethical and spiritual considerations. The idea of an economics which is value-free is totally false. Nothing in life is morally neutral. In the end, economics cannot be separated from a vision of what it is to be a human being in society. In order to arrive at such understanding, our first recommendation is for us to begin a journey to wisdom, by embodying the core values of the Golden Rule (Ethic of Reciprocity): “Do unto others as you would have them to do to you”. This in turn will prompt us on a journey of discovery, giving life to what many consider to be the most consistent moral teaching throughout history. It should be noted that the Golden Rule can be found in many religions, ethical systems, spiritual traditions, indigenous cultures and secular philosophies.

Another necessary step in this journey of self-discovery, which is complimentary to the Golden Rule, is to discover, promote and live for the Common Good.

For our purpose and intentions we can define the Common Good as “widely beneficial outcomes that are never preordained but instead arrived at through mindful leadership and active following”.  These outcomes involve a “regime of mutual gain; a system of policies, programs, laws, rules, and norms that yield widespread benefits at reasonable costs and taps people’s deepest interest in their own well-being and that of others”.

In short, the principle of the common good reminds us that we are all really responsible for each other – we are our brothers’ and sisters’ keepers - and must work for social conditions which ensure that every person and every group in society is able to meet their needs and realize their potential. It follows that every group in society must take into account the rights and aspirations of other groups, and the well being of the whole human family.

2- Now is the Time for a Revolution in Economic Thought

Here we are in total agreement with Hayek when he wrote:

“An economist who is only an economist cannot be a good economist”. Therefore, the focus of economics should be on the benefit and bounty that the economy produces, on how to let this bounty increase, and how to share the benefits justly among the people for the common good, removing the obstacles that hinder this process. Above all else the purpose of the economy is to provide basic human needs as well as the means of establishing, maintaining, and nurturing human relationships while dealing justly with future generations (Sustainability) and ethically with all life on earth (Ecological Balance).

Moreover, economic investigation should be accompanied by research into subjects such as anthropology, philosophy, politics, ecology, environmental ethics, and theology, to give insight into our own human mystery, as no economic theory or no economist can say who we are, where have we come from or where we are going to. All human beings and all species must be respected as part of the web of life and not relegated to narrow short term economic interests, commodification, or exploitation, as has been the case for the past few centuries.

Much of humanity thinks itself elevated above the rest of nature via one major difference: the possession of a critical mind. Many think it is through this gift that humans are honoured with a unique ability to influence the direction of our life and the world in which we live.  Yet, there is much recent scientific evidence, just as there is much in indigenous spiritual tradition to suggest that humans are not unique in this capacity.  Regardless, it is time to put our critical ability to good use and resolve to do our utmost in life for the good of humanity and the entire web of life.  In order to be for the common good, we must admit that, there is more to life than economics, more than the so-called rational and efficient market: the market knows it all mentality, which has brought us all such a bitter harvest. We must realise that we should do our utmost by uniting faith and knowledge, love and reason, heart and mind, the human community and the community of nature.

We must undertake the task of building a bridge between East and West. We must encourage a dialogue of civilisations, cultures and faiths. We must encourage a multi-disciplinary approach to problem solving. Above all, our paths must be to unite love and intellect. This, in our view, can be a great path of dialogue between East and West, and between “the modern” and the indigenous or aboriginal. Pursuing such a dialogue will lead to a more relevant and true economic model, in harmony with the deepest human values.  

In the West we have mastered the sophisticated art of increasingly complex and complicated and highly mathematical economic models. Our technological achievements of the last few decades and centuries are truly unbelievable to say the least. However, many critics, including us, believe that in the process, as it appears, we have lost the art of living and loving, along with any sense of what it means to be happy and content, and more. Here, is where the time-honoured Eastern philosophy, mysticism and spirituality may offer a solution to our western market-driven thinking. In the wise words of a Muslim philosopher and poet, Muhammad Iqbal:

In the West, Intellect is the source of life,

In the East, Love is the basis of life.
Through Love, Intellect grows acquainted
with Reality,
And Intellect gives stability to the work of
Love,
Arise and lay the foundations of a new world,
By wedding Intellect to Love

In addition, the so called modern world (both East and West) has much to learn from the spiritual and cultural values of the worlds many indigenous peoples, both past and present.  There exists much wisdom among the indigenous, containing lessons in sharing and equality and justice which can help draw ‘modern’ people into engagement with the deeper realities of their own dominant religions.  Also, people who live close to the earth, who possess an earth-based spirituality typically view themselves as part of nature, part of the earth, part of a community of species as well as being part of the human community.  

Among the indigenous not only do human beings derive tremendous benefits (physical, psychological, and spiritual) from nature, but all the elements of nature, (people, animals, plants, forest, rocks and streams) are regarded as living beings to be respected, reverenced, and to be in relationship with. These are the types of insights the world needs today in order to construct an environmental ethic which will allow us to enable an abundant flourishing of biodiversity on earth not only because we benefit from such diversity but also because it is right and moral.  We take to heart the words of a Laguna poet and author, Leslie Marmon Silko in StoryTeller.

“The earth is your mother,

she holds you.

The sky is your father,

he protects you.

Sleep,

sleep.

Rainbow is your sister,

she loves you.

The winds are your brothers,

They sing to you.

Sleep,

sleep.

We are together always

We are together always

There never was a time

when this

was not so.”

In a nut-shell, we believe that we should change our narrow economic obsessive and human centric language, terminology and values, to more inclusive ones. For us, our crises are not economic or monetary only, so to say. If they were, now that we have collectively poured in over 20 trillions of Dollars, Pounds, euros and more, into our economies, then, we should have had Heaven on Earth by now. We have not, because ours is a crisis of spirituality, of ethics, morality and love. Somehow we have lost our moral, spiritual and loving compass. Therefore, if any economic model, theory or prescription we may offer is going to be a good and useful one, then, it has to address these crises, thus, making the economics good and viable, as a subject under our control and not the other way round.

To achieve this, we suggest that students should be strongly encouraged to reflect upon the following as they begin their formal studies at the university. This will demonstrate how the economy can be made to serve the interests of society, and not the other way around, as it is today.

* Living happily is “the desire of us all, but our mind is blinded to a clear vision of just what it is that makes life happy”. The root of happiness is ethical behaviour, and thus the ancient idea of moral education and cultivation, is essential to ideal of joyfulness.

*In modern economics we have reduced humanity to a collection of individual, independent, utility maximizing creatures. And not without consequence, in our society success is too often defined by accumulation of material and financial wealth over a lifetime. We are ensconced in this free market ideology without questioning its morality and ethical foundations.  So watermarked is this spirit of economics and capitalism upon our lives that even though our hearts cry for a more meaningful and genuine existence, we are sucked back into the squirrel cage of capitalism, running faster and faster to “keep up with the Jones’s,” lamenting as we inwardly yearn for a simpler, more meaningful, and more genuine life.

* Economics, from the time of Plato right through to Adam Smith and John Stuart Mill, was as deeply concerned with issues of social justice, ethics and morality as it was with intrinsic economic analysis and questions of price theory. Most economics students today learn that Adam Smith was the ‘father of modern economics’ but not that he was also a moral philosopher. In 1759, sixteen years before his famous Wealth of Nations, Smith published The Theory of Moral Sentiments, which explored the self-interested nature of man and his ability nevertheless to make moral decisions based on factors other than selfishness, such as empathy and the desire for approval from others.

In The Wealth of Nations, Smith laid the early groundwork for economic analysis, but he embedded it in a broader discussion of social justice and the role of government. Students today know only of his analogy of the ‘invisible hand’ and his advocacy of free markets. They ignore his insight that the pursuit of wealth should not take precedence over social and moral obligations, and his belief that a ‘Divine Being’ gives us ‘the greatest quantity of happiness’. They are taught that the free market as a ‘way of life’ appealed to Adam Smith but not that he distrusted the morality of the market as a morality for society at large. He neither envisioned nor prescribed a capitalist society, but rather a ‘capitalist economy within society, a society held together by communities of non-capitalist and non-market morality’. As it has been noted, morality for Smith included neighbourly love, an obligation to practice justice, a norm of financial support for the government ‘in proportion to [one’s] revenue’, and a tendency in human nature to derive pleasure from the good fortune and happiness of other people.

*‘Economic rationality’ in the shape of neo-liberal globalisation is socially and politically suicidal. Justice and democracy are sacrificed on the altar of a mythical market as forces outside society rather than creations of it. However, free markets do not exist in a vacuum. They require a set of impartiality in government, honesty, justice, and public spiritedness in business. The best safeguard against fraud, theft, and injustice in markets are the cardinal virtues of justice, temperance, fortitude, and prudence, and the theological virtues of faith, hope, and charity.

*Every apparently economic choice is, in reality, a social choice. We can choose a society of basic rights – education, health, housing, child support and a dignified pension for example – or greed, pandemic inequality, ecological vandalism, civic chaos and social despair. Modern neo-liberal economics ignores the first and promotes the second path as the way to achieve economic efficiency and growth.

*The moral crises of global economic injustice today are integrally spiritual: they signal something terribly amiss in the relationship between human beings and the mystery of creation, the nature and the environment.
*It is the belief in collective responsibility and collective endeavour that allows individual freedom to flourish. This can only be realised when we commit ourselves to the common good and begin to serve it.
*There are four justifications for the common good which are not commonly discussed in economics:
1    Human beings need human contact, or sociability. The quality of that interaction is important, quite apart from any material benefits it may bring.
2    Human beings are formed in the community – their education and training in virtue (their preferences) are elements of the common good.
3    A healthy love for the common good is a necessary component of a fully developed personality.
4   The Common Good includes Nature. Human Beings need nature, biodiversity, and ecological balance not only for physical survival but also psychological and spiritual health.
*The marketplace is not just an economic sphere, ‘it is a region of the human spirit’. Profound economic questions are metaphysical and even spiritual in essence; in contrast to what is assumed today.  Economics can and should be concerned with the realm of the heart and spirit. Although self-interest is an important source of human motivation, driving the decisions we make in the marketplace every day, those decisions nevertheless have a moral, ethical and spiritual content, because each decision we make affects not only ourselves but others as well. We must combine the need for economic efficiency with the need for social justice and environmental sustainability and ecology.
*The greatest achievement of modern globalisation will eventually be seen as the opening of the possibility to build a humane and spiritually enriched globalised world through the universalising and globalising of compassion. But for ‘others’ to become ‘us’, for the world to become intimate with itself, we have to get to know each other better than we do now. Prejudices have to disappear: we have to see that cultural, religious and ethnic differences reflect an ultimate creative principle. For this to happen, the great cultures and religions need to enter into genuine dialogue with each other.
3- - Now is the Time for a Revolution in the Teaching of Economics
Much of what students need to learn in Economics courses is actually readily found in standard economic theory.  The typical course and textbook tends not to emphasize them however.  These concepts include externalities, public goods, imperfect competition, and the absence of information. All of these result in the failure of the market to work well. Theory makes it abundantly clear that, externalities such as pollution and waste result in market failure.  Yet, the typical student comes away from their economics course with the notion that markets usually work quite well.  Markets though in fact do not actually work so well, as externalities are not only widespread but are quite significant in the production and consumption of most goods and services.  Governments usually do not sufficiently tax or otherwise restrict negative externalities and do not sufficiently subsidize or otherwise enlarge positive externalities.
Public Goods, goods which are non-rivalrous in consumption and non-exclusive are not according to standard theory able to be supplied sufficiently by the market.  Public Goods not only include national defense, fire and police protection, but also biodiversity, fighting global warming, clean air, community, and social justice. Public Goods can not be somehow converted into private goods.  According to standard theory government must either work to provide public goods or take other steps to insure their provision.  The typical Economics student is not sufficiently grounded in this failure of the market.
In the case of imperfect competition, not only monopoly and monopsony but also any market structure where the number of sellers or buyers is less than a large number, standard theory says that the market fails, that a sort of contrived shortage will result.  This of course means higher prices and a lower quantity of the good for consumers.  In theoretical economics a large number means a number so large that any individual seller or buyer is powerless to affect the market price.  If a market were actually perfectly competitive selling firms would have absolutely no need of a marketing department.  Imperfect Competition also invites collusion and even more contrived shortage.  Imperfect Competition and not Perfect Competition is the usual condition of markets, yet that is not what most students take with them after the Final from their Economics course.  
Finally even if human beings were as rational as Standard Economics assumes, markets would fail to be welfare enhancing if consumers really do not know the full range of benefits and costs of the products they are consuming.  The full range of costs and benefits would include all manner of health and safety criterion, effects upon human relationships, and even state of mind and spirit.  Of course human beings don’t know the full range of benefits and costs in the products they buy or in the jobs and labor they partake in.  Hence we have another case of markets failing, not just once in a while but in fact almost continuously, yet students typically do not grasp these limitations of the market.
In spite of the ready admission in standard economics that GDP is not a measure of Welfare, not even economic welfare, there is nonetheless a theoretical and policy obsession with GDP and its growth.  Mention is of course frequently made of Tobin and Nordhaus and their Measure of Economic Welfare or even Bhutan’s Gross National Happiness but the focus of Macro Economics as well as Growth Theory is inordinately upon GDP and not developing improved alternative measures.
A sustainable and prosperous global economy needs to be for the common good, in which a fair society and the environment accompany profits. The failure of markets, institutions and morality during the current financial crisis has shown that the emergence of global capitalism had brought a new set of risks demanding an ethical, moral and spiritual framework.
Bankers have accused the politicians, politicians have accused the bankers and many have accused the business schools, while the ordinary citizens see the failings of all.
Thus, it is vitally important to teach that humanity flourishes only in a culture of respect for the individual, but that the common good has priority over individual interests. They should teach not only the business models and theories, but also draw on universal principles of respect for life, justice and solidarity, honesty and tolerance, and mutual esteem and partnership.
In short, it is now clear that, capitalism for the 21st century needs a fundamentally renewed morality to underpin it. To achieve this we must ask ourselves again what progress really is. Is it the accumulation of wealth, or is it a broader, more integrated understanding of well-being and quality of life? Surveys consistently show that economic progress has not been accompanied by the expected increase in happiness, and that the price paid by many has been in the quality of human relationships as well as the human connection to the environment. On average, people do not think of themselves as happier or better off, than what their parents were, even though their material standard of living is, in so many societies, unquestionably higher.
There has, in particular, been a marked decline in people’s perception of whom they can trust. The collapse in perceived trustworthiness is most marked in relation to the banking sector, but applies to the business world, more broadly, as trust has declined generally within family life and social relationships. As such, it is not surprising that, in the public mind that the system is not working as it should.
The seeds of the next crisis may already be sown and will surely grow to maturity, if we do not learn from the past and the current crises, and if we do not attempt to address the core issues. Given the enormity of the collapse, the usual excuses coupled with a whitewash for the basic structure of the global financial/economic system will not suffice. The House of Neo-liberalism, Washington Consensus and Market Fundamentalism has collapsed. The emperor has no clothes and the public is becoming quite fond of pointing it out.
What is the main role and function of a "good" business education? Is it to equip students with marketable skills, and to help their countries compete in a global, information-based workplace only? Has this narrow focus perhaps overwhelmed other historically important purposes of education, and thus, short-changed us all?
If there is a shared national purpose for education, should it be oriented only toward enhancing the narrow vision of a country's economic success? Should education be answerable only to a narrowly defined economic bottom line, or do we need to discover a more comprehensive, inclusive bottom line, given the catastrophic crises that we are witnessing all around us? Are the interests of the individuals and selective groups overwhelming the common good that the education system is meant to support?
The current financial crises has given us a golden opportunity to ask ourselves some fundamental questions on the role of economic and business education and our possible contributions to these crises. Soul-searching and self-criticism should not be seen as a source of weakness, but as a source of strength, humility and the search for wisdom. What part have the business schools and business academics played in the implosion of the world's banking system? Lest we forget, hedge funds, private equity, investment banking, venture capital, subprime mortgages, pyramids and more, were the overwhelming preferred job destinations of MBA’s.
In order to ensure that our economic and business education, produce graduates and the MBAs capable of rising to the challenges the world faces today, we propose an ongoing comprehensive examination and study of the major attempts to integrate economics with ethics and spirituality, along with an exploration of the theoretical underpinnings of these activities. Our central focus should be on solutions to the global economic crisis, broadly defined and understood. In considering the need for bold economic initiatives, we must keep in mind the deeper questions that rarely find their way into political debate or public discourse; questions that are deeply ethical and spiritual.  We need to honestly examine a new set of questions which could begin with the following to pave the way for dialogue:
*What is the source of true happiness and well-being? *What is the good life? *What is the purpose of economic life? *What does it mean to be a human being living on a spaceship with finite resources? *How can the global financial system become more responsive and just?    *What paths can be recommended to shift the current destructive global political-economic order from one of unrestrained economic growth, profit maximisation and cost minimisation, targets and bonuses to one that embraces material wealth creation, yet also preserves and enhances social and ecological well-being and increases human happiness and contentment?*How should we deal with individual and institutionalized greed?*What are the requirements of a virtuous economy? *What role should universities play in building an integrity-based model of business education?
*What should be the role of the youth? *How might the training of young executives be directed with the intention of supplying insights into the nature of globalisation from its economic, technological and spiritual perspectives, to build supporting relationships among the participants that will lead toward action for the common good within their chosen careers? *Indeed, is ethical, profitable, efficient and sustainable capitalism possible?
These questions and more need to be reflected upon, debated and ultimately answered and put into policy formation, guiding us to a more humane globalisation, enabling us all to live a more fulfilling life. 
4- Now is the Time for a new definition of the “Bottom Line” and other specifics in a New Way to Teach Economics
We should acknowledge that the new bottom line must not be all about economic and monetary targets, profit maximisation and cost minimisation, but it should involve spiritual, social and environmental consideration. When practiced under these values, then, the business is real, viable, sustainable, efficient and profitable.
Therefore, the New Bottom Line that we should tell the students now could read as follow:
“"Corporations, government policies, our educational, legal and health care practices, every institution, law, social policy and even our private behaviour should be judged 'rational', 'efficient', or 'productive' not only to the extent that they maximize money and power (The Old Bottom Line) but ALSO to the extent that they maximize love and caring, kindness and generosity, ethical and ecological behaviour, and contribute to our capacity to respond with awe, wonder and radical amazement at the grandeur and mystery of the universe and all being."
In contradistinction to the narrow profit only “old” bottom line approach of recent decades for individuals, firms, nations, and the globe, which has so pervaded public policy, social attitudes, and even economics, it was not always so.  In the early 1970’s even a conservative American president, Richard Nixon, favored a guaranteed annual income and the creation of the Environmental Protection Agency, while Milton Friedman found no fault with environmental laws consistently applied and supported a guaranteed annual income for all.  
Before either of them, such an ardent champion of free markets as Frederick Hayek wrote in favor of government social insurance, provision of basic needs for all, and the consistency of environmental, health and safety laws with basic free market principles.  
“ … Nor is there any reason why the state should not assist the individuals in providing for those common hazards of life against which, because of their uncertainty, few individuals can make adequate provision.  Where, as in the case of sickness and accident, neither the desire to avoid such calamities nor the efforts to overcome their consequences are as a rule weakened by the provision of assistance – where, in short, we deal with genuinely insurable risks – the case for the state’s helping to organize a comprehensive system of social insurance is very strong.” (See Hayek, The Road to Serfdom, 1944, p120)
In all, it is abundantly clear that, there is more to life than the accumulation of wealth for individuals.  There is so much that makes us happy and gives meaning beyond wealth, and that would include concern for others and their wellbeing.  There is more that truly matters to society than GDP; community, relationships, health, and the environment matter far more.  Finally there is more that should concern business than a narrow view of the bottom line.  Not so long ago business firms saw themselves as grounded in particular local communities as participants and members.  We call for a new bottom line for individuals, for firms, nations, and the globe, a broader view of what truly matters, fully recognizing that it means reversing a trend of narrowness and hard hearted social policies, which has lasted far too long, these last thirty years.  
The old narrow bottom line coupled with Neo-Liberalism, Market Fundamentalism, and the Washington Consensus creating a climate at the global and national level which fostered derision of the common good, discouraged social safety nets, merit goods, and public ownership of public infrastructure. This narrowly obsessive view of the bottom line was taken from firm, to nation, to the globe. It engendered a policy agenda that has stood in the way of real improvements in the lives of the poor, and in being able to restructure the global economic system, in order to provide basic needs to all of the world’s people.   
This hard hearted ideology has had far too much influence in recent decades. Born and bred from the seeds of ideas in academic circles, and nurtured by the inadequacies of Economic/Business education, it has infected policy for far too long.  The seeds of its perceived inadequacy and demise must also be born and bred in academic circles. We must find a new way to teach Economics and Business in order to be part of the process of global transformation and social healing which simply must occur if we are to avert disaster.
Moreover, we should all answer the call of Albert Einstein, when he challenged us by reminding that,
“A human being is a part of a whole, called by us ‘universe’, a part limited in time and space. He experiences himself, his thoughts and feelings as something separated from the rest… a kind of optical delusion of his consciousness. This delusion is a kind of prison for us, restricting us to our personal desires and to affection for a few persons nearest to us. Our task must be to free ourselves from this prison by widening our circle of compassion to embrace all living creatures and the whole of nature in its beauty.”  
Economic/Business education should be built upon the following key pillars in our view.  These are pillars it rarely contains today.
*It should be built on the belief that leadership is based upon a deep understanding of the self and of the core values that drive one’s actions.  Thus effective leadership requires the development of a compelling personal vision that engages others by offering meaning, dignity, and purpose.  The ultimate aim of leadership is the building of more humane relationships, organizations, and societies.  Effective leaders need to develop the critical imagination required to embrace individual, organizational, and global change from a stance of hope and courage. 
*The education path must attempt to provide a learning community in which students can develop the personal qualities of self-knowledge, self-acceptance, a restless curiosity, a desire for truth, a mature concern for others, respect for human individuality, and a thirst for justice.   The Programme of study must promote academic excellence and facilitates the strengthening of conceptual, scholarly, and professional competencies for use in leadership roles that serve others. The defining of the common good, in the context of personal, organisational, and global leadership, should be an important goal of this education and training.
*It should address the need for collaborative forms of leadership in a shared-power world.  There is an increasing need for interdependent and interrelated solutions to the complex ecological, political, cultural, health, and economic problems facing the people of our planet. These solutions must honor the voices of all global citizens and stakeholders from individuals to small groups to global organizations.  These solutions will involve various mixtures of government (global, national, and local), private enterprise, NGO’s, as well as labor and environmental organizations.  
In all, in a world of rising uncertainty — no matter where we live — the key question before all of us is this: How can the debate on global issues become more inclusive and better informed? How can people develop a better understanding of what connects — and divides — nations, societies and cultures in today's world?
5- - Now is the Time for New Economic Text books
We should acknowledge that economics textbooks, built upon  Samuelson’s ideology as depicted in his much criticised, Foundations, or Friedman’s ideology as depicted in his well known Free To Choose, or Buchanan’s Public Choice Theory cannot any longer be the bedrock of economic wisdom that they for so long have disgracefully pretended to be. Economics is historically a pluralism of many multi-dimensional conversations. Today’s textbooks are not sufficiently pluralistic. Economics should not be all about pandering to incompressible mathematical jargon and calculus, as well as unrealistic assumptions, including rationality, and market ideology. Economics once was, and is still at its best, far more than these.
As it has been observed, in the mid 1990s about 1.4 million students took principles classes in the United States.  All 20 best selling introductory macroeconomics textbooks in the U.S. are basically neoclassical texts. It is unlikely that even 1% of the students use a non-neoclassical principles text. The study of economics-if it is going to be a useful tool of analysis and understanding- doe not begin and end with distillation of Paul Samuelson and Milton Friedman/James Buchanan and only all points in-between. To pretend it does, is to ignore the full range of human instincts, needs, desires, and dreams. It is also quite neglectful of history and anthropology.
Yet, this is the narrow space which mainstream textbooks inhabit.  The criticism of Paul Samuelson is well deserved, particularly his obsession with economic growth.  He tied full employment to continued economic growth rather than an economy that prioritized basic human needs and guaranteed meaningful employment to all.  While Samuelson was preoccupied with Economic Growth, viewing it as the solution to all manner of human problems, (Ben Friedman recently even claimed that economic growth caused increased moral behaviour, See Friedman, Ben, The Moral Consequences of Economic Growth, 2005), Milton Friedman/James Buchanan in their almost unrestrained advocacy of free markets shorn of regulation and law, provided much of the intellectual fodder for and helped to enable market fundamentalism.
Mainstream economics textbooks have many weaknesses, it is very hard indeed to know where to stop in listing them. But for the sake of context here are a few examples. So, in no particular order these weaknesses include:

1) The pretence that people are rational and disciplined.
2) The pretence that more things make us happy.
3) The pretence that markets are mostly perfectly competitive.
4) The pretence that the economy can be studied in isolation from other subjects and disciplines.
5) The pretence that history does not matter.
6) The pretence that what matters most is to master mathematics and calculus.
7) The pretence that there exists in nature resources that are free for the taking or are unlimited.
8) The pretence that human welfare is unrelated to the welfare of the planet and other species.
We have arrived at this sorry state of affairs, because, there is a prevailing trend among a number of prominent economists- many these with best selling textbooks, who have become millionaires- which hold that they have a virtual monopoly on understanding economics. Indeed, believing that every field of human endeavour is explainable in economic terms, they have developed a new sub-discipline that interprets all human motivations and relations, including family life, cultural/civilisational dialogue and more in terms of mere cost-benefit analysis. This new hyper-economic school of thought in effect has become a new “fundamentalist” religion, drunk in its own false importance and pomposity, pretending to believe that all that matters in life functions by market forces and can best be understood as a consumer commodity. In contrast to the rich and diverse moral philosophy that has spun the centuries, how narrow minded and without soul or meaning has economics become!
                           Summary and Conclusion
As trained Economists who love our field and who have taught it for many years, while aware of its shortcomings, we are deeply troubled by the multiple crises that are engulfing the economy as well as Economics and our profession.  Yet it is an exciting time for our field, as opportunities for change give us a chance at emerging significant transitions and breakthroughs.  We rejoice in the opportunity that our field has now to reground itself in moral philosophy amid the deeper broader questions of human existence, meaning, and happiness, while mindful that humanity is a member of a larger community of multiple species and elements, necessary for our survival and health.
We have described in this paper how the current financial and economic crisis of the last few years is not the sole or even the most important crisis faced by humanity and this planet.  The crisis of social injustice, inequality, loss of community and thereby dire economic insecurity for hundreds and hundreds of millions of people shows no sign of ending soon.  At the same time the environmental crisis, consisting of climate change, habitat loss, pollution, and waste, grows exponentially, even as human institutions and structures prove themselves both incapable of dealing effectively with the crisis while at the same time standing in the way of needed progress.  Many of the same misguided ethics, philosophies, and politics which gave rise to the financial crisis, also gave rise to the crisis of inequality as well as the environmental crisis.
While distinct from Market Fundamentalism, too often Economics and the Economics Profession has been eerily quite in the face of its ascendancy, even as some Economists have enabled this ideology.  Standard theory, due to a lack of emphasis upon market failure as well as the limitations of standard theory is also not without blame.  
We have asserted in this paper that the purpose of an Economy is threefold.  An Economy must provide for basic needs for all of the worlds peoples.  It must help to establish, maintain, and nurture human relationships and community.  Finally it must be sustainable while allowing for a flourishing of abundant biological diversity on this planet.
In order to accomplish this, we, as a global human society must set our sights upon the Common Good and this involves four basic realizations:
1) Human Beings need contact with other human beings.  We need relationships as we are social beings.  It is in our relationships that we find genuine happiness and meaning.  
2) Human Beings need community, apart and distinct from our individual relationships with other human beings. There is a connection to the whole, a belonging to the community which is key to happiness and meaning. Such is manifest in socialization and education among many other aspects of community.  
3) A love for the Common Good is essential for the psychological and spiritual health of the individual.  
4) Nature, the web of life, and the integrity of the earth are also part of the Common Good, and neither the human community nor the individual person can be healthy without this aspect of the Common Good.
In order for Economics to be not only part of the transition and change which is so desperately needed, but to play a leading constructive role, of which it is capable we call Economics and Economists to significant change, amid the need for dialogue on specific solutions.  We must begin a journey of wisdom.  There is a certain beauty in the rigor and splendor of the typical highly mathematical standard model in economics.  If we found no beauty in such models, it would have been impossible to have become an Economist.  
Yet, there is a need to go well beyond the standard models and the typical assumptions.  We must reach more deeply and more broadly for wisdom.  We claim that now is the time for a revolution in Economic thinking.  There is not only much that can be learned from Western religions and philosophy such as Christianity, but also from Eastern Mysticism and Spirituality, including Islam, Hinduism, and Buddhism, and others.  In addition there is great wisdom in the cultural and spiritual values of indigenous peoples, past and present.  
Economics must find ways to incorporate all of these lessons in equality, social justice, ecological balance, and respect for the earth, community and relationship into its standard approach.  And that incorporation will be the revolution in economic thinking for which we call.  We proclaim and demonstrate that now also is the time for a revolution in the teaching of economics.  It can not wait.  We need to teach students a new bottom line. We have described many specifics on what needs to be taught.  Finally we call for new economics textbooks, while citing the deficiencies of those most popular.  
This is an exciting time for our field, for our profession, for our passion.  Yet, it is also a troubling time.  As we have said, Economics is not without blame for the crises which are engulfing the planet, the economy, and our profession.  Economics must change.  What we teach students must change.  It must change if it is to play a constructive role in solving the multiple and multi-dimensional crises that so engulf our world, our species, the fabric of human community, relationship, and the web of life.  We are running out of time.  If our field does not change, if the revolution in thinking we have called for does not happen, if we do not revisit the rich and fertile soil in which our field was born, that being moral philosophy amid the broader questions of human existence, meaning, and ecology, then not only will we have retreated from the chance to play a constructive role in solving these crises, we will inherit well deserved scorn and contempt.  The opportunity is upon us.  Let us seize it.  Carpe Diem!
Suggested Readings
In order to rescue our subject from the arrogant “fundamentalists”, who have brought us a very bitter harvest, and to move the field beyond the confines and limitations of standard theory, we suggest the following books, amongst others, that must be offered to students as part of their main reading list, not in their optional modules alone, but in their core courses as well:
Anielski, Mark (2007) The Economics of Happiness- Building Genuine Wealth, Gabriola Island: New Society Publishers
Blank, Rebecca M (2004) Is the Market Moral? Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press
Bloom, Alan (1987) The Closing of the American Mind: How Higher Education has Failed Democracy and Impoverished the Soul’s of Today’s Students, New York: Penguin
Brown, Garver, Helmuth, Howell, and Szeghi (2008) Right Relationship: Building a Whole Earth Economy, San Francisco: Berrett-Koehler Publications Inc.
Bunting, Madeline (2005) Willing Slaves: How the overwork culture is ruining our lives, London: Harper
Dallmayer, Fred (2007) In search of the Good Life-A Pedagogy for Troubled Times, Lexington: The University Press of Kentucky
Daly, Herman (1996) Beyond Growth, Washington DC: Beacon Press
Elgin, Duane (1981) Voluntary Simplicity-towards a way of life that is outwardly simple, inwardly rich, New York: William Morrow   
Frankham, Myron, (2004) World Democratic Federalism: Peace and Justice Indivisible, London: Palgrove-Mcmillan
Fullbrooke, Edward (ed) (2004) A Guide to What’s Wrong with
Economics, London: Anthem Press
Gaffney, Mason and Fred Harrison (1994) The Corruption of Economics, London: Shepheard-Walwyn
Galbraith, John Kenneth (1958) The Affluent Society, New York: New American Library
____________________  (1971) Economics Peace &Laughter, New York: New American Library
Gold, Lorna (2004) The Sharing Economy: solidarity Networks Transforming Globalisation, Aldershot: Ashgate
Grayling, AC (1998) Moral Values, London: Weidenfield and Nicolson
___________ (2003) What is Good? London: Weidenfield and Nicolson
Haidt, Jonathan (2007) The Happiness Hypothesis-finding modern truth in ancient wisdom, New York: Basic Books
Henderson, Hazel (1999) Beyond Globalization: Shaping a Sustainable Global Economy, Bloomfield: Kumarion Press
Jackson, Tim (2009) Prosperity Without Growth-Economics for a Finite Planet, London and New York: Earthscan
Keen, Steve (2001) Debunking Economics: The Naked Emperor of the Social Sciences, Annandale: Pluto Press
Keynes, John Maynard (1930) Economic Possibilities for our Grandchildren, Essays in persuasion, New York: W.W.Norton&Co
Kuttner, Robert (2007) The Squandering of America: How the Failure of Our Politics Imperils Our Prosperity, New York: Alfred Knopf
Krugman, Paul (2007) The Conscience of a Liberal, New York: W. W. Norton
Layard, Richard (2005) Happiness, London: Penguin
Lutz, Mark A (1999) Economics for the Common Good: Two Centuries of Social Economic Thought in the Humanistic Tradition, London and New York: Routledge
Meadows, Donella H, Dennis L. Meadows, Jorgen Randers and William W. Behrens III (1972) The Limits to Growth- A Report for the Club of Rome’s project on the Predicament of Mankind, New York: The New American Library
Mill, John Stuart (1848) (reprinted 2004) Principles of Political Economy, Great Minds Series, New York: Prometheus Books
Milward, Peter (2006) What is a University? London: Shepheard-Walwyn
Mofid, Kamran (2002) Globalisation for the Common Good, London: Shepheard-Walwyn
Mofid, Kamran and Marcus Braybrooke (2005) Promoting the Common Good-Bringing Economics and Theology Together Again, London: Shepheard-Walwyn
Nelson, Melissa K. (2008) Original Instructions: Indigenous Teachings for a Sustainable Future, Rochester, VT: Bear
Ormerod, Paul (1994) The Death of Economics, London: Faber &Faber
___________ (1998) Butterfly Economics, London: Faber& Faber
Porritt, Jonathon (2005) Capitalism-as if the world matters,            London: Earhscan
Schumacher, E.F (1973) Small is Beautiful: Economics as if People Mattered, London: Bland &Briggs
______________ (1997) A Guide for the Perplexed, London: Jonathan Cape
Sen, Amartya (1998) On Ethics and Economics, Oxford: Basil Blackwell
Smith, Adam (1776) (reprinted 1937) An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations, New York: Modern Library
Stiglitz, Joseph (2006) Making Globalization Work, New York: W. W. Norton
Szeghi, Steve (2006) Lessons in Development and Service on the Dine (Navajo) Nation, Journal of Economics and Politics, volumes 17 & 18
Tawney, R.H (1921) The Acquisitive Society, London: G. Bell& Sons
__________ (1926) Religion and the Rise of Capitalism, London: John Murray
__________ (1931) Equality, London: Allen & Unwin
Wilkinson, Richard and Kate Pickett (2009) The Spirit Level-why more equal societies almost always do better, London: Penguin
                  About the Authors
*Kamran Mofid is Adjunct Professor at Dalhousie School of Business, Dalhousie University, Canada, Founder of the Globalisation for the Common Good Initiative (Oxford, 2002) and Co- founder/Editor, Journal of Globalisation for the Common Good, and member of the International Coordinating Committee (ICC) of the World Public Forum, Dialogue of Civilisations.  In 1986 he was awarded his doctorate in economics from the University of Birmingham, UK. In 2001 he received a Certificate in Education in Pastoral Studies at Plater College, Oxford. From 1980 to 2000 he was Economic Tutor, Lecturer and Senior Lecturer at Universities of Windsor (Canada), Birmingham, Bristol, Wolverhampton, and Coventry (UK). Mofid's work is highly interdisciplinary, drawing on Economics, Politics, International Relations, Theology, Culture, Ecology, Ethics and Spirituality. Mofid's writings have appeared in leading scholarly journals, popular magazines and newspapers.  His books include Development Planning in Iran: From Monarchy to Islamic Republic , The Economic Consequences of the Gulf war, Globalisation for the Common Good, Business Ethics, Corporate Social Responsibility and Globalisation for the Common Good , Promoting the Common Good (with Rev. Marcus Braybrooke, 2005), and A non-Violent Path to Conflict Resolution and Peace Building (Co-authored).

* Steve Szeghi, Professor of Economics, at
Wilmington College, Ohio, is co-author of Right Relationship: Building a Whole Earth Economy.  At Wilmington since 1987 he served as Department Chair in Economics and Business, from 1998-2005. Szeghi writes on Social Justice, and Ecology, in relation to the Economy and Economic Theory, highlighting the socio-political economies of indigenous peoples as an alternative system. Mindful of the values and economies of indigenous peoples, Szeghi has grown to question many of the assumptions of standard economic theory.  While incorporating these themes into existing courses he developed a popular student study trip class called, Wilderness, Resources, and Indigenous Peoples of the Southwest. In his youth, Szeghi worked with Cesar Chavez and the United Farm Workers. Today he supports and consults for Labor Unions, and Environmental Groups. He has worked with American Indian Tribal organizations in support of social change/development favored by indigenous communities.

Go to top
Notice: Undefined index: adv in /home/kamranmofid/public_html/templates/jsn_epic_pro/index.php on line 654
tom kaulitz accident de viagra viagra einnahme lilly cialis cialis free jengibre viagra natural fighter pilots and viagra no pprescription 40mg furosemide canadien pharmacy side effects of viagra levitra and cialis drug interations vicodin valium viagra legal vender viagra viagra blue halo viagra side effects four hour erection viagra from mexico buy clomiphene citrate online cialis commercials cialis dosage instructions buy viagra price order cialis 5 mg viagra keeps flowers wilting viagra us to us shipping legal viagra online vendita viagra internet rx viagra kamagra kopen amsterdam generic cialis usa kamagra oral jelly vs viagra does cialis one a day work virtual viagra desktop emoticon viagra without ed viagra 40 for $99 generic viagra definition viagra for sale chicago price of viagra at walmart original viagra online kaufen online pharmacy generic cialis pills viagra hernia get viagra prescription canada buy viagra genuine efectos del viagra masculino en la mujer viagra line south africa viagra topical use the cheapest viagra in the world viagra forum which is best generic champix rxlist viagra prescription melbourne prednisone 10mg dose pack canadameds viagra bluelight buy viagra today buy viagra legally online cialis discount coupon venta viagra concepcion viagra sample dallas viagra patent in uk discreet viagra now costs of viagra vs cialis viagra femenino wiki viagra vs viagra professional recommended doses for viagra nitroglycerine sideaffects with viagra buy viagra gel uk presentaciones y precio de viagra viagra deutschland rezeptfrei viagra improves erectile function by pastile de viagra cialis 5mg cost viagra ice cream buy where is viagra sold over the counter maximum dose of viagra extended use viagra levitra hypertension female viagra samples buy clomid online no prescription uk how easy is it to get prescribed viagra buy viagra in canada long before intercourse should you take viagra photo effective viagra viagra 100mg price in nigeria viagra female response viagra retinitis pigmentaria viagra nigeria viagra 100mg recommended dosage viagra price in kolkata cialis chewable tablets how to buy viagra online without 24h berlin gloria viagra viagra side effects sleeplessness medistar viagra making your own viagra canadianonlinedrugs viagra deutchland cialis knee pain good substitute for viagra how long does it take viagra to start long term side efects of viagra quick forum readtopic viagra signature search viagra como se utiliza viagra and food has anyone purchased viagra online viagra prezzo italia does viagra work for women 2011 pfizer viagra new indication approval 2009 online pharmacy canada generic cialis cheapest viagra net viagra and sudafed amoxil generic name prices for viagra how to order cialis from india Cheap effexor without prescription aricept generic vs brand viagra coupons from manufacturer best price on viagra 100mg viagra urinary infection prednisone order online best buy online propecia viagra yahoo answers cialis substitute viagra ethnic discrimination canadian viagra reviews where to get viagra forum ordering celais viagra sin resultados perscription water pill viagra 100mg strong viagra pill buy does viagra produce nitric oxide efectos viagra niños viagra y medicamentos similares does viagra have nitrates how long does viagra stay in your system test sildenafil aurochem 100mg viagra under tongue crushed viagra radio ad order viagra online us buy generic viagra online paypal zofran zydis wafers 8mg best viagra alternative levitra active ingredient viagra safe use wendi virtual viagra tadalafil online uk viagra herbal españa cytotec on line sale without prescription what is kamagra tablets viagra citrus juice how to tell if your man is taking viagra cialis online without acquisto cialis in italia viagra dosage per weight anafranil cialis viagra website get a prescription for viagra online china viagra clitoris viagra viagra prescribed online using viagra when drunk buy viagra for sale super kamagra apotheke were can i buy real viragra prednisone and dizziness stop cialis email buying generic viagra online definition viagra jelly tosh gay viagra generique viagra pfizer belgique indocin efficacy of generic cialis viagra femenino y alcohol kamagra australia shop rx viagra buy cipro online viagra equivalents buy viagra in houston buy prednisone canadian super store buy generic viagra on line canadian pharmacy without prescritpion comprar viagra sem receita rio de janeiro buy generic viagra online india vendo viagra chile when will generic cialis be available best generic viagra prices viagra malaysia cialis vs flomax daily dose cialis robust vs viagra viagra dosage for hypertension levitra manufacturer break viagra in half buy cialis usa buy cialis from canada your viagra price online generic name of viagra is viagra covered by saho viagra lasts for furosemide 40 mg can i use viagra with high blood pressure does viagra makes you last long viagra amazon.co.uk order cialis from india kann man viagra ohne rezept kaufen apotheke buy cheap viagra prescription online can viagra and levitra be taken together viagra sale uk mail order cialis ad actors mail order viagra from canada would happen if female takes viagra alternative al viagra viagra for 30 year olds is generic viagra safe and effective dissolve viagra in mouth can i buy viagra in puerto rico sildenafil cost canada efectos secundarios de viagra order viagra online cheap levitra without prescription 25 g of viagra viagra online australian pharmacy viagra drinking water cialis o viagra mejor how to buy viagra on craigslist expired viagra generic viagra pills online meds without prescription buy viagra without getting ripped off cialis online kopen patent protection for viagra cheap anti fungal pills viagra uk boots ok to take 2 viagra viagra safe with high blood pressure viagra substitutes australia zithromax sildenafil cost boots viagra ocular hypertension how long viagra stay in your system viagra massage koh chang 100mg viagra price generic zithromax uk safe site to buy cialis long advance do you take viagra como hacer viagra casero para mujeres blue zeus viagra viagra risk factors que es el viagra y como funciona buy cialis online express delivery cialis 5mgs cialis black alternative viagra uses viagra commercial african american can you take cialis with viagra viagra edinburgh pages search free buy inderal online reliable source viagra talk buy viagra australia paypal nitroglycerin und viagra viagra dosage recommended free viagra trial viagra lawyer ohio when bush takes viagra viagra spain viagra linked to melanoma erfahrungsberichte mit cialis cymbalta generic 1000 ways to die viagra overdose viagra nl bestellen viagra usa generic patent expiration cialis online viagra price comparison what does viagra do to women kann viagra holland kaufen viagra trial size doxycycline online no prescription uk cialis dream pharmaceutical proscar canada online Buy Estradiol Online Canada viagra generic usa viagra injection video is viagra bad if you dont need it strattera glyburide viagra principio ativo do viagra generico cialis when to take boys viagra stories generic viagra new zealand nova sildenafil viagra covered by insurance 2012 tesco pharmacy viagra prices what works better levitra or viagra virus hotmail envia correos viagra can anyone get a prescription for viagra where to buy viagra online 2013 viagra 100mg india price viagra hcp why is viagra given to babies 50mg viagra prices clonidine hcl viagra no prescription online pharmacy cheap bulk viagra bestpricetabs viagra za potenciju viagra free trial coupon does viagra work with alcohol purchase kamagra oral jelly viagra dosage cialis free 30 day trial viagra dosage normal viagra online diagnosis cheap generic viagra online how long does levitra last in your system cialis tedavi edermi information on viagra does cialis make you feel sleepy are tired viagra natural herbs cost of private prescription viagra viagra 100mg review generic viagra cheap no prescription viagra vision side effects generic viagra online site reviews viva viagra lyrics the affects of viagra prednisone purchase no prescription can you take viagra every day usa viagra izmir viagra rezeptfrei deutschland is cialis bad for you can you just buy viagra viagra wellbutrin interaction buy cheap viagra online uk next day delivery what is sildenafil citrate CANADIAN PHARMACIES SELLING OTC PRODUCTS cheapest genuine viagra cialis wiki herbal equivalent to viagra proscar generic canada best prices on brand viagra viagra triangle chicago hotels cheapest way to buy viagra robin williams viagra youtube slimming tablets female viagra viagra launch success levitra canada pharmacy number of ways to spell viagra female pink viagra 100mg pills where to buy pfizer viagra levitra kaufen online levitra professional reviews cialis bathtub commercial where to buy viagra edmonton flagyl buy where can i find viagra viagra ed ac uk viagra online fast shipping no prescription lisinopril buy online no prescription overnight viagra cialis indian pharmacy what is equivalent alternatives to atenolol viagra pfizer español viagra brands in australia canada pharmacy discounted viagra 100 viagra de 100 mg precio viagra nobel prize viagra for children gnc viagra cialis super active plus how long before viagra takes effect viagra 50mg getting a prescription for viagra viagra online singapore viagra vision problems discount on viagra viagra suppository el viagra no funciona sin excitación doctor ahorro viagra larry david viagra comprar levitra online cialis without ed onde comprar viagra em belo horizonte viagra chino colombia cialis prescription dosage can i buy viagra in turkey ed trial pack canada viagra pd sexual viagra how much is a prescription of cialis pfizer viagra female viagra in homeopathy viagra generic any good viagra feminin spray nasal viagra generico walmart viagra back pain is viagra worth it precio viagra simi on line viagra otc prednisone viagra effect of watermelon can viagra cause gout vardenafil 20mg - levitra generika viagra how long to kick in viagra drink recipe boots the chemist viagra ed-apotheke.eu viagra viagra equivalent for females price of cialis at walmart does viagra delayed ejaculation buy viagra and cialis apa itu pil viagra viagra with adderall can viagra damage viagra infertility cimetidine and viagra taking viagra without telling your partner viagra online apotheke rezeptfrei viagra gdzie najlepiej kupic viagra length of erection free older viagra movies viagra effect on women buy viagra 50 mg online cialis mensuel how do i buy cialis online viagra discussion doctor can viagra increase sperm count price of viagra in rupees how to get viagra sample free cialis drug viagra abroad buy cialis 10mg online avanafil vs viagra viagra heart palpitations will hmsa cover viagra viagra online london red bull with viagra can you buy viagra in patong generic viagra costs can i break a viagra pill viagra where to buy online viagra español viagra xhamster antibiotic sale online recreational cialis l-arginina y el viagra on line prednisone liquid viagra or cialis generic viagra vs kamagra over counter cialis canada metronidazole over the counter walgreens prednisone to buy making viagra work better best place to buy amoxil generic viagra legal usa provigra acheter viagra ligne viagra de venta libre en farmacias viagra online america buy propecia online no prescription needed quick does viagra kick kamagra 100mg (viagra) oral jelly viagra tablets for womens in india viagra sleepy i took a viagra and it got stuck in my throat many hours does viagra work best online store to buy cialis problems ordering viagra online cialis bez recepty warszawa viagra in a drink amyl nitrate and viagra where to buy cialis over the counter buy viagra cambodia viagra and psychogenic ed women viagra arousal viagra cialis levitra canadian pharmacy where can i buy viagra in darwin viagra group viagra on pulmonary hypertension viagra side effects blue vision levitra 20 mg prices what can i buy over the counter that works like viagra viagra in heart failure buying cialis safely online buy online viagra india cialis generica barata generic valtrex no prescription drmedrx medica viagra 50 mg yahoo what works better cialis or viagra does viagra expire viagra a vendre montreal viagra what does it look like wirkt viagra bluthochdruck what is viagra yahoo viagra best buy reviews effet du viagra sur un homme what kind of doctor prescribes viagra is it illegal to buy viagra online in ireland viagra buy in uk online viagra rosen cheap levitra online next day delivery chep viagra cialis satan eczaneler viagra covered healthcare viagra after prostate cancer viagra to treat pulmonary hypertension pink viagra germany viagra 50 mg fiyatı liquid viagra forum best time to take cialis 20mg best place buy viagra yahoo love recipe viagra can you buy viagra legally in uk best place to buy viagra online 2015 bad headache after viagra otc viagra in canada food substitute for viagra generic name for viagra in india avoid upset stomach viagra viagra online order usa can you buy viagra in costa rica viagra model penggunaan cialis prezzo cialis 5 mg where can i buy cialis in singapore when is cialis going generic viagra sample pack free viagra and lisinopril interaction el viagra y sus consecuencias viagra and cialis together kamagra 4 tablets viagra funciona para las mujeres whats the street value of viagra viagra generika 50mg kaufen viagra wiki deutsch genuine viagra sale cheap meds no prescription cipro viagra 100mg ginkgo and viagra pharmacy viagra generic viagra online to australia viagra sale bristol PERSTRIPTION local viagra price viagra buy durban had a viagra party generic viagra free sample viagra suppliers ireland ginko viagra viagra overdose symptoms treatment viagra silden rx buy viagra san francisco dapoxetine for sale online viagra pps herbal viagra recipe best website to buy viagra what is cialis prescribed for viagra rectally buy super viagra online viagra kaufen paypal bezahlen viagra and adderall interaction sildenafil citrate 100mg- viagra buy generic viagra online with mastercard viagra effects on retina canadian viagra pharmacy online price of viagra at boots generic viagra mastercard where to buy flagl online without a perscription viagra in chicago edinburgh uk pages viagra find sites viagra overnight viagra and leaky heart valve viagra donde comprar sin receta does viagra increase libido viagra over the counter ontario nexium to buy online canadiangenericsstorecom cheap viagra super costo del viagra slovenia viagra pill sizes when was viagra released is online viagra genuine cialis in amsterdam viagra tablet size where to buy viagra boots viagra post radical prostatectomy ordering propecia online from canada generic viagra rite aid use viagra tab viagra online kaufen erfahrungen order viagra special offer viagra brand name in pakistan do young people take viagra viagra tablet splitting viagra for sale from canada sildenafil oral liquid viagra cause hypertension how to buy viagra from home generic viagra uk suppliers online viagra s trial packs viagra prescription dosage sex addiction and viagra how to get real viagra cheap viagra damage taking cialis when you don't need it 26 too young viagra buy viagra over the counter london price of levitra at walgreens viagra tablets images online physiacian prescriptions for viagra is 100mg viagra better than 50mg non prescription cialis viagra prescription renewal cialis prescription prices cheap online pill viagra is there real viagra cialis splitting pills buy viagra discreetly online tesco stores viagra viagra full name viagra 100 milligram healthy male bodybuilding pump with viagra buy cialis with priligy online buy viagra oklahoma inexpensive viagra many viagra prescription viagra and ischemic heart disease is viagra safe for men with high blood pressure can viagra maintain erection after ejaculation generic for ocuflox how to take viagra super active cialis cos'e' cheap viagra with dapoxetine aurogra vs viagra reload viagra viagra natural existe real viagra pills for sale cialis case study marketing effet secondaire de viagra gold max viagra uk clomid for women over 45 order cialis on line order viagra from india online viagra canadian pharmacy online long term side effects of kamagra cialis contraindications where can i get keflex w o rx and overnight order viagra online cheap tomar cialis es malo viagra made in usa kur perdoret viagra viagra for prisoners viagra sale cheap viagra online canada cialis 20mg erfahrung best online levitra female viagra in uk viagra and other medicines cheap priligy uk buy viagra cialis viagra high altitude pulmonary edema high blood pressure and viagra blue cross blue shield federal viagra pharmacy purchase viagra for paxil side effects viagra like medicine viagra falls 2 xxx generic viagra online pharmacy review viagra inconsistent results viagra second erection donde comprar viagra paraguay medcanadianex order viagra sample buy viagra pakistan lerk jet for sale compra cialis generisches viagra super active US Cilias cost of viagra at cvs viagra and ritalin viagra monograph nizagara vs viagra generic viagra and cialis can i buy viagra in pattaya garlic natural viagra natural viagra men viagra precio farmacia can i buy priligy at a store can i take viagra with low blood pressure plendil viagra viagra value card viagra femenino en farmacias del ahorro viagra target cialis czy viagra forum viagra pour femme pour homme generic viagra in san jose viagra sur internet avis does cialis thin your blood how to filter viagra spam kamagra oral jelly 100mg discount viagra drug viagra soft tabs directions viagra market price in india can buy viagra indonesia cialis ed viagra rht viagra substitute better cialis levitra viagra viagra femenino en mexico viagra 100 mg walgreens price when will generic viagra be available viagra costa rica will viagra go generic viagra cialis comparison buy cheap viagra pills online flagyl 500 mg viagra lethal dose asian girl in viagra commercial viagra ed emorroidi viagra for performance anxiety helps best price for real viagra purchase female viagra canadian top pharmacy cialis vs viagra cost buy clomid with debit card when cialis doesnt work viagra tongue buy viagra online in the usa viagra name best place buy viagra online the viagra spider sildenafil otc viagraca viagra online cost sildenefil dapoxetine viagra and young adults cialis 5 milligrams buy viagra online in singapore viagra by mail is there a generic viagra pill viagra rosada para mujeres apcalis kamagra oral jelly funny viagra comics viagra for babies with pulmonary hypertension tadalafil vs cialis que viagra es recomendable natural viagra at walmart generic viagra pills dth viagra viagra ersatzprodukte drugs should not taken viagra best over the counter viagra substitute difference between caverta viagra viagra headquarters canada natural viagra for women priligy in canada does viagra help after prostate surgery buy cialis philippines where to buy viagra pills viagra toung viagra quanto dura l'effetto que es viagra viagra patent wiki pfizer viagra results orlistat xenical buy online ordering viagra 100 mg does 5mg of cialis work free viagra woman online apotheke viagra ohne rezept efectos secundarios uso prolongado viagra viagra cialis trial pack female pink viagra online viagra apotheke teuer homemade viagra potion buy viagra pakistan where to buy generic viagra reviews over the counter viagra countries xenical roche buy online order viagra cheap remedio similar ao viagra Buy Azelastine Hcl Eye Drops blueberry 100 viagra review sildenafil and vision problems viagra online bestellen zonder recept prescription cialis on line generic viagra ok viagra over the counter nz where can i buy cialis in calgary viagra alternative hausmittel viagra kidney damage Canadian healthcare comprar cialis en farmacia sin receta comparativa viagra cialis y levitra levitra kullanici yorumlari where to purchase viagra generic viagra user reviews does bayer make viagra viagra and xannax any dangers buy viagra uk paypal cialis purchase buy sale viagra buy viagra in russia clonidine and viagra ordering real viagra online is it safe to buy generic viagra online viagra oral jelly viagra discount coupon chewable viagra buy zithromax raleigh nc clomid twins viagra and nitroglycerin viagra generico online españa will viagra make you bigger mega pharm norx viagra online sweden cheap s viagra purchase of viagra tablets viagra is addictive what does viagra do for healthy men cialis 5mg dosage Viagra Canada Pharmacy Scam joypox dapoxetine 60 mg viagra molecule viagra falls sarasota golden apple viagra side effects blood in urine candy viagra kamagra foro whats viagra compare viagra prices online buy generic valtrex no prescription overnight cheapest prices generic viagra viagra ne kosove generic viagra ranbaxy can you get viagra over the counter uk sildenafil grapefruit juice how do you take cialis viagra research funding climaxagen viagra quais são as contra indicações do viagra viagra antidoping viagra shirt viagra 100mg tablet price i need viagra viagra cialis hangisi female viagra nz buy viagra abroad kamagra fizz viagra online no prior prescription canada how to buy pfizer viagra online can women take cialis is generic viagra just as good herbal viagra pdf buy viagra alberta flagyl giving brown discharge viagra mumbai medical store viagra casero para mujer viagra liver damage viagra dapoxetine reviews which viagra substitutes are bogus and not effective free levitra sample pack buying viagra in vietnam natural viagra premature ejaculation l arginine viagra average cost of viagra how to properly take viagra viagra 100mg price in uae reaction du viagra sur une femme cialis drug name levitra tablets australia cialis generic best price viagra from canada cheap manufacturer of cialis generic viagra 50mg price viagra for young men quanto costa il viagra in italia buy viagra pills effet viagra pour femme viagra before and after tumblr buy cialis online legal generic viagra tab buy cialis usa where to buy viagra for the brain buy herbal viagra canada viagra shops london online cialis forum zithromax online receive fast Bystolic buy viagra now online generic cialis problems kamagra oral jelly srpski what's the cost of viagra priligy usa viagra emails from hotmail cialis female viagra viagra aerobic exercise ajanta viagra buy propecia online review cialis recommended dosage email virus with viagra link non prescription clopidogrel new zealand use of viagra in children effects viagra young women name of female viagra buy viagra pay by paypal brand viagra no prescriptionno prescription viagra wholesale canada viagra shop holland how do i get free samples of viagra viagra priser viagra trinidad lady viagra side effects furosemide purchase acheter du cialis pas cher cost viagra pharmacies viagra email virus viagra vs m force order viagra online without prescription ginkgo biloba natural viagra effets du viagra sur une femme cvs viagra price female sex viagra prednisone and diarrhea dachshund viagra harga viagra gold viagra mail order acheter viagra au canada effects of 150mg of viagra viagra te koop viagra & cialis juntos buy phentermine viagra online xanax viagra efecte adverse pfizer viagra køb cialis coupon card viagra thailand uso y abuso del viagra prednisone 10 mg online viagra user sildenafil cheap uk buy viagra online china viagra order low cost generic cialis overnight xanax buy viagra patent expiration in canada prix du viagra dans une pharmacie how does viagra make you feel buy viagra honolulu generic viagra review viagra society buy viagra online belgium generico de viagra canada buy accutane paypal cialis chez la femme viagra u.s.a. side affects viagra comprar cialis generico contrareembolso positive effects of cialis viagra generic name viagra apotheke wien cialis yahoo cialis online pharmacy without prescription do you need a prescription for viagra in usa free herbal viagra samples prednisone 20mg dosage viagra natural china epinephrine after viagra overdose buy female viagra uk effects of 150mg of viagra cialis v viagra scary movie 4 viagra italiano renova online amitriptyline sale viagra and headache side effect indian pharmacy viagra viagra online viagra x cialis viva viagra slogan cialis increase testosterone cialis 10mg bestellen lasix order online paxil bipolar disorder why no generic viagra in us is it safe to order viagra online viagra tablets 25 mg herbal viagra stockists can we use viagra daily levitra potency viagra double scan buy generic viagra cheap sildenafil citrate over the counter buy zithromax online cheap no prescription and over night delivery is it safe to take cialis with lisinopril where can i purchase real viagra azithromycin 600 mg tablets sale viagra buyonline strattera online viagra bondage buy cialis now kamagra 100mg viagra generika viagra and raynaud's syndrome female viagra uk review cialis online canada buy viagra ilocano song does viagra keep you awake viagra cartoons cialis 20mg viagra aspirin remedio de pressao e viagra where to buy generic cycrin viagra pills for sale cheap buy hctz no prescription stop stop stop viagra mp3 download einnahme viagra antibiotika pfizer's viagra video viagra side effects list viagra soda otc viagra gnc tips menggunakan viagra viagra head office in canada snopes generisk cialis 20mg using cialis for the first time cialis com coupon can you buy viagra canada cheapest place to buy viagra subaction showcomments viagra start from online viagra pfizer canada viagra femenino cruz verde viagra and liver enzymes what is cialis tablets prednisone generic can cialis taken viagra natural herbs used as viagra levitrabuy levitra online buy viagra brampton jamaica viagra cialis necesita receta medica viagra on medicare pfizer viagra dosierung other alternatives to viagra is it ok to drink with soft tab cialis viagra grapefruitsaft cheap generic viagra 25mg levitra rezeptfrei what was viagra originally created for viagra su duracion prednisone buy online without rx viagra find sites computer search what happens if i take two viagra viagra safe prix du cialis en pharmacie en france cialis fever viagra inventor kamagra herbal viagra alternatives viagra how to tell viagra is counterfeit where to buy viagra without prescription how to write a prescription for cialis viagra price swallowing compilation of viagra viagra for sale in miami price viagra chemist viagra indications contraindications sildenafil efectos secundarios largo plazo viagra actress black viagra bei ms zithromax z-pak 250 mg oral tablet farmacia viagra sin receta penes con viagra on line cialis cheap online viagra viagra cialis buy safe paypal generic cialis 5mg daily will my gp prescribe viagra can i take more than one viagra in a day generico de viagra en farmacias no prescription viagra australia wal mart pharmacy viagra price cialis define viagra trial offer buy viagra in new york city what happens when women take viagra viagra efficacy citrate generic sildenafil viagra php comprar female cialis viagra 100 mg wirkungsdauer find viagra free sites computer search viagra man woman most effective viagra alternatives girl rides viagra cock viagra srbija prodaja viagra sublingual site viagra can i take priligy and viagra at the same time online drugstore viagra canadian viagra can you cut viagra pill half cialis ohne rezept viagra for an impotent america buy cheap viagra online canada viagra performance anxiety cb viagra kit viagra stay in body viagra before surgery eriacta vs viagra cheapest cialis ?„ generic viagra for sale whats the active ingrediant for viagra sildenafil 100mg sale cialis samples for physicians viagra laced beer cialis online with prescription where to buy womens viagra amlodipine with viagra viagra cost us medical levitra viagra alcahol levitra generika cheapest uk viagra get online prescriptions viagra get rid viagra junk mail cipro xr 500 mg gonorrhea qual'è il migliore il viagra o il cialis viagra storage instructions is it safe to buy cialis online from canada real viagra online 10 pills x10mg cialis köpa viagra på apoteket buying viagra online in the uk topcanadianpharmacy cialis 50mg pills cialis vyvanse viagra chemist nottingham anwendung von viagra blue cialis buy cialis for daily use canada pharmacy prednisone no prescription looking for legitamate site for erectile dysfunction medication viagra im laden kaufen buy cialis 2.5 viagra 25mg online icariin viagra Healthcare of canada pharmacy viagra for diabetes herbal viagra colchester viagra kaufen ohne rezept viagra online deals does viagra help recovery levitra female viagra side effects lasix water pill cheap viagra online free shipping viagra prix cialis price increase viagra dick viagra bleeding gums at what age do men start taking viagra plant used viagra free viagra female viagra images ecstasy and viagra does viagra cause headaches effects of viagra with alcohol viagara express viagra laced beer viagra pills walmart generic-levitra viagra online in uk advair diskus generic name metformin without prescription canada can u buy viagra over the counter in the uk viagra email subscribe levitra rezeptfrei deutschland viagra fast delivery uk viagra affiliate program fluconazole to buy viagra cost cvs viagra canada the viagra song lyrics vitamed viagra how much are viagra to buy viagra blindness lawsuit reacciones causa viagra film about viagra viagra psuedo replacement for cialis for sale online prednisone for sale online viagra online?trackid=sp-006 cialis vs viagra buy online viagra pill how it works effexor xr generic brand viagra prices canada augmentin goodrx viagra causes what chemical compound viagra tv ad 1999 when will viagra be a generic female enhancement liquid version viagra niagra Lamisil buy flomax online no prescription cialis ranbaxy viagra bob dole video viagra barata buy online us viagra how many deaths from viagra viagra ordering online one a day cialis can you buy generic viagra in the us buy viagra bali Propecia canada online buying cialis from canada free female viagra viagra and cialis combined PURCHASE DIFLUCAN AND NYSTATAN all day chemist viagra viagra blindness new viagra for women making viagra more effective viagra for women available in india viagra prescrizione medica glucophage generic name suggested retail price viagra generic viagra march 2012 buy discount viagra fast orgasms with viagra viagra de ke esta hecho taking viagra at 20 visual viagra viagra head office shrubs bob dole viagra duloxetine and viagra use viagra y no funciono is viagra available in saudi arabia how to buy viagra legally miss viagra generic dapoxetine online cialis blue vision picture effects of viagra viagra women flibanserin is there womens viagra orlistat slender 120mg buy cialis online mastercard viagra uso frequente viagra cost 50mg yohimbe vs viagra viagra grapefruit juice interaction who has the best price on levitra hydrochlorothiazide and cialis viagra venta online viagra russian group viagra song download levitra online overnight delivery dosages levitra order 50 mg viagra miss viagra 420 viagra vegetales negative effects of viagra fast acting viagra alternative research viagra is viagra really needed torrent viagra επιπτωσεις treatment viagra induced priapism viagra athletes viagria generic viagra sale viagra nasal spray buy viagra perth big love viagra blue online viagra gone wrong viagra natural y rapido generic cialis for daily use levitra o viagra mejor naughty viagra pics buying brand cialis viagra online sales canada viagra pills in dubai palm tree pollen viagra buy cheapest viagra online uk viagra generic when will be available viagra panic attacks express-scripts viagra viagra 50 mg sildenafil viagra drug insert buy viagra by phone price of viagra at walmart pharmacy video viagra drunk viagra surgery risk cheapest pharmacy for cialis edhelpbiz viagra lawsuit discount viagra and cialis where can buy viagra 20mg cialis cost custa viagra media where can i buy viagra chicago pfizer and viagra order cialis black viagra pill markings yang mei viagra guangzhou viagra dosage vs cialis viagra sex options cialis kaiser permanente what mg cialis female viagra drug video levitra uses kashish 100 what does viagra do to women how long does it take for viagra to work how to buy prednisone online cheap female viagra viagra naturel recette generic viagra side effects effect of viagra on women viagra in mexico over the counter buy viagra bali cialis how to use what is kamagra 100mg oral jelly viagra nogales where to buy viagra in oman viagra pill costume what foods act like viagra canadian drugs online viagra best online pharmacy for generic viagra viagra femenino venta viagra in new jersey viagra blog viagra stock symbol next day viagra sildalis where to buy sex during viagra brand name cialis cheap viagra commercials funny cialis 30 day trial Find cialis without prescription cialis pseudoephedrine first viagra can take half viagra tablet levitra for sale viagra super active plus 100 mg viagra in ayurveda is it legal to buy viagra online in the uk viagra pillen te koop mixing viagra and cialis viagra soft tablets how to order cialis online cymbalta and cialis viagra prodaja srbija non prescription viagra alternative australia problems with viagra does viagra last after ejaculation super kamagra does work cos e il viagra 2buy levitra online viagra finasteride 5mg no prescription australia what are natural viagra viagra for women in south africa viagra cialis dose canadian pharmacy products viagra viagra michigan over the counter form of viagra viagra 100mg tablets instructions movie about viagra drug rep xanax and prednisone dewey cox viagra buy levitra odt online watermelon viagra generic cialis viagra caverta buy online does 100mg viagra work lasix paypal australia viagra india buy search viagra viagra edinburgh pages prescription to viagra where can i buy lamisil pills buy viagra greece viagra ingredients in food cialis fakes levitra uputstvo cialis sinus congestion buy viagra victoria bc what dosage of viagra mixing alcohol and viagra yelp viagra viagra impact viagra tx for pulmonary hypertension canadian pharmacy chap vaiagra viagra caseiro how can i get a prescription for viagra gay viagra mulher over the counter viagra substitutes buy turkish viagra viagra australia price viagra rx rs ru trial 2 buy cialis pattaya strengths of viagra order generic viagra phone viagra and alcohol safe viagra natural substitute viagra raise blood pressure viagra for sale online in canada how long does 20mg cialis last original blue pill viagra can you use viagra every day viagra online purchases generic viagra pfizer viagra out of patent how effective is cialis 5mg kamagra oral jelly fake canadian non prescription viagra what does cialis do g postmessage viagra subject reply viagra sildenafil wirkung viagradeal viagra 100 mg comprar viagra uk rps over the counter viagra equivalent vega viagra cream korean ginseng and viagra buy propecia online uk saturday night live viagra viagra online legitimate natural foods like viagra metformin no prescription buy viagra online shop order herbal viagra and heart disease cheap viagra a online generic viagra viagra mail order pharmacy how much is one pill of viagra viagra for benefits of mixing coke and viagra viagra online bestellen test viagra en ligne au canada viagra dosage by weight generic viagra stories where to buy authentic viagra online viagra equivalent onset of viagra composicion viagra viagra generic available united states orlistat diet pills reviews neurontin mg viagara order viagra safely online viagra blood clots levitra originale generic viagra online reviews viagra bulk buy viagra made in australia viagra wie schnell wirkt es viagra online deutschland viagra zakup online viagra alternative gel lavitra or viagra canadian meds viagra valtrex uk viagra and ecstacy viagra how many mg womens viagra viagra results forum heart viagra viagra online india experiences with viagra viagra every day viagra generic samples viagra ocular side effects viagra pharmacy prices best canadian pills products cialis?521 Buy Champix Online Usa viagra in the porn industry do i have to have a prescription to buy viagra viagra mail order does viagra help man what is better cialis or viagra levitra overdose women snorting viagra how can i get viagra samples viagra supplies power v8 viagra where can you purchase viagra cialis climax search viagra viagra find edinburgh pages female viagra canadian pharmacy viagra alternative test viagra cold feet cialis super active plus viagra online natural buy viagra cheap in canada how to get free viagra pills cialis pills review viagra cerebral edema best cialis online reviews viagra taken with cialis how to get cialis for free viagra copyright buy cialis 20 mg online patent viagra viagra funny pictures viagra generic best price viagra active ingredient how long to take viagra before intercourse african viagra plants viagra cialis comparison cine poate folosi viagra viagra 100mg tablet low priced viagra viagra stories forum buy viagra online flipkart how much is viagra at walgreens viagra alternatives holland barrett viagra how old to buy viagra and similar products order generic viagra acheter viagra ligne andorre levitra and atenolol viagra online superdrug viagra priligy together viagra doses and effects viagra spontaneity viagra research history levitra and alchohol viagra wikipedia does viagra do if women take how many pills of viagra should i take purchase viagra in uk levitra tab 20mg buy isotretinoin online cheap viagra with varicocele when should i take levitra free trial of viagra does viagra give you a hard on viagra rate india comprare viagra pagamento alla consegna canadian viagra pills erfahrung mit cialis generika horse viagra rite aid viagra prices its drug store edinburgh viagra search pages good che cose il cialis why isnt my viagra working buy viagra online free shipping viagra prescription cost cheap cialis uk suppliers viagra prescription doctor side effects to cialis levitra walmart impotence treatment online viagra viagra generic walmart where to buy viagra for women uk são efeitos viagra cialis or levitra or viagra viagra lasts a few days health shop cialis efectos de el viagra en jovenes good price on viagra tadalafil made in india cheap cialis generic canada ed pumps new viagra girl viagra venda no brasil cialis coupons for walmart medicine same viagra buying viagra in cyprus buying viagra bangalore viagra manufacturer pfizer buy bactrim online no prescription viagra slogan postfix viagra spam viagra cost in ireland viagra taking e street band viagra canada jual levitra di jakarta viagra fermato dogana freie alternative viagra viagra in the water mp3 prescription viagra written generic viagra / kamagra tablets online eczane viagra vern gosdin death cialis dosis muscle relaxers and viagra viagra spam email virus jack in the box viagra advertisement can viagra help psychological ed treating bph with cialis pharmacy price for viagra buspirone online uk taking viagra through us customs hentai viagra real brand name viagra cheap viagra online overnight shipping das grüne viagra viagra online billigt womenra - female viagra viagra maximum benefits cialis paypal payment non prescription drugs like viagra cialis online lloyds pharmacy viagra mg strength virus viagra ads viagra ojos rojos cheap generic viagra viagra dosage information vente de cialis en pharmacie viagra 12 filmtbl. 100 mg generic viagra teva canada buy viagra cialis or levitra viagra nyship 2007 buy cialis super active online uk buy cialis no prescription how to buy viagra legally remove viagra email virus where to buy generic viagra reviews zithromax online pharmacy can viagra cause a positive drug test viagra high bloodpressure how long does 100mg viagra last for salezhelp viagra for everyday use how long before cialis starts to work cialis fiyat listesi buy viagra while overseas cialis 40 mg viagra se necesita receta buy viagra in delhi viagra femenino colombia buy viagra nigeria getting prednisone online diflucan online no prescription viagra stop stop hd cialis side effects heart bob dole viagra ad how long after eating can you take viagra penis on viagra viagra medicine price viagra professional vs viagra super active can you buy viagra in saudi arabia seroquel no prescription needed canada Canadian Health Shop buy tegretol online no prescription viagra and stroke buy viagra nigeria cheapest generic cialis viagra falls band south bend indiana vaniqa cialis propecia remedio igual o viagra ebay cialis viagra wechselwirkungen viagra for people who don't need it cialis viagra together viagra and tinnitus cialis 5mg side effects buy viagra delhi viagra y congestion nasal best place to buy viagra uk viagra kinds viagra rosa pfizer viagra racial discrimination food supplements viagra cheap levitra online beli viagra dimana . viagra canada reviews cialis pct how does cialis wor viagra ou acheter forum buy viagra korea viagra tablets timing organic herbal viagra alternative viagra carvedilol interactions cytotec sale how long kamagra last viagra cialis levitra online rxmeds how long does viagra stay potent viagra bon marche will viagra help me ejaculate viagra quick viagra natural sin efectos secundarios england pharmacy cipro drugs stock order levitra online cheapest viagra anywhere viagra chest pain cialis xm radio cialis walgreens pharmacy quanto fa male viagra viagra delivered next day cialis 5mg uk best price on brand viagra cialis coupon free viagra rapid tabs reviews man dies from viagra overdose viagra effekt viagra experiences yahoo is viagra safe for diabetics viagra for female buy cialis paypal australia cialis directions 20 mg efecto viagra sandia propecia nz dunedin viagra from india buy cialis online from usa why do men need viagra purchase viagra on the internet viagra online india buy cialis 40 mg online viagra in india cash on delivery prednisone buy without perscription compare viagra or other substitute generic viagra patent viagra duracion de los efectos viagra malware email buy viagra without presc order viagra online. fast delivery female takes viagra buy viagra kamagra online buy cialis using paypal cheap rx cialis metformin india generic viagra overnight shipping viagra generico nombre canada cialis diabetes viagra nhs famvir generic cost viagra pills name in india prix viagra 50 milligrams uso de viagra hombres what is better cialis or viagra alternative to viagra natural viagra online canada with prescription girl in viagra commercial real viagra online buy buy viagra direct from pfizer effet viagra sur les femmes find cialis online can viagra damage the eyes peligros del uso del viagra woman taking viagra cialis nz viagra canada viagra online without prescription viagra leicester kamagra southampton canadian cialis online que es cialis y para que sirve message board viagra pregnancy on viagra real viagra substitute cialis athletic performance usa drugstore what was viagra originally developed for levitra generico no brasil brand name viagra buy where can i buy viagra manchester viagra men fastest generic viagra shipping viagra germany buying viagra from a chemist can i buy viagra online legally viagra laboratorio lilly price of levitra buy viagra internet what are the side effects of cialis myrx cialis how safe is buying cialis online do you need a prescription for viagra canadian cialis 5mg viagra rezept bestellen viagra for recreational use viagra brand online cialis levia and viagra xenical where to buy it generic viagra real or fake viagra how many hours before define viagra viagra getting a prescription orlistat online no prescription canadian drugstore female cialis vs male cialis cialis bulletin board how to get viagra from a doctor viagra pills buy online testimonials viagra inventor of viagra indian generic viagra reviews viagra available sweden staxyn online canada cytotec generico cialis search buy tadalafil cialis viagra kaiser a viagra for women viagra miracle drug buy cialis online yahoo answers viagra action video otc for viagra order kamagra online where can i buy viagra australia glace au viagra cheap generic viagra online canada viagra cialis quale meglio viagra prescription example buy viagra india sildenafil normon 100 mg female viagra bangalore viagra femenino venta en chile viagra bad stories get generic viagra online buying viagra canada viagra fast shipping h3n2 flu shot buy viagra northern ireland cheapest viagra price viagra online egypt target pharmacy viagra how young is too young for viagra can alcohol affect viagra using viagra in islam viagra turkey generic viagra by cipla buy viagra australia online how to use viagra spray video viagra pill clomid 50mg online pharmacy how does viagra cost buy cialis review generic viagra walmart pharmacy que edad es bueno tomar viagra cheapist non prescription viagra with dapoxetine online viagra online legal viagra professional review cialis veilig online bestellen buy viagra boots pharmacy certified pharmacy viagra os efeitos do viagra difference of levitra and viagra prednisone and lupus walmart pharmacy viagra cost buy cialis online without prescription penis on viagra how to spot fake kamagra cheap viagra online in canada non prescription prednisone prednisone without a prescription drugs money spent developing viagra viagra and migraines viagra online shopping india viagra manufacturer viagra stop lyrics viagra language online ritalin viagra paypal sporanox mg viagra france prix Generic Nizoral para que es la pastilla levitra online pharmacy uk cialis price of viagra in mexico viagra mano madrid one a day viagra viagra im alter viagra internal bleeding viagra car viagra online hrvatska where to buy viagra in east london cialis rx where to purchase viagra in india viagra sellers stoke on trent viagra falls newcastle band viagra spider banana watermelon and lemon juice viagra cialis super active 100mg prednisone withdrawal rash viagra 50 mg reviews trustedtablets levitra other uses tolerance for viagra buy viagra now online nitroglycerin viagra viagra without side effects acquistare viagra europa viagra stock taking viagra paxil viagra samples free mail what can you use instead of viagra viagra number viagra uk side effects viagra for sale perth Propecia buy now buy viagra in dublin ireland levitra from canada buy viagra uk shops drug viagra sildenafil viagra contraindicaciones buy pink viagra uk does taking half a viagra work viagra max impact viagra medicine price india viagra russische band wiki discount viagra cialis viagra gastroparesis viagra how long does it last with 100 mg viagra banned ads best use of viagra viagra and vodka viagra xlpharmacy canadian pills female women viagra viagra peak and duration buy generic cialis tadalafil kamagra posledice buy viagra fast delivery viagra in japan buy viagra from pharmacy buy viagra in store cos è female viagra flashback forum viagra viagra cialis mixen viagra dependency film sur le viagra viagra grapefruit side effects viagra india viagra de cuba topamax no prescription needed Status 365 Pill viagra 100 mg prices how to order cialis from canada cialis for daily use review safest way to buy cialis online get viagra como comprar viagra pela internet 1 7 8 aluminum hand railing cheap viagra 800mg impotence drugs since viagra can use viagra if dont need is viagra a prescription drug in france what works like viagra cheap cialis and viagra on cialis line viagra and group sex plavix without prescriptions le farmacie vendono il viagra senza ricetta viagra in canada color of viagra pills renova without perscription is cialis good for your heart viagra work viagra inventor wikipedia free trial viagra offer viagra approved in us viagra strengths mg advair diskus online using viagra with cialis viagra tablets in india online cialis suppliers uk can you take viagra extenze together cialis vs viagra reviews viagra shipped uk lowest price usa viagra cialis varicose veins using viagra without ed viagra online american pharmacy viagra cvs pharmacy viagra approved 1998 viagra generic cheep viagra by mail order from canada viagra a cialis viagra vs levitra vs cialis blue viagra does men can a women take male viagra viagra phosphodiesterase inhibitor sings viva viagra song v is for viagra the remixes puscifer viagra pills cheap online how often can someone take viagra how much is viagra in turkey buy viagra mumbai buy viagra in new york city what is maximum viagra dose viagra with women buying viagra with mastercard viagra alternative at walmart viagra prescription quebec viagra and cocaine 3 day cialis valtrex prescription online levitra 10mg viagra cartoons viagra generic date usa wie wirkt viagra bei gesunden viagra coupon code viagra age 30 viagra regular dose viagra buy from boise chinese viagra pills viagra canada office viagra 6 stunden cheap viagra mastercard why isnt viagra working ordering viagra from canada canada order viagra how to get free sample of viagra chinese viagra capsules source viagra cialis at walgreens generic form of viagra zithromax for sale online viagra efectos alcohol